×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

How to creating a proper engineering drawing?
5

How to creating a proper engineering drawing?

How to creating a proper engineering drawing?

(OP)
Hi, I have a new job where I need to take CAD models and create manufacturing drawings for the parts.

Are there any books that teach how to make a manufacturing drawing?  I have a copy of the ASME standards, but they don't teach how to make a "nice" manufacturing drawing.

I don't want to bother the senior engineers with my questions about what needs dimensioning and what needs GD&T...

Anyone know of any books or resources I can use to help me??

Thanks.

RE: How to creating a proper engineering drawing?

JimboJones21,

   Bother the senior engineers.

   If they want this thing done their way, they are going to have to help you.  They understand your company's requirements.  Hopefully, they have had the sense to talk to your fabricators, inspectors and assemblers, and there is knowledge to be passed on to you.

   There is no sympathy for know-it-alls who screw up.  

               JHG

RE: How to creating a proper engineering drawing?

Study existing drawings

Regards,

Mike

RE: How to creating a proper engineering drawing?

don't most CAD packages have a "print 2D drawings" option ?
 

RE: How to creating a proper engineering drawing?

Find a good, general text book to start with to get a foundation of why a good drawing looks as it does.  Something similar to those written by French & Vierck.  Used hardcovers are 32 cnts plus shipping on Amazon.  This will give you a foundation from which you can then study the various applicable standards.   

"Know the rules well, so you can break them effectively."
-Dalai Lama XIV

RE: How to creating a proper engineering drawing?

I would contact SolidWorks or AutoCAD and find out when and where they offer tutorial classes.  Might as well do it right, right from the start.  You can also find classes in the evening and weekends at your local technical college.  Heck, I've even seen some online through websites.  So there is no shortage of sources.

I would interprete "looks good" to mean "functional".  I only have one rule: if the machinist needs to stop the equipment, pull up an alternate source like the Machinist Handbook, ask a question or make a phone call, then the drawing has failed.  Tell the man what you want and not how to do it!

I've found some really excellent textbook references in antique book stores, some dated back to 1897.  I buy them just out of curiosity and see the history and development of the machining practice.  Some pretty amazing stuff.  Still, machines such as shapers and methods in hobbing gears are practical in today's age.  Old book stores would be another avenue you could investigate.

Good luck with it, stay focused on functionality of the print.

Regards,
Cockroach

RE: How to creating a proper engineering drawing?

Solidworks/Autodesk do NOT offer classed on how to make "proper drawings".

You bother the senior engineers..You study the companies existing drawings. You need to at least know design intent from the engineers. How the heck are you supposed to know what tolerances need to be applied/where,etc.. (hopefully this is in the models already..it should be)
You need to know how the parts will be made so you can put the correct information on the parts.   

RE: How to creating a proper engineering drawing?

Creating industry/coporate standard drawings and "...questions about what needs dimensioning and what needs GD&T..." are two entirely different things.

For the first, as suggested, review existing drawings.  Chances are you will find an existing drawing that covers something new.  Get to understand what the general notes mean, why they were used.  Talk with those that will build from your drawing, get their input in case you need to add clarification. Rise, repeat.

For the second, you'll have to pick senior brains, no way around it, unless you designed it yourself.  The application of proper GD&T is covered in forum1103: Drafting Standards, GD&T & Tolerance Analysis.

"Art without engineering is dreaming; Engineering without art is calculating."


Have you read FAQ731-376: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies to make the best use of these Forums?

RE: How to creating a proper engineering drawing?

3
Drawings need to completely and unambiguously define the geometry of a part.

To accomplish that, every feature needs to be located in three dimensions.

So step 1 is make sure that every feature is fully located.

The dimensioning and tolerancing scheme required has to do with how the part need to function.

[simplified example]If the relative location of two features is important, then the distance between them should be directly dimensioned, don't dimension them both to an unimportant feature just because it's easier to draw.[/simplified example]

So step 2 is understand how the part needs to function.

Drawings should define what you need.  Not how to make it.  However, it sure is useful to understand how things can be, and are likely to be made.

So step 3, go talk to machinists - good ones.  If you don't have machinists, at least try to find a good estimator who understands how things are made.

Modern CAD tools all have "dimension shot guns".  At the click of a mouse you can very easily scatter random dimensions over the entire drawing.  This will result in a really crappy drawing.

RE: How to creating a proper engineering drawing?

Drafting software does not a drafter make.

"Know the rules well, so you can break them effectively."
-Dalai Lama XIV

RE: How to creating a proper engineering drawing?

sorry, but are we talking about designing or about drafting ?

RE: How to creating a proper engineering drawing?

"proper engineering drawing" seemed like drafting to me.
Models already exist and the OP takes them and makes drawings, thus I think it is safe to say that drafting does apply.

"Know the rules well, so you can break them effectively."
-Dalai Lama XIV

RE: How to creating a proper engineering drawing?

Think in your mind "what information do I need to make this part?" This is how you make a good drawing for manufacturing and then have the seniors check your work for awhile so they can point out things that only experience can teach you. As others have said look at some of the other existing manufacturing drawings and try to see what they did and try to think about the "why" of each dimension and call out.  

RE: How to creating a proper engineering drawing?

I would suggest go to a local institute for a drafting program that can put you on a fast track or get private lessons from an academy instructor, otherwise, you may not have that job for long.  Also explain to your boss of what you are doing.

RE: How to creating a proper engineering drawing?

i thought it was a drafting question, too ... but he got a bunch of what seemed to me to be design answers.

and we should note his field, electrical, so he probably hasn't had much drafting instruction (if mech's get that these days).

GD&T would be a good place to start.

RE: How to creating a proper engineering drawing?

Yeah agreed. Seems to be more design related answers than "drafting". Sure hope that doesn't answer the question!

Regards,
Cockroach

RE: How to creating a proper engineering drawing?

You should be able to correctly project views, extract details, understand differing line weights and fonts and other basics (such as "dimension and extension lines should not cross), before you tackle more design oriented tasks, such as GD&T.

"Know the rules well, so you can break them effectively."
-Dalai Lama XIV

RE: How to creating a proper engineering drawing?

Well the OP seems to indicate a lack of knowledge about drafting practices.

RE: How to creating a proper engineering drawing?

"JimboJones21 (Electrical)"
I guess that says it all.

P.S.: I didn't know "OP" was used here.  

NX 7.5
Teamcenter 8

RE: How to creating a proper engineering drawing?

If you are asking for books that give guidance on creating clear and complete 2D drawings for people that don't have (or little) experience here are two that I've seen over the years. Though it's been to many years for me to admit since I last looked at either.

Technical Drawing by Frederick E. Giesecke, Alva E. Mitchell, Henry C. Spencer, Ivan L. Hill, John Thomas Dygdon, James E. Novak, Shawna Lockhart

Engineering Drawing And Design by Cecil Jensen, Jay Helsel, Dennis Short

HTH,
Dan

Han primo incensus

RE: How to creating a proper engineering drawing?

I'll assume you're working in the US to ASME standards.

First off, look at the relevant standards.

Not just Y14.5.  In fact I'd take a look at Y14.3 & Y14.24 before Y14.5 as they are more about drawing lay-out and how views are projected and what belongs on the drawings etc.  Maybe even take a look at Y14.2 & some of the other 'lesser' standards as well as Y14.100 itself.

Read the first few chapters of Y14.5, not the tricky GD&T stuff initially but chapter 1 & 2 especially which give more general ground rules & definitions etc..  Section 1.4 'Fundamental Rules' is especially something you should know almost by heart.

Ask the seniors if you have any company specific standards to follow, or at least examples to follow.  Try to find out who the real 'drafters' are as opposed to the engineers who half heartedly/grudgingly fudge it just enough to get by (most engineers will probably fall in this latter category from what I've seen) or the CAD monkies/jockeys that know what every button on the CAD does but can't create a decent drawing for the life of them.

If you are lucky enough to have a Checker, or at least a really senior drafter (or the rare engineer that really has a clue about drafting) who can spare the time to bleed (as in red pencil everywhere) all over your drawings then you are very fortunate - MAKE THE MOST OF IT.

forum1103: Drafting Standards, GD&T & Tolerance Analysis really is a good place than for this type of question as it covers most things drawing related - although there may be a few members there that tend to take things into the esoteric realm whenever possible

(And frankly, some of the suggestions above are laughable for "How to creating a proper engineering drawing" - many, perhaps even most, 'CAD Trainers' or standard CAD training courses from the CAD companies are more interested in 'what the software can do' than 'how you should use the software to create a good drawing'.  

As for the self generated drawings, it's a case of serious GIGO - if you're lucky - the automatically created drawings usually need serious tweaking unless you were really careful when creating the models.  Even then they usually mess up at least a few things.)

Posting guidelines FAQ731-376: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies http://eng-tips.com/market.cfm? (probably not aimed specifically at you)
What is Engineering anyway: FAQ1088-1484: In layman terms, what is "engineering"?

RE: How to creating a proper engineering drawing?

Exisiting and old drawings is a good place to get an idea of what the companny wants in a drawing and you can build from there..Cde and other texts can follow...And yes i am agreeing with the others...bother the Seniors..Thats what they are getting the big bucks for..!!!

RE: How to creating a proper engineering drawing?

Late to reply but I am curious. Are the drawings going to be used to manufacture the parts or just something to look at or put in a file cabinate? Depending on the complexity of the parts, the models can probably be used for programming in which accurate drawings may not be required. I know that may seem like a dumb question but if you are going to try and create manufacturing drawings for functional use, with absolutly no experience, you may not last long in that position. I have been a checker for many years in the automation industry and will go out on a thick limb here and say it cannot be done. Man dude, what did you put on your resume to get that position? Good luck!.....Wait a minute...I just noticed the "Electrical" part of your post. Sorry about that. No problem then, just throw some dimensions on those panel boxes and call out the hole sizes. Locate everything from 2 common edges in each view, call out the hole sizes and quantity and the toolmaker will figute it out with no problem.

RE: How to creating a proper engineering drawing?

"dimension shot guns" - star to Mint for that one.

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources