×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Welding Filler Metals
3

Welding Filler Metals

Welding Filler Metals

(OP)
I have a WPS with the filler metal specification 4130, manufacture Techalloy, F-No. A & A-No. 11. Testing of this procedure had Charpy Impact testing at -20C. Is it acceptable for me to use filler metal from another manufacture other than Techalloy as long as the specification is 4130, F-No. A & A-No. 11?

RE: Welding Filler Metals

Yes.

RE: Welding Filler Metals

Dear Metengr:

I usually consider your answers simple, clear, concise and extremely pertinent.  This one is the finest yet.

Tom  

Thomas J. Walz
Carbide Processors, Inc.
www.carbideprocessors.com

Good engineering starts with a Grainger Catalog.    

RE: Welding Filler Metals

It is by code but I have often seen customers specification that indicates all procedures must use the same manufacturer for production welds as was used for the procedure testing. Check your contract documents.

RE: Welding Filler Metals

Why? There is no technical  rationasle and most suppliers would be forced out of business. This is why you have filler metal specifications.
 
 

RE: Welding Filler Metals

Why do users continue to use any trade names in specifications and purchasing documents?
We see it often, we will quote both of the options, the brand that they stated and a technical alternate.
This is what UNS numbers are for, to prevent these kinds of questions.

= = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = =
Plymouth Tube

RE: Welding Filler Metals

(OP)
I did find out that when welding using a DNV WPS in accordance with DNV-OS-C401, which I am, you only need to requalify a different brand if charpy testing was done below -20C or consumable classification is different. I test at -20C so I am ok to change brands.

RE: Welding Filler Metals

If only all welding consumables were the same!!!  Many oil and gas operators are very picky when it comes to consumable suppliers, with good reason:  they have suffered failures after the procedure was qualified with consumable supply from one location followed by supply of production welding consumables from another, particularly those forming local joint ventures in 'less restricted' parts of the world!!  And that's why DNV have it in their offshore structure fabrication specification only they don't go as far as to restrict the manufacturing location.

Steve Jones
Materials & Corrosion Engineer

http://www.linkedin.com/pub/8/83b/b04
 

RE: Welding Filler Metals

Understand. This is why you have customized welding consumable specifications, if applicable, and work closely with more than one supplier. Relying on one supplier can result in a similar trick bag where the welding consumables may not remain at a consistent quality level . There is no guarantee that one vendor is going to always meet welding consumable specifications.

RE: Welding Filler Metals

I find it somewhat difficult to believe that a filler metal designated as 4130 can meet A-11 analysis - 0.17% C max. and a 1.25 to 2.25% Mn range.

I must second Steve's comment. Not all manufacturers' filler metals trade designations for a given classification are created equal. I have experienced many such instances when trade name purchase changes provided unaceptable welds (X-ray quality) or welds with unacceptable mechanical properties. I have also seen these types of problems from the same manufacturer's trade designations manufactured at different locations.         

RE: Welding Filler Metals

(OP)
The problem that I am having is that the WPS that I am using and have used since 2005 is producing hard welds. With in the past six months it has been getting more frequent.  Our welds must meet NACE MR-0175, 237HBW max. Lately we have have been getting hardness in the high 200's HBW low 300's HBW.  We tried welding without our shielding gas bulk tank and used single bottles, which made no difference, then we verified that we were within our WPS parameters, heat input, and that has not made any difference. So that is way I am questioning filler metal quality.  

RE: Welding Filler Metals

Why are you trying to achieve hardness limits for H2S service when fabricating an offshore structure?

Steve Jones
Materials & Corrosion Engineer

http://www.linkedin.com/pub/8/83b/b04
 

RE: Welding Filler Metals

(OP)
We weld on Marine Drilling Riser, main tubes and auxiliary lines (Choke, Kill, Mud Boost and Hydraulic Lines).

RE: Welding Filler Metals

F number - A is a new one for me. Where does that come from?

 

Best regards - Al  

RE: Welding Filler Metals

(OP)
ASME Sec IX QW-442

RE: Welding Filler Metals

nadfourchon,
QW-442 is for A-Numbers - not F Nos; furthermore, the chemistry of 4130 low alloy steel does not meet the requirements for A No. 11, as I had previously stated.

RE: Welding Filler Metals

nadfourchon,
Also note that QW-404.4 states "A change from one F-Number in Table QW-432 to any other F-Number or to any other filler metal not listed in Table QW-432; the 4130 filler metal is not listed in Table QW-432.

Based on your own stated problems regarding hardness (strength/ductility) issues, it would appear axiomatic that you would qualify a procedure using a different manufacturer's 4130 filler metal.   

RE: Welding Filler Metals

Shouldn't you be using DNV-OS-F201/F101 for welding on drilling risers?

Steve Jones
Materials & Corrosion Engineer

http://www.linkedin.com/pub/8/83b/b04
 

RE: Welding Filler Metals

nadfourchon;
As I read more of this thread from others that have contributed good comments, it appears you have a very serious problem with how your filler metal was originally specified versus worrying about purchasing this same filler metal from another supplier.
There seems to be significant  confusion regarding the chemical composition of the filler metal, and if it was custom made to match 4130. Weld procedures can be qualified with coat hanger wire and as long as you have some specification or nominal composition and another supplier can provide their product to this specification you do not need to requalify the procedure. This is purely administrative.
Your problem as I now see it seems to be what you have in terms of actual welding consumables. If need be have this filler metal analyzed after welding bead on plate. You may be surprised as to what was supplied.
Welding 4130 can be done with several recognized filler metal specifications  from E 7018 to E8018 B2.  The selection of the filler metal is based on desired strength/hardness level.
 

RE: Welding Filler Metals

Any good welder will tell you that there is huge differences from one brand to another even though they both meet the same UNS and filler specifications. If the welder is confident with the electrode the end result is a lot better than if he is fighting with slag inclusions all the time. I do not mean to indicate the welder should dictate the brand but we often get three or four brands and test them all to determine which one is both cost effective and user friendly as well as meeting code requirements.  

RE: Welding Filler Metals

Why does confusion about trade names on welding procedures persist?  Because welding is something everybody knows a little about.  (But as they say, 'a little knowledge is a dangerous thing'.)  Too many amateurs out there writing inefficient or overly restrictive welding procedures.  

That said, there is often a difference between welding consumables, especially with covered electrode, in operability and properties.  But I have to say some criticism of products is generated by welders having a bad day.  ('It is a poor workman who blames his tools'.)  

A final saying (one I made up) is: 'when welding on alloy steels, don't always assume your filler metal composition needs to match that of the base metal'.  

I'm out of sayings at this point and will shut up.  
;)  
  

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources