×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Is This Pump Motor Too Small?

Is This Pump Motor Too Small?

Is This Pump Motor Too Small?

(OP)
The pump is a submersible type with a design point of 139 gpm at 589 ft of head.  The purpose is pumping out a wastewater tank with worst case fluid properties of SG = 1.25 and viscosity = 3.0 cP.  It is designed to operate from 1' - 45' of submergence as measured from the bottom of the suction strainer (the lowest point of the pump).  Pump is custom-made for the application (nothing "off-the-shelf" available that met all design requirements) with a gearbox connecting the 1750 rpm motor to the 3600 rpm pump.

I have included the following:
-Motor manufacturer's data
-Pump manufacturer's curves
-Pump performance curve of assembled motor/pump (performance test conducted with water, SG = 1)
-Data from pump performance curve of assembled motor/pump & my calculation determining pump input power for a SG = 1.25 (I wasn't sure how to incorporate a viscosity of 3.0 cP)


 

RE: Is This Pump Motor Too Small?

It's a lot easier to check your calculations if you'd write the equations you used somewhere.  I don't really want to try to rebuild your spreadsheet.

Power with 1.25 SG will be 25% higher.  Viscosity of 3 doesn't matter for the pump, but could affect the head loss in attached piping. You don't tell us anything about that.

Without the attached piping, or details on elevations, it is not clear why you need 589 ft of head, but assuming you are pumping to that head, the power calculations appear correct at about 100 HP required.  If you don't really pump to that head, power required will vary linearly with head and with whatever flowrate you do get at the output head.

The pump's efficiency leaves a lot to be desired.

Normally you'd expect to see motor power capacity of 110% to 120% of what's needed, so that's marginal, but it should work at design flow and head.  Just don't try to change flowrates too fast, or plan on doing higher flow x head combination for more than 15 minutes.

From "BigInch's Extremely simple theory of everything."

RE: Is This Pump Motor Too Small?

(OP)
Thanks for answering my post, BigInch!

Top part of spreadsheet is from test with water with SG=1.  Bottom part of spreadsheet is me trying to calculate what motor requirement would be at test points if pump encountered fluid with SG=1.25.  The motor that was provided is a 100 HP 3-phase AC motor with a service factor of 1.00.  Spreadsheet breaks down as follows:

Pressure, flow, current and volts are all measurements from performance test.

Fluid power calculated by - flow*pressure*SG*2.31/3960   flow in units of gpm and pressure in units of psi

Input power calculated by - ((phase a current*phase a voltage)+(phase b current*phase b voltage)+(phase c current*phase c voltage))/746

Pump efficiency calculated by - fluid power/input power

RE: Is This Pump Motor Too Small?

So that's a wire to water efficiency.  Alright.  I usually get to see the pump hydraulic efficiency curve too. No problem.  Motor HP is marginal.  Normally a bit more HP is provided as a matter of course.

What about the piping.  Surely you have the 600 ft head for some reason.  It's not apparent why you need so much, if the pump is only 1 ft under a -45 low level., but I'll leave that reason to you.  You may however have to provide some backpressure to keep flow from running away, if for some reason the 600 some odd feet of head resistance is not provided.














 

From "BigInch's Extremely simple theory of everything."

RE: Is This Pump Motor Too Small?

Didn't you say there was a gearbox?? Don't forget to factor in the losses to the box. Get gearbox efficiency from manufacturer.

RE: Is This Pump Motor Too Small?

Wire to water, he's got gearbox inefficiency included already.  

From "BigInch's Extremely simple theory of everything."

RE: Is This Pump Motor Too Small?

aye,aye matey.

RE: Is This Pump Motor Too Small?

Your point of intersection between pump performance and system demand curves should somewhat higher in your linear graph since the system performance curve will be near or a quadratic form.

RE: Is This Pump Motor Too Small?

should read "....be near or at a quadratic form."  

RE: Is This Pump Motor Too Small?

Pump is a submersible type.
I'm familiar with grindex, flygt, toyo, dragflow and tsurimi submersible pumps curves and this curve is different to those.
This motor spreadsheet looks like reliance submersible motor.
If so, it will be very difficult for reliance submersible motor to be conected to gearbox.
Reliance submersible motor uses to work with some USA pump mfg.
In other hand , gearbox needs to be submersible too?
I see pump curve, and it seems to be a horizontal pump.
GE 1.25 is like 32% solids by weight assuming fine sand solids,
it is a high solids content.

Please confirm all data you sent.
 

RE: Is This Pump Motor Too Small?

(OP)
Chicopee,  the pump performance curve was generated from the company that the custom pump/motor combination is being purchased from.  The "system curve" on the pump performance curve is actually the power.  I think it is motor horsepower and not brake horsepower though the graph doesn't really say.

RE: Is This Pump Motor Too Small?

(OP)
PumpSmart,

Indeed, the motor is a Reliance submersible motor.  The pump is a Goulds.  They are connected via a gearbox.  All data included with original post is correct.

RE: Is This Pump Motor Too Small?

It is Brake power.  Motor HP is brake power.  Hydraulic, or sometimes, "water power" is what is used inside the pump.

From "BigInch's Extremely simple theory of everything."

RE: Is This Pump Motor Too Small?

jeffvd,
Reliace motors needs to have a minimun height of water for cooling.
Pump is LF3196 Horizontal Low Flow Pump - it is "NO submersible pump" and "NO handlings solids".
32% in solids by weight is a high number.
You need a slurry pump, low rpm, high chromium metallurgy.
So it is slurry fluid, if your pumpen 32% by weight of sand  d50, 100 mesh, fluid will be settling slurry type that means solids could settle on piping and plug.
So you have to calculate settling pipe velocity and derate pump performance for handling settling slurry.
You will use a Dragflow or Toyo pumps and in Goulds, you may use JC or HSU submersible heavy duty pumps.

I hope this helps

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources