×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

How do you calculate the force in a compression flange?
2

How do you calculate the force in a compression flange?

How do you calculate the force in a compression flange?

(OP)
How do you calculate the force in a compression flange based on the moment?

Hi,
 
I am trying to calculate how much force is in the compression flange of a portal column based on its moment. I have to design a torsional restraint (capable of withstanding 2.5% of the force of the compression flange). The angle of the tie from the compression flange to the restraining member is very accute and as such I am a little worried about the steel angles which have been added. Was thinking it would go something like this:
 
Calculate the Z vale of the compression flange only.
Divide the moment by the Z value to get a stress.
Multiply the cross sectional area by the stress. That should give me a maximum applied force.
Find the resultant force based on the angle of the tie.
Check the angle against the maximum force in compression to see if it passes.
 
Any help would be really appreciated.
 
Thanks!!!

RE: How do you calculate the force in a compression flange?

You could just be conservative and take the area of the compression flange and multiple by the yield stress.

RE: How do you calculate the force in a compression flange?

(OP)
Thanks TJ but I like the idea of working it out. Shows that I'm thinking about it. I'm pretty new to structural engineering so trying to be accurate.

Thanks again for the reply!
 

RE: How do you calculate the force in a compression flange?

just take the max compressive bending stress at the location of the brace + the max axial compressive stress and multiply by the area of the flange.
The stress in the flange wont vary greatly across the thickness.  

RE: How do you calculate the force in a compression flange?

or use the mid-thickness of the flange to calc the bending stress (rather than the extreme surface)

RE: How do you calculate the force in a compression flange?

(OP)
So would this be something like:

M=650kNm at brace
Area of compression flange= 4486mm^2
I=111444cm^4
Axial Force in Column=430kN

M/I=F
F*Area of compression flange=CF

CF*tan Angle=Compression Force the angle has to resist

I don't quite understand why you would require the compressive force of the column.

One another note if I was to be conservative and multiply the cross section of the flange and multiply with by the tensile capacity of the steel (fy=355N/mm^2) I would end up with a force of 1682kN *2.5=42kN?

Thanks for your help as always.


 

RE: How do you calculate the force in a compression flange?

(OP)
*2,5%

RE: How do you calculate the force in a compression flange?

(OP)
Sorry I've put the I value of the cross section, this should be the I vale of the rectangular flange only.

RE: How do you calculate the force in a compression flange?

Max compressive stress in the column at the brace:
P/A + Mc/I (or M/S)

Take this vale and multiply by the area of the flange.
This = the force in the flange.

Design your brace withstand 2.5% of this force.
 

RE: How do you calculate the force in a compression flange?

"CF" is the compression force in the flange due to bending, M.

the axial load is also compressing the flange (along with the rest of the section).

if you're designing the connection, ie what's the maximum load that could be in the flange, then using fty is conservative.  if you're designing the flange, the allowable will be less than this, due to buckling.

RE: How do you calculate the force in a compression flange?

(OP)
Thanks a bunch TJ, its really appreciated.

RE: How do you calculate the force in a compression flange?

The stress is M/S where M is moment and S is section modulus.

Multiply that with the flange width x flange thickness...

Dik

RE: How do you calculate the force in a compression flange?

if you want to take it a step further, use the force in the flange as calculated above as a horizontal force. Since your brace will be at an angle (presumably), do the statics and come up with the corresponding load in the brace ...it will be higher that the calculated force obviously.  

RE: How do you calculate the force in a compression flange?

Just use .025M/d as the force.  Close enough.

RE: How do you calculate the force in a compression flange?

Hokie - that's what I would do. M/depth of the beam is a close and still conservative compression and tension force.

RE: How do you calculate the force in a compression flange?

M*(distance of the flange centre to the neutral axis)/Ixx*0.025 if the member is pre yield. Area of flange*flange yield stress*0.025 if the section is post yield.

RE: How do you calculate the force in a compression flange?

asixth,
You left the area out of your first expression.

All,
So much ado about nothing.  Why does everybody seem to object to simplification?  Does anybody seriously see anything wrong with my approach?  Of course, this has to be resolved into a bracing force as the OP knows.

RE: How do you calculate the force in a compression flange?

Cheers hokie, stress*area gives a force. Nothing wrong with a simplification, but we can't carry too many simplifications into our calculations. Our clients are always concerned about cost so we need make designs efficient. Sometimes, like the calculations to justify to size of a fly brace can be typified. I would call up a 50*5EA at a 1H:1V angle with 1(no.)-12mm bolt for anything up to a 460UB and consider it a lateral restraint.  

RE: How do you calculate the force in a compression flange?

(OP)
Thanks to all for contributing. Like I had mentioned I'm relatively new to structural engineering however I always believe we should work to the actual values rather than approximations (is this not what load factors are for?). Personally I need to calculate these values as I don't have the bank of experience as most others do. As mentioned clients are keen to keep cost down, our duty as engineers should be to provide an economical design (both cost and environmental impact). I understand that the difference in calculating the compression forces exactly (see the second post by ToadJones) or using the cross section of the flange multiplied by the tensile strength (see the first post by ToadJones) won't make a huge difference but its good practise to get into. I don't think the most sensible thing to do is encourage graduate engineers to do approximate calcs, it should be on the button.

Thanks again to everyone who added to this thread.
 

RE: How do you calculate the force in a compression flange?

Just remember that our FIRST duty as engineers IS to provide a SAFE design.  If I need to be conservative and redundant in order to make me sleep better at night, you can bet I'm going to.  Just remember that real world engineering problems are often different than you encounter in school.  In school, the majority if the problem is handed to you and you usually just work out the math.  Now you are the one defining the paramaters of the problem, so a little conservatism goes a long way.  Additionally, if I can get an answer that is within 3% - 5% in 5 minutes or spend 45 minutes getting the "exact" answer, my time is better spent approximating.  

RE: How do you calculate the force in a compression flange?

one vote for hokie's method here. if you try to use actual values for everything you design, you may as well give up now and become an accountant. Most if not everything in structural engineering as an approximation somewhere along the line, even if you don't know about it. for example the code rules for buckling of the flange brace.  

How could you do anything so vicious? It was easy my dear, don't forget I spent two years as a building contractor. - Priscilla Presley & Ricardo Montalban
 

RE: How do you calculate the force in a compression flange?

I wanted to add to my above post.  Using reasonable and valid approximations is a good thing, as long as you understand to do the problem correctly, understand exactly what you're approximating and why, and make the determination that it is, in fact, reasonable and valid to do so.

As rowing notes above, almost everything in structural engineering is approximated on some level.

RE: How do you calculate the force in a compression flange?

Here's a quote you can take with you:

"If you understand why what you're doing works, you'll be much more effective at it!"

RE: How do you calculate the force in a compression flange?

The OP, refreshingly, wasn't asking for the answer, but rather the correct way to calculate the force.
I tried to oblige.
However, If I was designing a brace like this (and I have many times) I would use the yield stress of the steel in the calc.
You'll find after designing a few such braces that 2.5% equates to a very small, easy to accommodate, load.  

RE: How do you calculate the force in a compression flange?

You might also find that 2.5% might have nothing to do with what is actually required for bracing strength or just as important bracing stiffness - both of which should be calculated using AISC Appendix 6 for the particular situation in question.   

RE: How do you calculate the force in a compression flange?

(OP)
As TJ has mentioned I wanted to find out how to do it correctly and not just guesstimate. There is a correct way to approach the problem and that is what is I felt important.

Lion, I fully appreciate that it would take you much less time if you just approximated but for the sake of 10 minutes I now have an accurate answer, a method for carrying out this type of analysis, a better grasp of what value of the applied load I would need to start worrying about, etc.

Being conservative is one thing but actually knowing how to carry out the process correctly is far more important for a graduate engineer don't we all agree?

On that note I just want to post a thank you to TJ for his help.
 

RE: How do you calculate the force in a compression flange?

you may wan to look into WillisV's comment as well.  

RE: How do you calculate the force in a compression flange?

....although from you OP, it appears as if you are not using AISC codes.  

RE: How do you calculate the force in a compression flange?

I also agree with the calculation provided by Hokie66.  

If you have ever designed a moment connection, the force in the flange is M*12/(d-tf).  This calculation is littered throughout the AISC manuals.  So if it is not exact then why hasn't the AISC revised the calculation in all their design examples?  

RE: How do you calculate the force in a compression flange?

The OP is bracing a column, which will most likely also have axial load, ... axial compressive stress.  

RE: How do you calculate the force in a compression flange?

I would definitely do Hokie's method.  It there was also axial force in the column, I would divide that by the area of the whole section, multiply by the area of the flange, and add the result to M/D.  This method is really accurate enough.

I would not necessarily use the yield stress times the area of the flange because slenderness might have controlled the allowable compression in the column.

 

RE: How do you calculate the force in a compression flange?

if you're designing the connection using yield stress*area is conservative, 'cause the load can't be bigger than that.

using yield*area as an allowable can be unconservative if the flange has a lower crippling/buckling allowable.

if you're just getting started in the business, i think it's a good idea to calc the load the long way a couple of times to learn how conservative is the yield stress simplification and how much (or little) time it saves, and to be carfeul in applying it.

it might be a "clever" way to show the calc and then to use the higher yield stress load as a conservatism.

the long method, as pointed out above, is the combination of axial compression and bending stresses.

RE: How do you calculate the force in a compression flange?

Ozy001,
Not much of what we do has to do with "actual values".  For instance, the 2.5% used in your example is arbitrary, and could just as well be 3, 4, or 5.  Some codes differ in the amount of bracing required.

RE: How do you calculate the force in a compression flange?

(OP)
But it has come from somewhere, I mean someone didn't just wake up one day and decide that's the figure to use. As with all elements in codes they have been based on sound engineering knowledge, much more specialist than anyone here is involved.

There is a correct method of carrying out a calculation. That's important for a graduate, not just to quickly scoot around it and get a rough answer. I like facts, clear and in black and white. Even if the people responsible for writing the codes are completely wrong I am sure the insurers etc would be willing to accept that based on the code and through proper analysis my design was safe and proper.

Until I get to a stage where I am comfortable in my analysis I will always do the correct calculation to the button and not just approximate.
 

RE: How do you calculate the force in a compression flange?

I think the technical paper it was derived from by published by trahair. I'll try and find and post it when I get home. Keep going though, it's good that your eager and trying to learn.

RE: How do you calculate the force in a compression flange?

Ozy - Can you post a sketch showing your column and the loading on it? It would be interesting to see how the various methods work out.
 

RE: How do you calculate the force in a compression flange?

Ozy, don't write off the advice of those who seem to be simplifying the procedure.  In some cases, there is a reason to use M/d [or more precisely M/(d-tf)] to calculate the flange force resulting from the moment.  For moment connections where the flange connection is all that is being used to resist the moment, calculating the bending stress (M/S) and multiplying that stress by the flange area will result in a lower flange force than is actually there.  Also remember that despite your desire for learning the true theoretical approach, there is a lot to be learned from the practical recommendations of the gray-haired.

RE: How do you calculate the force in a compression flange?

(OP)
Nutte and all others, I really hope I havent come across dismissive. I really appreciate everyone's input, I've already learned lots by listening to your points of view and from now will try to get involved within these forums as they are a great place to bounce ideas around! I've been at Uni for a few years but I have learned more in 6 months working with the my team (engineers and technicians). I know that the best people to learn from are experienced engineers. My original post was how do I calculate and not how do I approximate, as I thought it best that as a very junior engineer this is something which I should be able to do to the Newton. If however through time I get a feel for the values I'll never carry out the calculation in it's entirety. I just like to know that I'm doing it the right way and not the roughly way.

Graybeach, I'll upload the sketch tomorrow as I'm out the office now.

Once the sketch is uploaded and the variables and unknows set I would really appreciate the clear and definitive approach to the problem.

Once again all your help and advice no matter how little or expansive is always appreciated (that gos for the oldies too lol)

RE: How do you calculate the force in a compression flange?

Ozy, as people have said its great that you want to learn for yourself and understand whats going on. I fully advocate doing the proper and "Accurate" calc a few times so you have a feel for the values.

However, once you have been out of university for a while, you will being to realise that the best engineer is not the one being the most accurate or carrying figures to 6 decimal places. The main things is always understanding all the simplifications you make, and ensuring a safe and logical load path for all applied loads.

I did my thesis under one of the authors of the Australian wind code. I called him up one day to ask him for advice on a condition not covered in the code. He said "handex, your guess is as good as mine. Just make a conservative approximation".

Once you get on site and see how a lot of things are done, you will realise that the following quote holds a lot of truth for engineering calculations (quoted from a user of these forums)..

"We tend to measure with a micrometer, mark it with a crayon, and cut it with an axe"
 

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources