×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Is the top beam helping?
2

Is the top beam helping?

Is the top beam helping?

(OP)
In the attached, the load is resting on a smaller beam.  Does the smaller beam actually assist the bigger beam by resisting the 500# to keep the deflection within the allowable 1/2"

If so then can it be said that at the 1/2" deflection only 1000# plus the wall weight is being transferred to the bottom beam?

RE: Is the top beam helping?

All I will say is that load is attracted to stiffness.

RE: Is the top beam helping?

The upper beam will help.  The upper beam will take Iu/(Iu+Il) of the load and the lower beam will take the remainder of the load.  Iu = I of the upper beam, Il = I of the lower beam.  

 

RE: Is the top beam helping?

(OP)
So the whole load will push the bigger beam beyond the allowed 1/2" deflection?  

RE: Is the top beam helping?

If the I's work out to exactly what you have (i.e. that I of the upper beam is 1/2 of I of the lower beam and they both deflect 1/2" under the assumed loading), then they will both deflect 1/2".   

RE: Is the top beam helping?

(OP)
Thanks Lion,

Is Iu/(Iu+Il) a constant regardless of the proportionate size of the two beams?

RE: Is the top beam helping?

if there is OSB or Plywood sheathing on the wall, everything changes.

RE: Is the top beam helping?

(OP)
Understood Toad.:) This is a hypothetical situation as shown...no other variables.

RE: Is the top beam helping?

This is assuming the beams are of the same material, so "E" is constant.  It also assumes that lateral buckling of either beam is not a governing factor.

Bottom line here is that your problem cannot be answered with any degree of certainty as it is not specific enough.

Mike McCann
MMC Engineering

 

RE: Is the top beam helping?

(OP)
E is a constant.  

RE: Is the top beam helping?

(OP)
Buckling is not a factor.

RE: Is the top beam helping?

Mike-
I don't think the capacity of the beams matters for the load distribution.  That's a capacity problem.  The beam may, or may not, be able to take the load, but it will attract it based on the relative stifnesses.  Point taken, though, that if one of the beams fails prematurely that the other beam is doing all the work.


Toad-
I considered the diapgragm behavior of the wall, but discounted it when I saw the load and aspect ratio of the wall.  The wall is longer than it is tall so the plf of the diaphragm would be greater than the load plf, which is significant for a wood diaphragm.

RE: Is the top beam helping?

(OP)
I put the wall studs in this scenario merely to transfer the load to the lower beam. Let's remove the wall and put the smaller beam on top of the bigger one with the same loading conditions and deflection limits. If the beams are deflected 1/2" is the upper(smaller) beam carrying 500# and the lower (bigger) beam carrying 1000#?

RE: Is the top beam helping?

not totally following you Lion.

RE: Is the top beam helping?

relative stiffness problem, nothing more, nothing less.

RE: Is the top beam helping?

Relative stiffness, I agree Toad.

Lion:

I would have to disagree as the detail is dimensionless, only subjective in nature.  I do get your drift however.

It is interesting to note though that if the studs transfer the vertical force with no plywood, then the size of the top and bottom beams (speaking of the larger and smaller context of the OP) will not matter.  However, with the plywood, and the aspect of a deep plywood beam between the two solid beams, then the shear stress in the end of the plywood wall will be greater if the smaller beam is placed on the top since a greater portion of the load will have to be transferred through the plywood wall to the larger beam below.  However, in the end, regardless of the placement of the beams, all three will deflect the same.  

In essence, with the plywood, there will be three beams of different relative stiffnesses.   

Mike McCann
MMC Engineering

 

RE: Is the top beam helping?

Toad-
Which part do you not follow?  I did say this was a relative stiffness problem, no?  Iu/(Iu+Il).

RE: Is the top beam helping?

2
As 4thorns defined the problem, I would say the answer is YES.  I don't know why you guys have made it so confusing.  He did say the little beam deflects 1/2" under 500#, and the big beam deflects the same amount under 1000#, so the sum of the load taken by the two beams is 1500# when deflecting 1/2".

RE: Is the top beam helping?

Agreed hokie, I just wasn't sure if that was purposeful or not.  I guessed not, because if he understood the problem well enough to make it purposeful, there's no need to ask the question.

RE: Is the top beam helping?

One thing to note here is that IF either of the beams fail or go into the inelastic range beyond a 1/2" deflection, then load will get shed over to the non-inelastic or non-failed beam.

You might flesh out this problem for us by telling us why you are asking.

 

RE: Is the top beam helping?

(OP)
Basically in this situation I need to determine what the bottom beam needs to be. I know what the top one is. The deflection is controlled by the bottom beam. If I know my deflection limit, I can find out how much load the top beam can handle to not surpass that limit.

Can I then subtract that amount from the overall load and design my lower beam based on the result?

I've been told to ignore the (in some cases small amount) that the upper beam can resit and design the lower beam to carry the whole load. That just didn't make sense to me.

Thank you all for your time.

RE: Is the top beam helping?

I do need to correct my last post here on thinking about my comment more.  

It will not make a difference in the plywood wall shearing stress whether the larger beam is placed at the top or bottom as all three mechanisms deflect at the same rate and together.  When I thought about it further, a difference in stress made no sense.

And, Hokie, you are correct.  The answer ti the OP is yes.  We were beating around the bush.

Mike McCann
MMC Engineering

 

RE: Is the top beam helping?

Yep,

If the smaller beam deflects 1/2" when subjected to the 500# and the larger beam deflects 1/2" when subjected to 1000#. Then a 1500# load applied at the top beam will be shared in a ratio of 33.3% and 66.6% as long as the transferring elements (being the wall frame) has the ability to help share the loads.

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources