3/8" A325 Bolt??
3/8" A325 Bolt??
(OP)
I have a drawing that calls for a 3/8" x 1-1/2" lg hex head bolt w/nut. The associated materials drawing states that "Structural field connections are to be 'Friction Type' and are to be made with high strength bolts (ASTM-A325). ASTM-A325 does not cover smaller than 1/2". Would A354 be an acceptable equivalent if I have spec a 3/8" bolt?





RE: 3/8" A325 Bolt??
RE: 3/8" A325 Bolt??
RE: 3/8" A325 Bolt??
RE: 3/8" A325 Bolt??
RE: 3/8" A325 Bolt??
RE: 3/8" A325 Bolt??
RE: 3/8" A325 Bolt??
RE: 3/8" A325 Bolt??
RE: 3/8" A325 Bolt??
Although SAE bolts and ASTM bolt have identical strength equivalents I have been told they have differing modes of failure due the differences in brittleness.
ASTM bolts are ductile compared to SAE equivalents and will yield more when over-stressed before reaching ultimate failure.
I've been taught that ideally in a structural connection such as a steel building the connecting members will fail before your bolts, i.e. bolts prying through a the plate in a shear tab.
The combination of the two lends to a more subtle mode of failure versus an explosive failure of a bolt reaching its ultimate strength.
RE: 3/8" A325 Bolt??
Why can't 3/8" be a structural bolt? It all depends on the scale.
In the Meccano universe, No. 10 is a structural bolt ...
RE: 3/8" A325 Bolt??
The OPs drawing calls for an A325 bolt and that standard does not go that small; so he can't meet the print requirements. You can't have a 3/8" A325 because it isn't in the standard.
RE: 3/8" A325 Bolt??
stierman: you forced me to look this stuff up!
We agree that the tensile and yield minimums are the same betwee A325 and SAE gr 5 bolts.
ASTM A325 type 1 bolts are medium carbon, carbon/boron or low carbon steel, quenched and tempered. Elongation in 4D is 14% min and reduction in area is 35% min.
SAE J429 grade 5 is typically paired with ASTM A449. These bolts are also medium carbon steel, quenched and tempered, with 14% min RA and 35% elongation.
The bolts would appear therefore to be identical except for dimensions, the A325 bolt having a shorter threaded length (i.e. better suited to use in shear connections) and a larger head (i.e. a "heavy hex" head).
Is there really a difference in the ductility of these fasteners?
RE: 3/8" A325 Bolt??
Note that what we're talking about is not substituting SAE gr 5 for A325 construction bolts at sizes 1/2" and larger. We're discussing whether it's necessary or even a good idea for people to substitute 1/2" bolts for 3/8" bolts in a design purely out of a concern over the properties of the bolt material between the two grades. I know the AISC manual doesn't deal with fasteners smaller than 1/2" and that the A325 spec also starts at 1/2", but that shouldn't stop people from using 3/8" bolts in structural applications where they're appropriate.