×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Shed Structure Foundation Depth Hurricane Area [130 mph] Wind

Shed Structure Foundation Depth Hurricane Area [130 mph] Wind

Shed Structure Foundation Depth Hurricane Area [130 mph] Wind

(OP)
Hello:

Would like to know if any of you has any experience with structures in hurricane area [Southwest Florida]regarding Fla Building Code requirements for a foundation depth. I am thinking of overturning resistance or uplift forces. Walls to be 4" or 6" reinforced CMU. Owner wants to do only concrete slab on grade. Shed 10'x20'

Any thoughts appreciated.

Rarebug

RE: Shed Structure Foundation Depth Hurricane Area [130 mph] Wind

It depends on various items. The bottom line is it has to be designed not estimated. If you don't have the ability to design the structure I recommend you consult with a structural engineer.

RE: Shed Structure Foundation Depth Hurricane Area [130 mph] Wind

(OP)
Thats not a thought, maybe a egotist rant! Please disregard and move on to the next thread!

RE: Shed Structure Foundation Depth Hurricane Area [130 mph] Wind

RareBugRA,
I have to confess limited knowledge of the Florida code in particular (Ron are you out there?), but in general, a flat mat foundation might work as long as you check the 0.6D + W uplift combination and verify that the slab is stiff enough to account for loading on the portion that would participate in holding down the load bearing walls or columns.

A thin slab, getting pulled up by its edges, may not have enough dead weight tributary to the walls to work.  The amount of slab you use as tributary to the walls would depend on the slab stiffness.

General comments but I'd need to see the actual code language to help you any more than that.  Perhaps others out there - anyone?

 

RE: Shed Structure Foundation Depth Hurricane Area [130 mph] Wind

(OP)
Jae: thanks for your constructive comment. More than enough to work it out.

Regards!

RE: Shed Structure Foundation Depth Hurricane Area [130 mph] Wind

RareBugRA...agree with JAE on the technical.  Slab on grade with sufficient consideration for uplift/overturning should work fine.  In the event that the geometry of the building presents an issue with overturning, you can supplement the slab with tie-downs such as helical soil anchors; however, depending on where you are in south Florida, you might be sitting almost on "rock", so that might be ineffective.

The foundation/slab must also be designed for lateral bearing/movement.  This is to determine the minimum depth of the foundation, based on lateral sliding resistance.

As for the depth of foundation for vertical loads according to the Florida Building Code....for monolithic slab/foundation systems, the minimum depth is 12 inches....but you still have to check for sliding.

A 4-inch masonry wall might give you a bit of a problem under the wind loads in that area. You will be limited to a wall height of less than 7 feet for a 4" bearing wall.

Also, ...no need to be snarky. Ron9876 gave you good advice if you are not a structural engineer; and presumably you're not since you asked these questions.  We commonly get contractors asking such questions hoping to save some money....keep in mind that the building department will require signed/sealed drawings and in some cases, calculations.  For these reasons, Ron9876's comment was right on target.

Now be nice and apologize!

RE: Shed Structure Foundation Depth Hurricane Area [130 mph] Wind

(OP)
Thanks Ron forthe time you took to highlight these items. By the way, City in this jurisdiction does not require stamped plans not to mention calculations. They even have "standard" details for homeowners to reproduce at their discretion and  get easy permits. I find them questionable. It is tiny shed the subject structure.  Anyhow i do not believe used foul language but here it goes the apology If anybody was offended to keep the bytes cordial. I attended engineering school and will be sitting for PE examination this year but do not think i'll ever stop learning from fine people like you .Regards!  

RE: Shed Structure Foundation Depth Hurricane Area [130 mph] Wind

Thank you for that.  Best wishes for your exam.

Mike McCann
MMC Engineering
http://mmcengineering.tripod.com
 

RE: Shed Structure Foundation Depth Hurricane Area [130 mph] Wind

RareBugRA...good luck with the exam.

Didn't realize this was a residential shed.  Requirements are less for the slab edge.  Can do 8" depth for utility shed, particularly if less than 450 sf.  Still need to check for sliding, overturning and other high wind considerations.

Geez...now we have a municipality practicing engineering without a license!!

RE: Shed Structure Foundation Depth Hurricane Area [130 mph] Wind

Without knowing the exact dimensions of your building, roof pitch, importance factor and exposure, etc, etc - I would guess the uplift somewhere in the 15-20 psf range.

Design for that.

RE: Shed Structure Foundation Depth Hurricane Area [130 mph] Wind

I would also add that reinforcing a 6" CMU wall is difficult and reinforcing a 4" wall is near-impossible.

RE: Shed Structure Foundation Depth Hurricane Area [130 mph] Wind

Saw a lot of unreinforced 8" CMU laying on the ground in some of the videos and pictures of the devastation in Kentucky.

Mike McCann
MMC Engineering
http://mmcengineering.tripod.com
 

RE: Shed Structure Foundation Depth Hurricane Area [130 mph] Wind

I've done some work in Florida. It's not my wheelhouse, however. As a matter of fact I'm sitting in a hotel room in West Palm Beach right now.
But I think most failures occur well above the concrete slab, not within it. Or maybe the attachment to the slab. If concrete is good at nothing else, it provides a lot of mass for very little money. With enough reinforcing to activate the mass, you can at least move on to the next weak link. Run the overturning and sliding numbers and see what kind of slab you need. But I suspect that other things will control.

RE: Shed Structure Foundation Depth Hurricane Area [130 mph] Wind

(OP)
Jed:
Thanks for your valuable input!. Initially, I was exactly thinking on the sliding and overturning resistance, but was curious how the foundation depth component played in all these.

It would be worthless to figure out steel anchoring to the slab or foundation wall or detail the roofing attachment to the wall,and  have the building roll over altogeter, and I think the foundation depth plays an important role in both sliding and overturning resistance.

Thanks!

RE: Shed Structure Foundation Depth Hurricane Area [130 mph] Wind

A 4" reinforced block is usually impossible. A 6" reinforced wall can be a piece of cake with modern masonry units. Unfortunately, most of the 6" units made in Florida are not really produced for reinforced masonry because of the habit of using 8" thick old fashioned units. The 8" units there are "cookie cutter" designs without much regard to use.

Dick

Engineer and international traveler interested in construction techniques, problems and proper design.

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources