×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

motor starting problem with generator

motor starting problem with generator

motor starting problem with generator

(OP)
hi all
we have installed 130 kw motor with a star -delta starting system to be driven by 280 kva new generator.but when we test the motor with the gen-set . the  motor starts to run but the engine will stop running when the delta contactor closes.( with out the generator breaker tripping ),
the geset supplies only the motor no other load
the altitude here is around 2400 above see level.but i have seen on the generator manufacturer catalog it says it can work with the above stated rating without any deration for up to 3000m above see level.

is this the rating compatibility problem b/n the generator and the motor.
can it be adjusted without changing both machines.
best regards

RE: motor starting problem with generator

You'll never have good luck with an open transition wye-delta starter, don't bother trying to adjust it.  If you can convert it to closed transition, you'll do better.  You may well find your best results with across the line start.  If you can unload the motor for starting, you could direct connect it to the generator and start the motor by ramping up the generator.  No inrush at all.

RE: motor starting problem with generator

You could try using a soft starter, this will limit the voltage drop seen by the generator and will also reduce the stresses on the motor and load.

RE: motor starting problem with generator

May be 2 problems; one is control unit of diesel engine, it's not fast enough to allow such step load increasing. Check if you can adjust parameters of control unit (99% a PID regulator); second (or cumulative to first) is air density at 2400 altitude which is about 26% smaller than at sea level and may be a problem to assure enough compression for a cold diesel engine with high step load. Regarding manufacturer catalog derating, this may be true for nominal regime and with respect to maxim allowed engine temperature and not with respect to transient loads stability speed.

RE: motor starting problem with generator

What David said. A one-on-one direct connection: motor connected to generator right at the very start; the moment the generator builds up voltage the voltage goes straight to the motor. Motor spins as the generator speeds up. The same effect as a soft starter,IMO.

RE: motor starting problem with generator

Just going DOL may do the trick. If the motor slows down the generator, the UFRO function will reduce the voltage and ramp the voltage back up as the speed recovers.
Step #2 Direct connected DOL before starting the generator. This will probably work with a PMG generator. It may work with an output powered AVR.
Step #3 You may have to use a UPS to supply power to the AVR. Then the UFRO function may emulate the action of a VFD.
Note: If you have an AVR with common power and sense terminals you will have to change it out for an AVR with separate sense and power terminals.
TLA's:
AVR Automatic Voltage regulator.
DOL Direct On-Line.
PMG Permanent Magnet Generator (A small alternator which supplies power to the AVR.)
TLA Three Letter Acronym.
UFRO Under Frequency Roll Off.
UPS Un-interrupt-able Power Supply.
VFD Variable Frequency Drive.

Bill
--------------------
"Why not the best?"
Jimmy Carter

RE: motor starting problem with generator

(OP)
Dear all
thankyou so much for your fast and good answers.
based on your suggestions i have told the technicians there at the site to do some of the suggestion you gave me and
when we tried to increase the time on the timer we have found out the engine stops after the voltage and frequency drops before changing to delta ( within two or three seconds before the motor reaches its full speed while  it is on the star connection) i.e we were mistaken earlier to say the engine stops when the starter changes to delta.
I am going to the site in the remote area 500 km from where i am now,the day after tomorrow to check the last possible options and make the last decision
do you still think it is possible to adjust  the generator or the motor starter so that we can use the existing system?
or do we have to change the star delta starter with the solid state starter or vfd starter?can this starter work ?which one is better for this problem?
If this is not possible we are planning to change the generator which will be very expensive.
Based on you suggestion I will start the generator and the motor all together .with the star delta starter connected but with the generator starter  key as a starter first if it doesnt work. I will try it as DOL.
i will also try to adjust the AVR based on your suggestion
 
I would be glad to receive all the possible option which i can try at the site .
best regards

 

RE: motor starting problem with generator

As waross has said, it depends on what type of excitation system the genset has. If it has a PMG supplied AVR system you are in better luck than if the AVR and excitation system is supplied from the stator voltage which will be very low on start-up as the DOL connected motor looks like a short circuit as seen by the generator.

From the spec of the genset you should be able to go to the genset OEM to get info on how the excitation system works.  This should be done before going to the remote site.

Also what type of control system the genset has. "Catserveng" our resident genset expert may be able to give some expert advice if you know he OEM and model.

BTW what is the motor driving? Is this an unloaded start?

rasevskii  

RE: motor starting problem with generator

Check the engine controls of the generator. From your description it sounds as if the generator engine is stopping. If the engine controls have a low speed shutdown you may have to disable it.

Quote:

Based on you suggestion I will start the generator and the motor all together .with the star delta starter connected but with the generator starter  key as a starter first if it doesnt work. I will try it as DOL.
I didn't see that suggestion anywhere. Oh well.
You will have to have the star delta starter pulled in or blocked in mechanically. The controls may not work to pull it in electrically when the frequency and voltage are low as the generator ramps up.
I doubt that a soft start or a VFD will be suitable. The harmonics that they create often interact badly with the AVR.
Take a UPS, about 500 or 750 VA.
Arrange the star delta switch for DOL starting.
Supply the starter with the UPS.
Supply the AVR with the UPS.
Check that the genset does not have any low frequency shutdowns. Disable them for starting.
Check that the gen set does not have any circuits that disable the generator output until the generator comes up to speed. Disable them if need by.
With the motor direct connected to the gen set and the AVR powered by the UPS. Start the genset and the motor should start with it.
Is this a newer gen set? If the gen-set is more than 20 years old, the AVR may not have UFRO and you may have to fit a new AVR.
If the gen-set has a PMG, it may work but you may have to change to an output powered AVR.

Bill
--------------------
"Why not the best?"
Jimmy Carter

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources