×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Slab on grade design
2

Slab on grade design

Slab on grade design

(OP)
I am looking to design a slab on grade as a standard (non site specific) foundation. Does anyone have a good rule of thumb to use when little info is known?

RE: Slab on grade design

Just pour a bunch of concrete on the ground about 4'' thick and level it.

NO good answer to your question without better info esp concerning soils.  

Around here we use perimeter footings with SOG.  In parts of Texas I know they use post tensioned slabs.  

Need more info

RE: Slab on grade design

(OP)
Thanks Mike I need the slab to withstand a large aircraft rolling over it. Normally I design for worst case soils such as clay.

RE: Slab on grade design

designing a slab for a large aircraft is not something you want to do by rule of thumb. Get a geo tech to do some bore hole, use an approprate design referance to design the slab on ground. Depending on how big the aircraft and what part of the airport this slab is going, you will need to get hte loadings for the wheels either at landing or full of people.   

http://www.nceng.com.au/
"A safe structure will be the one whose weakest link is never overloaded by the greatest force to which the structure is subjected" Petroski 1992

RE: Slab on grade design

If you're doing non site specific design, I hope your company has good liability insurance... and be prepared to lose it.

RE: Slab on grade design

(OP)
I have the design loadings, but the foundation is meant to be used anywhere. Do you have a good reference in mind?

RE: Slab on grade design

Typically a 747 requires a minimum of 12''concrete but often going to something like 18'' but it depends on the soils.

Get some help on this one.  747's cost around $200 million PLUS!!!
There are worse things than clay!!

RE: Slab on grade design

(OP)
It is a foundation that has a 2% chance of a plane going onto it. It was previously sized up with a 6" slab. I was going to take a look at increasing the depth of the slab. Looking at previous designs we had from 30 years ago they just designed everything accounting for clay.   

RE: Slab on grade design

wow - that made me laugh really hard!  rule of thumb and oh, guess what, an airplane on it!

2% chance = if you don't design for it, it will DEFINITELY go there.  Take Mike's advice and get some help, using super-thick slabs.

RE: Slab on grade design

They use more than 6'' for simple interstate highways.  You really do need to get somebody who has experience in this area and a soils test.

Also - is the plane just going to taxi on it OR land on it.  TWO different loading conditions.

As slta said - if there is a 2% chance - I can almost guarantee you it will happen next week.!!!

RE: Slab on grade design

Mike,
"Just taxiing" is actually a more severe loading condition then landing.  Ends of runways and taxiways see more load than the part where there is uplift on the wings.

RE: Slab on grade design

(OP)
Thank you guys for your responses. This foundation would be located off of the runway not on a surface that sees traffic. I have been preaching soil tests. Problem is I work with mainly mechanical engineers.

RE: Slab on grade design

Is it a slab on grade or a foundation?  You have called it both.  If a foundation, what does it support?  If those mechanical engineers won't listen to you, let them do it themselves.

RE: Slab on grade design

just curious, what wheel load are you designing for?

RE: Slab on grade design

First of all, it sounds like you want to design a pavement, not just a slab on grade.  Further, it sounds like it might be an apron in front of a hangar or perhaps even a hanger floor slab.

If it is a pavement, design it as such.  You will need to know wheel loadings and load frequency.  For concrete you generally design so that the tensile stress at the bottom of the slab does not exceed 50% of the modulus of rupture of the concrete...then you don't have to worry too much about the number of load repetitions.


If it is a hangar slab, design everything but the integral footings as a pavement and then design the integral footings for the building loads...then tie the two together, considering lateral thrust resistance as well.

The US Army Corps of Engineers has some pretty good info on concrete pavement design for aircraft.

RE: Slab on grade design

hokie66 - I tend to agree with you BUT I have been on a few very hard "long" landings where the pilot simply "planted" the plane about half way down the runway and went to full engine reverse, spoilers and lots of brakes!!  I could almost hear the runway groan a few times.

As a matter of fact.  Hitler had the Autobahn built with very thick roadways that often were two or more miles dead straight.  Why - so they could use them as runways if necessary,

The USAF even explored that possibility after WW2.  My Dad was there and flying F-86s.  

You could surely land a lot of planes on I-70 in Kansas!!  

RE: Slab on grade design

You can land a 747 on most any highway in the US....you just can't do it repeatedly.

RE: Slab on grade design

Hokie66 - You describe "just taxiing" as a more severe case of loading than 'landing'... Is that official or just hearsay?

I am not familiar with the design of pavement slabs for aircraft wheel loadings, so I am just thinking it through... I agree that air speed over the wing generates uplift making the plane lighter - by this I can see how a plane 'taking off' would be less load than taxiing.
However considering a plane landing we are talking about initial dynamic impact, then under full brake with aileron + elevators creating down force to bring the plane to rest in short distance - Hard to imagine this loading condition is going to be less that a near stationary plane?
Thinking about a mass opposing gravity vs working with gravity, I would have thought that takeoff<taxi<landing?
 

RE: Slab on grade design

In general, hokie66 is correct about the taxiing loads being higher.  The initial impact of an aircraft on landing is often less than its taxiing load.  Further, the taxi loading often achieves an almost resonant quality...depending on the wheel pattern and the joint spacing.

Due to the elastic response of a rigid pavement, the forward speed of the aircraft lessens the load that the bottom of the pavement feels.

The next time you fly out, look at the pavement and you'll probably see more evidence of maintenance on the taxiways than the runways.

RE: Slab on grade design

keenaseng,
I don't know about official, but it is how I remember it being taught in my one airport engineering class.  The principal was that central areas of the runway, and I don't remember how much, could be designed for 75% of the loading seen by the ends and taxiways.  I have never been involved in the design of airfield pavements, so don't know if they are actually built that way today or not.

RE: Slab on grade design

Thanks Ron and Hokie66 - Interesting stuff.
I have felt the resonant quality you mentioned before whilst taxiing around and also noticed it by the deflection (or 'bouncing') of the wings. There would be a substantial saving in designing the central areas to 75% of loading due to the large area of a typical runway.

RE: Slab on grade design

I've done a bunch of 747 pavements, and there are some aircraft wheel configurations that will exceed 747's...

The Portland Cement Assoc. used to have a very good text on Aircraft pavements and I still use their airport program for designing slabs (mostly for rack loading).

Dik

RE: Slab on grade design

dik...for many years we analyzed pavements based on 727 loading, which I believe is higher than 747, because of the landing gear configuration.

hokie66...that is the keel section and you are correct.

RE: Slab on grade design

Check out PCASE to design pavements for aircraft loading.

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources