×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Steel construction problem, overhead crane rail
3

Steel construction problem, overhead crane rail

Steel construction problem, overhead crane rail

(OP)
We have some problems with the bolted connection in our steel construction. Due to the overhead cranes the construction is not static. Due to that fact there are some issues.
I would like to discuss these problems and even the correction on these issues.

It is a real challenge to find the right solution. We have some experts to look at it, but not very satisfying.


 
 

RE: Steel construction problem, overhead crane rail

I would love to have the details

RE: Steel construction problem, overhead crane rail

(OP)
We have found some loose bolts in the connections and some broken bolts. The 4 overhead cranes can move each 200 tons. We are afraid there is a principal fault in the detail construction. As we checked the calculations we did not find any clues.  

RE: Steel construction problem, overhead crane rail

You need to post some pictures and details, plus give more descriptive information here.  Too sketchy to give you what you need right now.

Mike McCann
MMC Engineering
http://mmcengineering.tripod.com
 

RE: Steel construction problem, overhead crane rail

Broken bolts are probably a bigger design problem than just cyclical loading.  Did the design consider the thrust and impact of the crane movement?  Properly installed bolts can loosen from vibration, but this is uncommon.  But if the bolts are elongating they are designed incorrectly.  There are simple installation steps that can help if nuts are loosening from vibration, such as double nuts, damaged threads, etc.  But, a bolt simply loaded in shear rarely loosens, even if loaded cyclically.  Yielding of the bolts is the best explanation of both your conditions, loosened and broken bolts.  Photos of the damaged bolts would be helpful.  Also photos of the connection.   

http://www.FerrellEngineering.com

RE: Steel construction problem, overhead crane rail

We do have some people on the forum with experience in industrial structures with travelling cranes, but there can be a myriad of problems.  Maybe if you can give a better description of where the failures are, or some photos, we could give some advice.  I am sure your "experts" have more information than you have given us.

For your education, you might have a read of the CISC Publication, "Crane Supporting Steel Structures: Design Guide" by MacCrimmon.  Also some of the publications by James Fisher.

RE: Steel construction problem, overhead crane rail

(OP)
I will upload some pictures and sketches tomorrow, Due to time difference 23:00hr local.
Thanks for the information so far.

RE: Steel construction problem, overhead crane rail

I suggest contacting CSD, they know what they're doing... heck, Fisher works part time for them...  http://www.csd-eng.com/



 

RE: Steel construction problem, overhead crane rail

I am very familiar with loose and broken bolts installed between crane runway girders and crane columns.  In fact, I recently repaired an old runway where the standard fix for years had been to retighten the loose bolts.  Cracks had formed in the ends of the girders starting in the webs and ripping horizontally due to the plastic hinge formed in the ends of the girder between the outside column flange and the inside bolts (think of the bolts prying down the end of the deflected girder).

Would like to see more info.

RE: Steel construction problem, overhead crane rail

A good place for your posting...

If you can show us a photo of the general arrangement of the column/girder/crane rail intersection as well as close up photos of the girder ends, bolt failures, and the general bearing of the girder end on the support, it would be appreciated.

The cause of the broken bolts sounds interesting... to others as well.

Dik

RE: Steel construction problem, overhead crane rail

(OP)
We have specified two problems
1. Broken bolt M30(fatique) connection of crane rail beam. We think the bolt takes forces due not calculated for. It is only calculated for shear. Due to crane movement it will have shear stress and tension stress.

2. Broken bolt M20(stress) connection support to crane rail beam. Due to bending an additional force other then shear will be applied.

For details see attachment

RE: Steel construction problem, overhead crane rail

I think both are fatigue related.  So many variables.  Could even be the flatness tolerance of the crane beam bottom flange.  If its not flat you start putting cycles on the bolts.

At 200T, I would not have detailed it this way.  Look into AIST and CISC manuals, but definitely get an engineer out there who specializes in crane runways..

RE: Steel construction problem, overhead crane rail

2
For 200T+ cranes, continuous spans are going to cause significant problems due to reversal of stresses and the need for plastic hinging to accommodate the deflections from the moving load.  Although the hinge zone is often small, because the loads are many cycles, this small area of overstress will eventually embrittle the steel.  

Whether the failure is in the bolts, the girder webs, or the connection welds, this is a problem that will be chased from one maintenance issue to the next.  For example, the problem is currently identified in 2 failed bolts.  Repairs for broken bolts include: reaming the holes and installing larger diameters, using higher performing bolts, extending the connection plate and installing more bolts.  Strengthening the bolts means the overstress will shift from the bolts to either the girder or the connection welds.

By the way, make sure all of your bolts are installed slip critical.  

RE: Steel construction problem, overhead crane rail

(OP)
Thank you all for your input. Does anyone have a collegea or associate in Europa whom I could invite to discuss the details.
Prefarable The Netherlands, Germany or Belgium.
Your answers tell me that we where on the wright track. We just need to
find the wright man(specialist) for the job.

Many thanks
John

RE: Steel construction problem, overhead crane rail

Agree with Teguci that the continuity of the runway is the main issue, and will continue to provide maintenance problems.  This will need frequent periodic inspection.  I won't presume to get in the way of your engineers, but the solution to your Problem 2 may be as simple as removing those bolts outside the cap plate which are subject to prying forces and provide little benefit.  This is based on the assumption that the crane runway longitudinal braking forces are resisted by bracing rather than by frame action.

RE: Steel construction problem, overhead crane rail

(OP)
Your are correct with problem 2, we suggested the same. The structural engineer is checking the calculations. We thougt that only the bolt in the support are sufficient. I have some doubts, why the bolts have been broken. We are substituting the bolts which have been broken including the once in the same connection. We need to investigate all these bolts.
The structural engineer is working for same firm who fabricated the construction. We need to have an independent specialist, who is not biased in any way. We are talking about serious injuries if something goes wrong.

RE: Steel construction problem, overhead crane rail

Good decision to retain an independent industrial structures engineer, and good luck.

RE: Steel construction problem, overhead crane rail

Teguci-

"by the way, make sure all of your bolts are installed slip critical"

Why is this the first option of some many designers?

Is it for pretension reasons? Pretension and SC are not the same.

I have dealt with many crane runway issues over the years and sometimes thought that slip critical joints were part of the problem; not the solution.

In particular, if one is using slip critical connections in a girder to column cap connection in a setting where thermal expansion is a MAJOR issue....do you design these connections for these astronomical thermal forces (+/- 100 degree F in a day)?
If you are using SC bolts in a long span runway girder how do you account for the expansion of a runway girder especially if the bracing scheme for the building does not lend itself to proper thermal expansion (seen this many times)? If the girder has to move thermally and the columns are restrained, something has to give.

I have seen 3" thick column cap plates broken almost completely  from the columns on 300 Ton crane runways.



 

RE: Steel construction problem, overhead crane rail

also....its well documented that any kind of fixed end girder on a crane runway is a bad idea. The fatigue problems be come obvious after studying a few examples.  

RE: Steel construction problem, overhead crane rail

Toad,
Thicker cap plates are more likely to crack than thin ones, far more material is yielding for a given rotation.  Thinner, more flexible, is better so it goes along for the ride without yielding.

You want the bolts pretensioned so that the two faying surfaces are drawn together so that the passage of the crane doesn't force them together and cause stress cycles on the bolt.

RE: Steel construction problem, overhead crane rail

johg,
I would include the bolts themselves as suspects in your investigation.  Bolt quality can vary widely, particularly from some of the Chinese manufacturers.  There may be problems with bolts from other locations as well, but the Chinese bolts are the ones I know about.

RE: Steel construction problem, overhead crane rail

We call all recite the words of Fisher from Design Guide 7.
It is not the be all & end all document on design of crane buildings particularly when dealing with very large OTC's IMO; and particularly when dealing with thermal issues.

Bottom line in these buildings is something has to give. So you must design to allow for movement. Making flexible cap plates may be one way to achieve this but that comes with problems as well.

These buildings need to be designed with intimate knowledge of the cranes themselves. They are an extension of that machine. Reading design guides is not enough.  

RE: Steel construction problem, overhead crane rail

Are the bolts failing by yielding (suggests a strength issue) or in a brittle manner (suggests a material/fatigue problem).

Have you checked any other connections for problems?  We've done a lot of inspections of buildings with cranes hung from the roof trusses, and it's rare that we DON'T find loose bolts all over the place.

In the most recent building we looked at, we arranged for all the bolts at key locations to be checked and tightened until some permanent remedial works are carried out.  Since that has been done, crane breakdowns have reduced significantly.  Might just be a coincidence smile


 

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources