×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Beam Deformation Load

Beam Deformation Load

Beam Deformation Load

(OP)
If you have an A36 bar 1" wide and 1-1/2" deep.  29" long between a hinge and a pinned latch. What force is required to permanently deform the bar, in the strong axis, by 7/8" at the center?  The load is applied by a point at center span.

"Saving the World One Beam at a Time"

RE: Beam Deformation Load

Isn't this basic beam theory?  Delta = PL^3 / 48EI



 

RE: Beam Deformation Load

Delta = PL^3 / 48EI is the elastic deflection of a steel beam with a point load in the center.
For permanent deformation of the steel beam, the beam must go into the plastic zone at the center. Once there the steel will elongate at the tension face relaxing the elastic sections at the ends so they won't go plastic. Now how much deflection do you apply to get enough plastic deformed steel at the center to resist the elastic ends and the elastic steel in the center of the beam at the plastic section to have a certain amount of bending in the unloaded steel beam?
Unfortunately, I have neither the time or the data to work out the problem. I am sure that somebody somewhere has done it.

Garth Dreger PE - AZ Phoenix area
As EOR's we should take the responsibility to design our structures to support the components we allow in our design per that industry standards.

RE: Beam Deformation Load

Why didn't you do a web search?

Delta plus 7/8". It should spring back by delta when the load is removed.

I found a picture for you, page 2:
http://www.me.mtu.edu/~mavable/Book/Chap3.pdf

 

Michael.
Timing has a lot to do with the outcome of a rain dance.

RE: Beam Deformation Load

The key word in the question was "permanent".  Woodman has it.

Mike McCann
MMC Engineering

 

RE: Beam Deformation Load

Yes - I missed the "permanent" word as well.  That does make for a more difficult solution.
 

RE: Beam Deformation Load

Damn, I missed out specifying Delta. I meant to write:

Delta plus 7/8". Where Delta = PL^3 / 48EI. It should spring back by Delta when the load is removed leaving 7/8".

That didn't answer the question though, OP wanted the force.


Woodman isn't quite right, it does not have to go plastic all the way to the center. A thin layer will still be in the elastic range.

This cannot be calculated exactly without having the mill certs for the bar, yield stresses vary considerably from heat to heat.


 

Michael.
Timing has a lot to do with the outcome of a rain dance.

RE: Beam Deformation Load

You will not be able to calculate this accurately.
My guess is you are trying to manufacture some part.
You will likely need to do some test runs

RE: Beam Deformation Load

Sorry paddingtongreen, my part about "...and the elastic steel in the center of the beam at the plastic section..." was to imply that the center span section of the beam would have the lower (depth) part going plastic with the center and maybe upper (depth) part still in the elastic.

Garth Dreger PE - AZ Phoenix area
As EOR's we should take the responsibility to design our structures to support the components we allow in our design per that industry standards.

RE: Beam Deformation Load

i guess if you want to do this analytically you'll need NL FEA.

it's easy to calc the load to yield the beam's outer fiber; if you need precision, you'll need the yield of the bar (not of the material).  Part of the trouble is i don't think this starts to create permanent deformation of the bar (ie the bar will return to straight after unloading at a (slightly?) higher load 'cause the material around the yielded material can strain to accomodate the plastic deformation).

if you really need to know, then testing is an easy solution.

RE: Beam Deformation Load

Most steels have a safety factor of about 1.5 to 2

My guess is that based on all the loads described above - you will need to probably double it!!!  But as noted - testing will verify!!

RE: Beam Deformation Load

Everybody needs to think in terms of going back to the stress-strain curve for steel. The modulus of elasticity is the slope of the stress-strain curve. The modulus of elasticity is not constant for all stress ranges, and there are different stress at different points along the length of the bar,

Young's modulus is based on an idealized stress-strain diagram, and is not valid for stresses above yield, where you get into the calculation of tangent modulii. Think in terms of a bar with a varying modulus along most of it's length. Stresses would be in the elatics range only near the supports.

When all is said and done, I don't know how you would ever calculate such a problem. If you load steel to stresses beyond the proportional limit, then unload it, the response is essentially linearly elastic, parallel with the original slope line. When the load reaches zero, the permanent set can be measured along the strain axis. However, this tells you what's happening only at the point of maximum stress. Maybe somebody who remembers how integrate a curve could figure this out, but it's beyond me.

RE: Beam Deformation Load

It has to be done with NL FEA, and make sure to include material and geometric nonlinearity considering the length to depth ratio you are working with.

Or testing would be probably easier, as said above.

tg

RE: Beam Deformation Load

Non-linear FEA is probably the easisest way for someone who has a suitable package available and knows how to drive it, but it wouldn't be too hard to do this from first principles with a spreadsheet:

- Generate a moment-curvature diagram based on the best available information for the steel stress-strain curve.

- Use this to generate a force displacement diagram, based on standard beam bending theory.

- On this diagram plot a line starting at 7/8 in deflection, parallel to the initial straight line part of the curve.

- Find the intersection point, that is the force for 7/8 in plastic deflection.

This doesn't take geometric non-linearity into consideration, but for the proportions giving, and assuming the bar isn't restrained longitudinally, I don't think that will be very significant.

 

Doug Jenkins
Interactive Design Services
http://newtonexcelbach.wordpress.com/
 

RE: Beam Deformation Load

The force shall be large to yield the section, assuming the strain hardening curve is not ver steep:
Fy = PL/(bh^2/6) or P = Fybh^2/6L
For A36 realistic Fy=40-44 ksi
P = 44(1)1.5(1.5)/6/29 = 0.57 kips

Is it reasonable?

RE: Beam Deformation Load

It is really not a very difficult problem.  The bending moment is known in terms of the applied load, i.e. PL/4.  It is simply a matter of calculating how much load is required to produce plasticity in the beam which results in a total permanent deflection of 7/8".  It could be easily done iteratively.

BA

RE: Beam Deformation Load

i thought it'd become difficult when you start yielding a portion of the beam, which'll change it's stiffness, etc ...

and calc'ing deflection under load is also easy, calc'ing the permanent deflection (without load) seems to me to be quite a bit more work.  

how do you calc the perment kink/deflection in a beam ?  your beam has some "small" permanent strain, partially reacted by elastic strains  ...

RE: Beam Deformation Load

rb1957 - Calculate the total deflection and subtract the elastic deflection to get the plastic deflection.  To get the load for a specific plastic deflection you can do it graphically as I suggested, or iteratively as BA suggested.

 

Doug Jenkins
Interactive Design Services
http://newtonexcelbach.wordpress.com/
 

RE: Beam Deformation Load

Every thing every body says makes sense - but you won't know till you test it.

I have seen many beams, plates, etc sold as A36 but were really A50 when tested.  And many engineers will say that the change in Fb shouldn't make a difference - but it does!!

Trying to predict these things with any hint of accuracy is difficult!!

RE: Beam Deformation Load

"Trying to predict these things with any hint of accuracy is difficult!!"

Have you ever tried to explain to a manager why we have difficulty designing something to fail without having the actual mill certs and exact dimensions?

Michael.
Timing has a lot to do with the outcome of a rain dance.

RE: Beam Deformation Load


You can't really extend theory & design procedures exactly into practice.

I agree with Spats.

Maybe the OP can tell us why he is doing this?

If it is for the manufacture of some bent bars, like I said, you're going to have to test it anyway. Some of this theory may help you size whatever mechanism you are using to bend the bar, but that's about it.

RE: Beam Deformation Load

Quote:

You can't really extend theory & design procedures exactly into practice.

True, but that applies to everything.  The calculation isn't that hard, and given reasonably accurate material properties it will give reasonably accurate answers.  I don't see people here suggesting that calculating reinforced concrete deflections is too hard to bother with, even though there can be just as much variability with that as with this case.

Doug Jenkins
Interactive Design Services
http://newtonexcelbach.wordpress.com/
 

RE: Beam Deformation Load

I agree with Doug.  The calculation should be no less accurate than the stress-strain curve for the A36 bar.

BA

RE: Beam Deformation Load

This is just a cold forming operation caused by inelastic deformation, with the bar retaining some wished for deformed shape.  Any shop with a press brake, bulldozer or some such forming equip. can do this for you and tell you what force was required to achieve the 7/8" permanent deformation.  They will just keep applying more force, in steps, until they to achieve the desired result.  Maybe they could record the forces and permanent deformations, thus allowing you to draw a M/ or P/Delta curve for that bar.  Obviously, to start to approach this problem form the analytical standpoint, you must know the mechanical properties of the steel involved, and the shape of the/its stress-strain curve.  It's a little more complicated than just applying Delta = PL^3/48EI, because you are talking about a permanent deformation of 7/8," a little more than half the depth of the bar.  It is a fairly basic Structural Engineering problem/concept, unless the pinned latch and the hinge prevent one of the support points from moving/sliding along the length of the beam, as if on a roller.  But, it's not a simple or exact calculation process.  The deflection calc., Delta = PL^3/48EI is pretty straight forward until the extreme fibers start to yield; then the rate of change of deflection or localized rotation per unit of load applied starts to increasing, it's no longer linear, since the beam is starting to form a plastic hinge.  That's the NL part in NL-FEA, and I believe this is done in a stepwise fashion also.  It seems to me that over the years I've seen and done some calcs. and analysis methods which relate the formation of a plastic hinge to the moment and angular rotation of the yielding section of the member.  I think it was an internal work vs. external work or energy method we used.  The analytical difficulty is in this moment, angular rotation, approximation and then a conversion to a deflection, but I suspect this is the iterative approach BA was suggesting.  At best, it's still just a good approximation.    It's the locked in (residual) strain in the upper and lower quarter +/- of the bar's depth that causes/retains the permanent deformation or deflection.

In its simplest form, the way the steel responds is seen in Paddington's stress-strain curve (his 13DEC post and attachment) which shows this for a tension specimen.  The tension specimen is loaded beyond its yield strength and when unloaded from that point on the stress-strain curve.  It follows the same slope, as the virgin proportional limit slope,  back down to zero load (stress), hitting the stain axis at some residual strain or offset.  It is a bit more complicated for the bending specimen because the whole section is not loaded with a uniform stress, and then unloaded in a uniform stress manner.  And, once the outer fibers start yielding, the stress or strain are no longer linear about the neutral axis.  After the unloading, there are residual compressive and tensile stresses near the top and bottom portions/fibers of the bar.

A number of the lower strength steels show a very distinct yield point and a long, almost horizontal yielding plateau (plastic region) before strain-hardening starts, and then their stress-strain curve slopes up to their tensile strength, and ASTM A36 is one of these.  Most of the higher strength alloyed steels and heat treated steels do not have a yield point as such, but rather they have a yield strength which is set at a .2% strain offset, and they go directly into a fairly long strain-hardening range on their stress-strain curve before reaching their tensile strength.  As long as the load step-up operation is done over a short period of time, to finally achieve the 7/8" permanent set, the bar continues to act within its original (virgin) stress-strain curve.  If the bar is allowed to age at room temp. for several days or age at a slightly elevated temp. for a shorter period of time it will exhibit a higher yield stress for any added deformation, and a higher tensile strength too, but a reduced ductility.  This is called strain aging.
 

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources