×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Welding A Stainless Steel Manifold

Welding A Stainless Steel Manifold

Welding A Stainless Steel Manifold

(OP)
I am designing a stainless steel manifold like the one attached. I am however a little confused as how they made this. It appears they used a stainless steel pipe then welded some couplings onto it. In order to do this would you simply bore the holes in the pipe first to match the OD of the coupling then insert the coupling and weld? Or am I missing something?

RE: Welding A Stainless Steel Manifold

Quote:

In order to do this would you simply bore the holes in the pipe first to match the OD of the coupling then insert the coupling and weld?

Yes, most likely. These couplings look to be stubbed into the manifold or pipe run and GTAW welded. The external fillet welds were blend ground smooth, contoured and polished or plated (can't tell).
 

RE: Welding A Stainless Steel Manifold

(OP)
So you have a coupling sitting inside the pipe? So if you are to look down the pipe you would see the bottoms of all the couplings? What if you want smooth flow through this instead of hitting these couplings?

RE: Welding A Stainless Steel Manifold

The coupling can be stubbed in and flush with the ID pipe surface.

RE: Welding A Stainless Steel Manifold

(OP)
Sorry but, what does stubbed in mean.

RE: Welding A Stainless Steel Manifold

The picture is at a difficult angle to tell exactly how the branches have been made, but apart from weld on, there are at least two other methods that could be used: hot isostatic pressing and extruded branches.  The shaping of the crotch area and the lack of a joint further up the branch in the picture does suggest weld on.  The weld on approach will require creation of the hole, the other two methods create the hole during manufacture.

Steve Jones
Materials & Corrosion Engineer

http://www.linkedin.com/pub/8/83b/b04
 

RE: Welding A Stainless Steel Manifold

A better term for 'stubbed in' is 'set in', which is where the hole in the manifold/header is large enough for the branch pipe/coupling to be set into the header.  The weld takes place between the ID and the OD of the header pipe.

The other method is 'set on', where the hole in the header matches the ID of the branch pipe/coupling and the weld is all on the OD of the header.

RE: Welding A Stainless Steel Manifold

(OP)
I would imagine the set in would be easier however if flow is of concern through the header you would get a lot more turbulence running down the header because of hitting the ends of the coupling

RE: Welding A Stainless Steel Manifold

Could the taps be welded into place first and then a bore run through them to open the connection?

Michael.
Timing has a lot to do with the outcome of a rain dance.

RE: Welding A Stainless Steel Manifold

Boring after welding is not "normal", but it is fully acceptable.

RE: Welding A Stainless Steel Manifold

If turbulence is really a concern, the manifold should be sized large enough so that the manifold velocity is very low.

I would also consider coping the nipples and beveling coped ends similar to a weldolet connection.

 

RE: Welding A Stainless Steel Manifold

There are several design alternatives to consider, but determining which is best requires some information such as:

What code is any is required or is applicable?
What is the design/operating pressure?
And what is the design/operating temperature?

The US Navy uses MIL-STD-22D as their standard for joint details. Many of the joint details for branch fittings involve welding the fitting to the run pipe and drilling the hole after the welding is completed.

If no code requirements need to be met, you could simply weld half couplings to the run pipe. Even if ASME B31.X is applicable, the diameter of the couplings and the run pipe must be considered. B31.3 for Normal and Category D for instance limit the coupling to 1/4 the run pipe diameter.

Whether the fitting is a CJP or a simple fillet weld is also dependent on code requirements if one applies.
  

Best regards - Al  

RE: Welding A Stainless Steel Manifold

Is it just the one you have to make?

Id be looking at casting it in stainless(polish it), or brass, and plating it, if it doesn't have to be stainless that is...

Its going to be tough to blend in the welds, and having it all look nice.

Depends on numbers though...

Brian,

RE: Welding A Stainless Steel Manifold

The pictured manifold comprises an apparently thick wall run pipe with a female thread counterbored into at least one end, and an array of half-nipples welded in and blended to a high polish finish.

<People, please respect the difference between nipples and couplings, and use the proper root word in discussion.>

The nipples do not appear to be extraordinarily thick, though it's hard to tell from the photo.  It's also possible that the female run thread is actually a thin half-coupling pressed rather deep into a thin wall run tube, welded around the coupling's outer circumference, with severely blended welds.  The female run thread's recessed position limits the sort of fittings that can properly mate; a typical hex nipple probably could not engage enough to seal properly before fouling the hex points.

Manifolds are much more commonly made with half-couplings instead of half-nipples, because the nipples' external threads are easily damaged in handling, and not so easily repaired.

I would conjecture that appearance and compactness of the next higher assembly is of paramount importance, that this part does not have a formal pressure rating, does not meet any code, accepts only a limited number of styles of mating parts, and may not even have a drawing, certainly not a proper one.
 

Mike Halloran
Pembroke Pines, FL, USA

RE: Welding A Stainless Steel Manifold

Many hydraulic cylinders use this type of port. The port is machined with a radius matching the barrel OD. The barrel has a hole predrilled for the port. This hole is used to locate the barrel in the welding fixture which is a circular spud welder with a cam following vertical slide. As the welder rotates the cam causes the weld gun to rise and fall matching the barrel OD.

The interior of the barrel will be deformed by the welding which may require resizing after welding the port on. Normally this is performed using a hone. Some manufacturers use pre-honed material and live with the weld distortion on the ID of the barrel.

You didn't say what type of material is flowing through this manifold but unless there is a very substantial flow rate the size of the ID versus the port sizes there shouldn't be much turbulence even with the fittings sticking into the flow stream.

I assume your biggest problem is the cost of the shown manifold. There is probably more cost associated with the finishing then the manufacture of the tube. The polishing will require substantial hand work and then an environmental unfriendly plating process. This part would not be a part I would recommend to in-source unless your company has experience with this type of part.  

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources