×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Timber Exposed to the Weather - type of treatment?

Timber Exposed to the Weather - type of treatment?

Timber Exposed to the Weather - type of treatment?

(OP)
I am working on residential project where the architect is using exposed timber that extends outside of the house.  There are also some exposed timber columns and headers that are exposed to weather.

IBC 2006 - section 2304.11.5 states that naturally durable or preservative-treated wood shall be used in such situations.

I have not really had much experience with timber exposed to weather, so I apologize if my questions are naive.

1) The timbers are Doug-Fir.  Should the timbers be pressure-treated?  If so, will they look green like the pressure treated 2X's you get from Hope Depot?

2) Is it possible to just use a sealer in exposed exterior applications?  It would seem that the IBC does not allow it.

3)  The architect seemed to think that Douglas Fir is a naturally durable wood, but I don't think that it is... correct?

4) Does anyone have any pointers for treating or addressing timbers exposed to weather?

thanks!
StandStruc

RE: Timber Exposed to the Weather - type of treatment?

Douglas Fir is definitely not a naturally durable timber.  Architects periodically come up with this idea, with predictable disastrous results in a few years time.  

RE: Timber Exposed to the Weather - type of treatment?

call AWPA

RE: Timber Exposed to the Weather - type of treatment?

You can get a clear pressure treating, but it's probably special order.  The wood should look fairly similar to un-treated wood.

Douglas fir is definately NOT naturally durable.  In an exposed condition you'd be lucky to have it last 5 years.  It also needs to be sealed with a UV resistant sealer.  The pressure treating helps with decay but not weathering.  A sealer will help keep the weathering in check.   

RE: Timber Exposed to the Weather - type of treatment?

DF is definitely not naturally durable.  Only two I know of that are readily available are Redwood and Cedar.  You might get more than 5 years - but probably not much.

Then - how do you repair it??  Tear the house apart to replace a few beams??

I have seen these beams sheathed with redwood then well caulked and painted.   If well maintained - should be OK.

RE: Timber Exposed to the Weather - type of treatment?

I sometimes feel like I have to ask the stupid and obvious questions, so, where is this?

Big difference between Florida, where I live and would suggest to not leave any wood exposed except maybe a deck, and the SW USA...

Oh, and what do you mean exactly by "exposed"? Will these columns and headers not support some type of roof?  

RE: Timber Exposed to the Weather - type of treatment?

I only specify seasoned hardwoods for external applications. Would not use douglas fir.

RE: Timber Exposed to the Weather - type of treatment?

(OP)
Thanks for all of the responses. the project is in the Midwest, so I am concerned with the weathering.
 

RE: Timber Exposed to the Weather - type of treatment?

Another thing about architects is that they like to use clear coatings or stains on wood which is exposed.  They look fine for 6 months to a year, depending on where located, but the clear coating provides little actual protection.  "UV resistant" is just a marketing ploy with clear coatings.

RE: Timber Exposed to the Weather - type of treatment?

StandStruc,

The midwest includes the whole gammut from barren deserts to alpine regions. You will have to be a bit more specific than that if you want decent advice.

RE: Timber Exposed to the Weather - type of treatment?

(OP)
The project is in Missouri.

I have done some additional reading and have some additional questions for everyone.

1) Treatment appears to be the way to go.  What are people's thoughts on pressure treating vs. brush applied treatments?

It would seem that pressure treating is better, but would it be overkill for beams that are interior for 20' and exposed for about 2' outside the structure.  Also, some of the columns will be exposed for about 3' on one surface.

Brush applied would be easier and could be applied after members a cut and fit-up.

2) What treatment would you recommend for Douglas Fir?

I have been looking at borates or Copper napthenate.  There is a lot of conflicting information available on what is best.  Borates possibly are more prone to leaching. Copper Napthenate seems to be the recommended field applied product for bridges, but has a green color.

It seems that none of the preservatives penetrate Douglas Fir very well unless it is incised.  I am pretty sure this will be unacceptable to the architect.  I am hoping that the preservative will have "reasonable" penetration if the wood is not incised.

3) Can sealers be applied over the various treatment options?

I would hate it if a preservative that I specified was not compatible with the preferred sealer product.

Thanks everyone!
 

RE: Timber Exposed to the Weather - type of treatment?

make sure that the treatment is not water soluble.

RE: Timber Exposed to the Weather - type of treatment?

You can paint over pressure treated wood.  Use a 100% acrylic coating, which should last 10 years before recoating is required.  Clear "sealers" won't last a year, and don't provide much protection.

RE: Timber Exposed to the Weather - type of treatment?

Some of the Sikkens clear coat products are very good, but will require recoating more often than an acrylic paint.
I suggest contacting the distributor for advice.

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources