×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Temperature reduction in shaded versus unshaded area under the Sun
7

Temperature reduction in shaded versus unshaded area under the Sun

Temperature reduction in shaded versus unshaded area under the Sun

(OP)
The Steam for humidification of supply air is injected in the supply Air Duct by a standalone humidifier at the Roof that is open to the Sun.
The maximum ambient temperature for the electronic controls of this humidifier as specified by the manufacturer is 40C.
The ambient temperature at the location actually goes to above 52 degrees centigrade, therefore this humidifier must be housed in a shaded portion to bring down the temperature.
Would it be sufficient to simply enclose this humidifier in a non air conditioned but louvered steel enclosure as the means for reducing the temperature from 50 degrees to 40 degrees, or must some air conditioning be provided to bring the ambient temperature down? Would an insulation lining in the weather box (but without any air-conditioning or forced ventilation) be sufficient?
 

RE: Temperature reduction in shaded versus unshaded area under the Sun

I'm confused by your terminology.  Is the 52°C actually the "ambient" or the temperature within your box exposed to solar load?  If it's actually the air temperature of the environment, then shading will not drop the temperature, but even forced ventilation will at least increase the heat flow to mitigate the problem.

TTFN

FAQ731-376: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies
Chinese prisoner wins Nobel Peace Prize

RE: Temperature reduction in shaded versus unshaded area under the Sun

(OP)
The ambient temperature is the temperature outside of the box. The humidifier will be housed in a sheet metal box so that it will not be exposed directly to the Sun. The external (atmospheric) temperature outside of the box is 52 degrees celcius.
The concern is about the electronic control circuitry portion of the humdifier which should not be in more than 40 degrees temperature.
I am not sure whether putting the controls inside this metal enclosure alone will bring the outside air temperature to the required 40 degrees C or not.
 

RE: Temperature reduction in shaded versus unshaded area under the Sun

Basic thermodynamics....heat goes from the warmer place to the cooler place.

RE: Temperature reduction in shaded versus unshaded area under the Sun

solidspaces,

They're trying to say that your box temperature cannot fall below 52°C if the temperature outside is 52°C, unless you put an air conditioner in it.  Shade does not help.

 

Good on ya,

Goober Dave

Haven't see the forum policies?  Do so now: Forum Policies
 

RE: Temperature reduction in shaded versus unshaded area under the Sun

(OP)
When the ambient temperature is 52 Degrees C in unshaded atmosphere, what would be the approximate temperature at sea level, still air conditions under a shade? How can this be calculated or is this purely empirical?

RE: Temperature reduction in shaded versus unshaded area under the Sun

Definition of AMBIENT

: existing or present on all sides : encompassing


 

RE: Temperature reduction in shaded versus unshaded area under the Sun

The Carrier Design Manual reckons it is 5F cooler in the shade as compared to the ambient.The shade in this instance refers to the unconditioned space in a proper building and therefore will not apply to the shade created by a "metal enclosure".

I had to deal with a similar issue with variable speed drives on the roof exposed to the sun that were tripping out on high temperature days.Shielding with scraps of ducwork were tried and did not work.We ended up relocating them indoor.

Though the metal enclosure may cut out the radiant component for a while,it will get heated up above ambient in a while and will start radiating to the protected body as well probably worsening your situation.Maybe a black umbrella might work!

RE: Temperature reduction in shaded versus unshaded area under the Sun

I'll volunteer to confuse the issue some more:  if it can catch radiation from the sun in the day, it can radiate to the cold night sky as well, and the box can dip below ambient when it's dark and starry outside, IF the internal heat generation is not enough to overcome the external radiation.

Good basic heat tranfer lessons to be learned.  I suggest that solidspaces study them thoroughly.

 

Good on ya,

Goober Dave

Haven't see the forum policies?  Do so now: Forum Policies
 

RE: Temperature reduction in shaded versus unshaded area under the Sun

Although this may further compound the issue, you won't need the humidification equipment to operate unless it's winter, so your high ambient temperature limits might lose importance if the devices with the temperature limitations do not need to operate.

RE: Temperature reduction in shaded versus unshaded area under the Sun

(OP)
ChasBean 1 is correct in the general case, but we have low relative humidity (about 15-30%) all year round. So our Building management system monitors humidity and brings it in service regardless of the calendar season.

RE: Temperature reduction in shaded versus unshaded area under the Sun

"Would it be sufficient to simply enclose this humidifier in a non air conditioned but louvered steel enclosure as the means for reducing the temperature from 50 degrees to 40 degrees, or must some air conditioning be provided to bring the ambient temperature down? Would an insulation lining in the weather box (but without any air-conditioning or forced ventilation) be sufficient?
"
OK, try again

> No.  Shade will help keep the box temperature from EXCEEDING 52°C
> Yes.  You have air at 52°C.  You need AC to get down to 40°C
> That will make it infinitely worse.  The objective, to reiterate, is to reject heat from the electronics into an ambient of no greater than 40°C.  Insulation increases the thermal resistance.

 

TTFN

FAQ731-376: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies
Chinese prisoner wins Nobel Peace Prize

RE: Temperature reduction in shaded versus unshaded area under the Sun

2
What are the inside temperature and humidity requirements?  Unless they are both higher than normal, you shouldn't have to use the humidifier until outside temp is less than 98F, worst case.  Why can't the humidifier go inside?

RE: Temperature reduction in shaded versus unshaded area under the Sun

- Is this an exisiting system or in design stage?
- did you talk with manufucturer?
- use two termometers, one under the sun the other in sahded area and check the difference
- you said your box will be louvered, will you use a fan too or just two louvers?
- if maufucturer limit is 40C then you may be have choosen the wrong product,this product may be for in house use only.

RE: Temperature reduction in shaded versus unshaded area under the Sun

(OP)
The responses from IR STUFF, TYS90 AND 317069 and the others earlier on, provided the needed insights to address the problem at hand.
Thanks a lot to all who responded

RE: Temperature reduction in shaded versus unshaded area under the Sun

Should note that official temperatures are shaded temperatures.  Unshaded temperature will be higher due to direct radiation (ie solar radiation and from surroundings).  

Therefore proving a simple shading structure may not reduce the temperature below the ambient temperature of 52 degrees but will prevent the equipment from heating up above 52 degrees which is what would happen if is was not shaded and located in direct sunlight.

RE: Temperature reduction in shaded versus unshaded area under the Sun

"We have low relative humidity (about 15-30%) all year round" is meaningless without temperature. Look at the space. Say you want to maintain 20°C but you don't want RH to drop below 40%. If it's 37°C outside and the RH is only 15%, you still don't need to humidify because the dew point is above 6°C and the space will be at or above 40% RH. For the summer, in general, you shouldn't need humidifiers. Think in dew point and not %RH.

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources