×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

20W LED tube interchangeable with 20W fluorescent tube.
11

20W LED tube interchangeable with 20W fluorescent tube.

20W LED tube interchangeable with 20W fluorescent tube.

(OP)
Hello,

We want to put a 20W LED tube into a socket for a fluorescent tube with a high frequency, switch mode fluorescent ballast driver.

...we dont want to remove the fluorescent ballast as it would be inconvenient.

Are there any standard solutions for this?

-we still want it to be quite efficient, so dont want a linear driver to be added in for the LED current control...we want efficient switch mode current control of the LED current.


...Ultimately, we would like to design a 20W LED tube (containing auxiliary circuitry and converter , etc) which could run off ANY fluorescent ballast.
..that is, it should be able to run off either a 50Hz magnetic ballast, or any high frequency switch mode fluorescent ballast.

....do you know if standard solutions exist for this?  

RE: 20W LED tube interchangeable with 20W fluorescent tube.

When buildings throughout North America switched from 4-foot 40w tubes with magnetic ballasts to the newer 34w tubes with electronic ballast, they (obviously) switched out the ballasts. It only required a few minutes each.

LED tubes are available and run off AC power directly. Just remove the ballast and twist a few wire nuts.

Leaving the ballast installed, where who knows how much variability exists between various ballasts and how they might react, is not likely to be practical as a general solution.

Watcha up to now?

 

RE: 20W LED tube interchangeable with 20W fluorescent tube.

(OP)
Hi, Thanks, unfortunately i can't say too much as i signed a NDA.

I can  say that ripping out the fluorescent ballast is not convenient in this situation......it would be too expensive in this particular application.......

-not only that...but the customer doesnt really know if they want LED.......they'd like to try it , and if they dont like it, they'll go back to their fluorescents....so another reason to leave the fluorescent ballast in.

 

RE: 20W LED tube interchangeable with 20W fluorescent tube.

There are OTS LED 'tubes' that directly replace fluorescent bulbs.

Google "fluorescent led replacement" and you will get over 8 million hits.  Most of them plug right in and need no re-wiring. Have a ball.  

Keith Cress
kcress - http://www.flaminsystems.com

RE: 20W LED tube interchangeable with 20W fluorescent tube.

(OP)
Hi,
I have googled and found millions of LED tube lights.

...But all of these have their own specific LED Driver ballast.......

-none of the ones that i've found can run off any type of fluorescent ballast.

The manufacturers of fluorescent ballasts wont supply us with their fluorescent  ballast circuit diagrams, because they dont want us to put LED tubes into these ballasts outputs....so theres another problem for this task.

RE: 20W LED tube interchangeable with 20W fluorescent tube.

Then leave the ballast in place (physically) and wire around it. It's literally just a couple of minutes for the electrician and his trusty step ladder. They don't even bother killing the power as they shake ceiling tile dust all over your cubical.

You're looking for an extremely complicated and impractical solution to a non-problem.

On the other hand, if it's possible then it'll already have been done.

RE: 20W LED tube interchangeable with 20W fluorescent tube.

Hi Grigson,

Unless your new tube is like itsmoked advised, you may not get the results you want.  

The purpose of the fluorescent ballast (in my learnings) is to provide a high voltage to strike the lamp, then to provide a reactance (or electronic modulation) to keep the current at the design level after the lamp is struck.

That initial voltage spike may damage LED lamps that are not designed to handle it.

Good on ya,

Goober Dave

RE: 20W LED tube interchangeable with 20W fluorescent tube.

I'm not sure what the difficulty is.  Doesn't a ballast simply crank up the input voltage briefly during turn-on to get the fluorescent lamp's gas to ionize?  

So, wouldn't you just have essentially and overvoltage clamp to limit the voltage into the LED circuit?

TTFN

FAQ731-376: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies
Chinese prisoner wins Nobel Peace Prize

RE: 20W LED tube interchangeable with 20W fluorescent tube.

(OP)
.........the thing is, before a fluorescent tube has struck, it looks like an open circuit....and thats how the voltage builds up across its terminals at start-up.

So any LED replacement is going to have to look like an open at start-up, or else the fluorescent ballast controller will think that it never struck, so to speak.

but since we dont have any of the datasheets for any of the fluorescent ballast controllers, its going to be difficult to sort out.

I have been asked to do this job, but i am not sure if its just a plain bad idea....and i should state that?

.....Surely , i keep thinking, it'd  end up being cheaper to just rip out the fluorescnet ballast and put a LED driver in there?

...Though our sales people tell us the customer doesnt want this.

RE: 20W LED tube interchangeable with 20W fluorescent tube.

Making the thing look like an open is not a problem. There are able transistors that can easily take 300 - 400 V. Data sheets or measure the ballasts to see what they do can't be an issue either.

Still, if "sales" came up with this, I woudn't bother too much. Most likely a bad idea. Test the peddlers; ask them what the volume will be and how much money the company can make from this idea.  

Gunnar Englund
www.gke.org
--------------------------------------
Half full - Half empty? I don't mind. It's what in it that counts.

RE: 20W LED tube interchangeable with 20W fluorescent tube.

Certainly a salesman's dream.  Less light output for the same power because you now are doing two electrical conversions, but you can tell the customer he has high tech LED now.  Maintenance might be less.  Probably not if it ends up built a cheaply as the electronics in a compact fluorescent.

RE: 20W LED tube interchangeable with 20W fluorescent tube.

If this is intended as a universal field retrofit device, I don't see how it could be made practical. There are different types of fluorescent ballasts out there; instant start, rapid start, programmed start, as well as old magnetic ballasts and new electronic (SMPS) ballasts. Considering that most electronic ballasts ar firing at 20kHZ or higher vs older magnetic ballasts are at line frequency, do you think that will be a problem for your LED system?  

"Dear future generations: Please accept our apologies. We were rolling drunk on petroleum."
— Kilgore Trout (via Kurt Vonnegut)
  
For the best use of Eng-Tips, please click here -> FAQ731-376: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies  

RE: 20W LED tube interchangeable with 20W fluorescent tube.

(OP)
yes i do think the frequency differences will be a problem.

-but it is thought that we can put  a frequency detector into the LED tube, so it sees what frequency the particular ballast is giving, and then the LED tube configures itself to be able to work with that frequency.

RE: 20W LED tube interchangeable with 20W fluorescent tube.

With all of the checking you plan on doing, you're going to create an LED tube that costs $400 and no one will buy.  In onesies, LED T8 tubes can be had for <$100.  You're over-engineering for a market that is only in the mind of a salesman.

Dan - Owner
http://www.Hi-TecDesigns.com

RE: 20W LED tube interchangeable with 20W fluorescent tube.

Why do you need to get schematics from a ballast company? IRF has all kinds of reference circuits and designs for electronic ballasts available on their website. I'm sure some Googling can yield you other designs too.

I suspect you'd have to somewhat match the ballast loading of the fluorescent bulb with the LED replacement, which would ruin your energy savings.

All-in-all, it sounds like a poor idea. The one time extra cost of re-wiring would more than offset the cost of the more expensive bulb and the extra energy used by the extra circuits required and conversions being done.
 

RE: 20W LED tube interchangeable with 20W fluorescent tube.

Quote:

...one time extra cost of re-wiring...

Bypassing the ballast would only require an additional 5 minutes maximum; that's worst case. Even at $100 per hour (also worst case), it's about $8. More realistically, it'd be about $2 labor per fixture. So if the fixture contains two bulbs, then your budget for this feature is about $1 per bulb (at retail). The manufacturing budget for this feature is perhaps $0.25 per bulb. Otherwise, it's not economical. A longer term analysis only makes the business case worse.

It'd be different if bypassing a ballast was difficult. But it's not. The wiring is RIGHT THERE. Pop off the ballast cover, relocate a few wire nuts, pop the cover back on, and slap on a warning sticker ("LED Bulbs ONLY").

 

RE: 20W LED tube interchangeable with 20W fluorescent tube.

(OP)
VE1BLL: I am inclined to agree....bypassing would be a better idea than running led tube off a fluorescent ballast.

But i am now reckoning that its going to be best to just rip out the whole fluorescent ballast and put in a led driver.

There is an opinion that we can produce a LED tube which, in every way, electrically imitates a fluorescnet tube, and thus can be placed into any ballast that that fluorescent tube can be placed into.

Though i am inclined to agree with most of you that this is a non cost-effective solution.

By the way, out of interest, supposing the fluorescent ballasts were on several fleets of passenger aircraft.....i presume you would still say its not cost-effective.?

RE: 20W LED tube interchangeable with 20W fluorescent tube.

Aircraft modifications carry so much overhead that the cost of the equipment itself is typically buried in the second digit.

 

RE: 20W LED tube interchangeable with 20W fluorescent tube.

As I recall, flourescent ballasts also include an autotransformer (or electronic conversion) to change line voltage to a voltage suitable for a particular lamp design.  Voltage may be near line voltage, but likewise may not.  Also; flourescents, especially the high-output versions, want to be kept up to a given temperature for proper operation.  Fixtures designed for flourescents are not designed for the same heat transport and control needed for LEDs, which need to be kept as cool as possible.

RE: 20W LED tube interchangeable with 20W fluorescent tube.

(OP)
VE1BLL:

i appreciate aircraft mods are going to be expensive....but the fluorescent luminaires are in the cabin, so surely this is a cheap modification.....not like replacing the cockpit controls or the engines.

....But by mentioning the high cost, are you now saying that its not going to be cost-effective to remove the fluorescent ballasts?, and that we really should try and find a way of interfacing the LED light tube to all the types of fluorescent ballast?

RE: 20W LED tube interchangeable with 20W fluorescent tube.

The little detail that this project is perhaps intended for passenger aircraft was not revealed until just a few posts back. Of course it changes everything, making most of the discussion above a bit of a waste of time.

hammer

Way deep down inside each million dollar aircraft avionics modification you'll find several hours of 'actual' engineering work (no offense intended to all the *.*ilities folks that also perform extremely important work).

I suspect that the aircraft owners would prefer to have the ballasts removed to save weight, power, and improve reliability. Perhaps they can be replaced with dummies or PS with a "simple" (LOL) box swap - you won't find wire nuts on aircraft, the ballasts should be plugged in.

RE: 20W LED tube interchangeable with 20W fluorescent tube.

(OP)
I must admit, i thought, for example, removing  fluorescent ballasts from the  isle of a  passenger   aircraft and replacing them with  LED drivers is just a short, cheap job for a guy with a screw driver and a few other simple tools?

RE: 20W LED tube interchangeable with 20W fluorescent tube.

Is it just me, or do you keep taking on projects where there's no firm grasp on actual requirements, actual markets, etc.?

Dan - Owner
http://www.Hi-TecDesigns.com

RE: 20W LED tube interchangeable with 20W fluorescent tube.

The approach would be to create a driver (if the LED tube requires an external driver) that was "Form, Fit" compatible with the ballast. The third F (Function) would obviously differ.

The Airworthiness / Safety / Human Factors folks should rightfully object if the LED tube fits into the same sockets as the Flourescent tube....unless you followed the original proposal (that brings the other problems listed above).

The same consideration applies to your new Driver box; people will ask how you ensure that they won't get mixed up and what happens if they do get mixed up. This can require very careful analysis and may demand an extremely clever solution to solve the quandary.

Dan mentioned "requirements" (post just above). Oh. My. Gawd. This sort of project could easily call up a dozen thick specification documents, each with hundreds and hundreds of applicable requirements. Done correctly, it might require a dedicated DOORS SME working for hundreds and hundreds of hours to support PoC and formal Airworthiness. A full suite of qual tests can eat $100k.

PS: are you adhering to the NDA? hammer

RE: 20W LED tube interchangeable with 20W fluorescent tube.

(OP)
Well, somebody's doing it already.............

http://www.everled.com/led-lighting-products/everled-tr/

.....I cannot understand how they are managing to sell these.

-if they can sell these then they can sell ice to Eskimo's.

Now matter what the EverLED-TR is like, it can never be anywhere near as good as a LED tube with matching LED Driver.

...i notice in the instruction manual pdf doc, they ask customers to report "unusual operation" to them.

...if the overall product catches fire....who is liable i wonder?.....is it the fluorescent ballast manufacturer, or EverLED?

....I think i'm now going to go away and find a machine that converts beer into brandy....somebody must be doing  that somewhere too.

 

RE: 20W LED tube interchangeable with 20W fluorescent tube.

LED drivers are switching current drivers.  It's not hard to build one that takes in all the typical ballast outputs including striking spikes, rectifies it, and uses the result in the controller.

Keith Cress
kcress - http://www.flaminsystems.com

RE: 20W LED tube interchangeable with 20W fluorescent tube.

(OP)
I agree that the ballast output has to be rectified.

However, we cannot put a smoothing capacitor after the rectifier.....because.....

There is inrush  into such a storage capacitor at start-up...
..and we dont know what kind of current limiting the fluorescent ballast features.....in fact, we have no circuit details of the fluorescent ballast at all, because the fluorescent ballast companies dont  actively want us to put LED tubes in their fluorescent tube sockets.

..also, the nature of current draw into a rectifier/smoothing capacitor is in the form of spikes of current occurring at the peaks of the input voltage.
...this is not a viable load to put on the output of a fluorescent ballast...

...the load has to be pretty much the same as a fluorescent tube.....or basically look like a resistor.....

...so what is actually needed is a Power Factor Corrector type stage.....that is, a stage which will monitor the voltage at the ballast ouput and make the current proportional to it...

....this is not so easy as for a normal mains PFC controller, because the frequency at the output of the ballast is anywhere between 50Hz and 70KHz...depending on the ballast.

So you are looking at the first stage of your interface circuitry being a highly customised Power Factor Correction stage, almost certainly controlled by a DSP or high-end microcontroller.

The current feedback loop in a mains PFC stage is a couple of KHz.......it has to be much more than the line frequency.
-With a 70KHz fluorescent ballast, the current  feedback loop bandwidth will have to be much much higher than 70KHz.....that in itself makes the solution expensive.

We have already clocked up quite a few dollars for the solution so far, and we're nowhere near finished.....

....the PFC stage will just be able to shovel the energy to its output......and it will have to be a flyback PFC....because boost type PFC's don't isolate the output capacitor from the input...and the inrush problem rears its ugly head again.

After our flyback PFC stage, which is software controlled, we will then need another switching stage to provide the specific current regulation to the LEDs.

As you know, this is a lot of engineering effort for very little in return.
....the resulting "hybrid" ballast is going to be much poorer in performance than even the simplest and cheapest LED tube/LED Driver combination.

...What's more, the fluorescent ballast will, in time, fail.....and the customer will try and replace it......but they will find that its probably gone obselete......and then they'll be left with this  highly expensive LED tube, with all sorts of electronics in it, which is now useless to them.

It'd be much cheaper to simply unscrew the fluorescent ballast in the first place and put in a LED Driver.

After all, as mentioned, the  fluorescent ballast is going to fail anyway and need replacing, so why not simply replace it right away and put in a cheap simple LED Driver for the LED tube.

I think the EverLED product is for individual householders who want to dabble in  a LED product because it happens to tickle their fancy.

....i cannot see how this solution can  provide any kind of serious marketing solution for a corporation wanting to replace thousands of lighting fixtures....its not financially viable.

RE: 20W LED tube interchangeable with 20W fluorescent tube.

Quote (grigson):

It'd be much cheaper to simply unscrew the fluorescent ballast in the first place and put in a LED Driver.
Didn't we say that already?

Dan - Owner
http://www.Hi-TecDesigns.com

RE: 20W LED tube interchangeable with 20W fluorescent tube.

Hints for plug-compatible avionics:

1) The LED Driver module (assuming it's plug compatible with the existing aircraft wiring, replacing the ballast) has to be certified safe in case it's accidentally connected to a legacy fluorescent tube. This should be trivially easy.

2) The LED tube (assuming it's plug compatible with the existing sockets) has to be certified safe in case it's accidentally connected to the legacy ballast. It doesn't have to work, it just has to be safe in all respects. (It can even be damaged in these circumstances, but that's a very poor selling feature. Better if it's not damaged.)

3) One should also write up a 'white paper' to make sure that the aircraft wiring can handle the lower voltage and higher current. 20W is so low that this is not likely to be a problem, but it has to be proven and certified.
 

RE: 20W LED tube interchangeable with 20W fluorescent tube.

"....i cannot see how this solution can  provide any kind of serious marketing solution for a corporation wanting to replace thousands of lighting fixtures....its not financially viable."

While I agree that it is a horrible solution, don't dismiss the costs of re-lamping as a justification for replacement. A fixture with an iron ballast will last 40 years - my facility has hundreds of this vintage - but they are re-lamped every couple of years. Access is expensive because of the nature of the facility, so if that could be pushed out to an interval of, say, ten years then there would be a very worthwhile saving in labour costs. Breakdown replacement is even more expensive than planned re-lamping because of the one-off nature of the work.
  

----------------------------------
  
If we learn from our mistakes I'm getting a great education!
 

RE: 20W LED tube interchangeable with 20W fluorescent tube.

(OP)
I accept that your magnetic ballasts are going to last a long time..................

.....I am not really too convinced though, even in your case.

The fact is, a LED tube which runs off a LED driver, will be the longest lasting of all....and ultimately need least re-lamping......Supposing the LED ballast is inside the tube, then it will run cooler than the interface circuitry that gets used in EverLED-VE type products.....cooler running means longer lasting.

So taking a long term viewpoint....LED tubes with LED Drivers is the cheapest and best way......It ultimately means less re-lamping than for the "Fluorescent Ballast - LED tube"  option.

I accept your point if you are saying that your lamps are difficult to get to....but then again...in the long term...that just means its best for you to use "LED Tube - LED Driver"

The "Fluorescent Ballast - LED tube" option *appears* to be a short-termist option.....

...but then again....."Fluorescent Ballast - Fluorescent tube" is the ultimate short term option because fluorescent tubes are much cheaper.

So i am afraid i can see only one reason for the EverLED-VE LED tube light...........

-the sales people dont know how to properly explain the options to the customer, and the customer doesnt know what they're doing.......and its the company's money theyre spending, (not their own) so what the heck, just go out and buy EverLED-VE.


This doesnt denegrate the quality of the EverLED product as a product in its own right.....i am sure its a very good product at doing what it does (running leds off fluorescent ballasts)...
I am sure it has great market potential for individual homeowners who want to experiment.

RE: 20W LED tube interchangeable with 20W fluorescent tube.

(OP)
Hello,

I am still trying to discover if this product, the EverLED-VE LED light tube has passed UL or CE approval, or in fact, has it passed any approvals tests such as Safety and EMC related?

http://www.everled.com/led-lighting-products/everled-ve/


(as mentioned in previous threads, its a LED tube which runs off literally any kind of fluorescent ballast)

I have written to EverLED about this but get no reply.
There is no evidence of any approvals on the website.

RE: 20W LED tube interchangeable with 20W fluorescent tube.

What does it matter if it has UL/CE certification?  What are you trying to determine?

Dan - Owner
http://www.Hi-TecDesigns.com

RE: 20W LED tube interchangeable with 20W fluorescent tube.

In my experience, there is no approval when the company makes no mention of any kind of approval. Companies generally want everyone to know when they spent the cash and got a listing for a product.

There likely is no suitable UL standard to approve the product under. And yes, I know there are UL standards for lighting but there is likely nothing in any UL standard about a LED lamp running off a fluorescent ballast meaning UL can refuse to list it.
 

RE: 20W LED tube interchangeable with 20W fluorescent tube.

Companies will also proudly list all the approvals...

Even if they're still pending.
Even if they've simply "planned".
Even if they're infested with deviations.

 

RE: 20W LED tube interchangeable with 20W fluorescent tube.

(OP)
OK Thanks, I am trying to determine if its actually likely to be  possible to get such a product through any kind of EMC or Safety test.......and thus trying to work out if it is worthwhile for a company i worked for to actually consider designing one of these type of products.

 

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources