Camber by welding
Camber by welding
(OP)
Is it feasible to generate a 5% camber (height of curve vs length, ie 100" length and 5" height) in a 3" Sq 1/8" wall 6061-T6 aluminum tube, by welding beads along the side inside the camber? The idea is, the welds would distort the tube into an acceptable curve. This is proposed to make a mild large radius curve without heavy machinery. I have no idea if such a thing would work. Residual stresses may be an issue, since the welded side will be in tension.
Any thoughts or ideas would be appreciated.
Any thoughts or ideas would be appreciated.





RE: Camber by welding
If that isn't a concern, then yes, the residual stress introduced by welding will act in tension and camber will result.
Best regards - Al
RE: Camber by welding
RE: Camber by welding
rmw
RE: Camber by welding
RE: Camber by welding
RE: Camber by welding
http://bending.net/structural-bending.html
They might send you on to someone who does do aluminum.
Michael.
Timing has a lot to do with the outcome of a rain dance.
RE: Camber by welding
I don't think your weld concept works.
h = R - sqrt(R^2 - 0.25L^2) (you can work this out)
where h=height, L=length, and R=bend+radius. I am guessing R=252".
h = 252in - sqrt((252in)^2 - 0.25×(100in)^2) = 5.010in.
252in is close enough.
From my mechanics of materials book by E.P. Popov...
1/ρ = M/EI, where ρ is the bend radius, which I am calling R.
M = EI/R.
For your 3"×1/8 square tube I=1.98in^4.
For aluminium, E = 10×10^6lb/in^2.
M = (10×10^6lb/in^2)(1.98in^4)/(252in) = 79000lb.in.
Stress σ = My/I = (79000lb.in)*(3in/2) / (1.98in^4) = 59000lb/in^2
For aluminium 6061-T6, σy=40ksi. σu=45ksi. As noted above, aluminium 6061-T6 is heat treated, prior to you welding it.
You cannot elastically bend your 100" tube mechanically by 5".
I remember doing the experiment in college, where we applied a weld bead to one side of a piece of steel and we measured the resulting deflection. It bent into a circle. Aluminium is a better heat conductor. I have a hard time visualizing this one.
RE: Camber by welding
The camber for the length is excessive and would be difficult to accomplish with welds. Besides, welding on aluminum, as gtaw noted, will significantly reduce the allowable stress.
I would roll it.
RE: Camber by welding
Any bender that can bend a 3"x1/8" aluminum angle "the hard way" can probably do it, maybe even a big mechanical bender. E.g. Hossfeld.
Some kind of flanged roller on the bender might be enough to prevent the walls from bulging out. If they bulge in, you are screwed, unless you prefilled the tube with sand and plugged the ends.
Mike Halloran
Pembroke Pines, FL, USA
RE: Camber by welding
I have had the best luck filling with either salt or pitch (rosin) instead of sand. I find that sand compresses too much and I still get some collapse of the tube.
RE: Camber by welding
Taking another tack on forming a shallow camber in a square aluminum tube with minimum machinery. What would the prospects be, for making a series of small narrow linear indentations across one side the tube, to form a chamber in incremental steps. Obviously making a big dent the tube would crush it and make a kink. Would a series of carefully controlled smaller indentations make a suitable incremental camber?
RE: Camber by welding
It can be done, however at 5" in 100", you are pushing the limits of formability.
You would still need to pack the tube and use a distance limiting stop.
I would recommend putting the bottom supports 18" to 24" apart.
And leave at least that much waste on each end of the bar.
B.E.
The good engineer does not need to memorize every formula; he just needs to know where he can find them when he needs them. Old professor
RE: Camber by welding
Basically, if you use a punch to plastically deform the inner wall at intervals, you can get a pretty extreme overall camber. The punch impressions effectively shorten the inner wall. The punch, in this case I'd guess 2" square with a somewhat rounded nose and maybe rounded corners, _partially_ buckles the inner edges, so they get shorter overall, and bingo, there's your curvature.
Mike Halloran
Pembroke Pines, FL, USA
RE: Camber by welding
RE: Camber by welding
You had better have lots of scrap pieces, because this is very much a trial and error method.
I do not think at 0.01" to 0.02" depth you will get what you want.
You may have to go to 0.04" to 0.05" . with some flaring on the sides of the tube.
An alternative to sand, rosin, or salt in the tube is greased strips of sheet metal to pack it out.
Your best bet is to find somebody with an angle iron roller And get it done outside.
B.E.
The good engineer does not need to memorize every formula; he just needs to know where he can find them when he needs them. Old professor