×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Wind on Shoring/Bracing for tiltwall panels during construction

Wind on Shoring/Bracing for tiltwall panels during construction

Wind on Shoring/Bracing for tiltwall panels during construction

(OP)
Project is in 120mph basic wind speed zone.  Are there any Code-allowed reductions to that design wind speed for the shoring/bracing of the tiltwall panels while they are being constructed?  Tiltwall Contractor is claiming they "always" use 90mph since "temporary condition".  I'm inclined to make them design the shoring/bracing for the full 120mph, but want to make sure I'm not missing something...  Anyone know?

RE: Wind on Shoring/Bracing for tiltwall panels during construction

The code should have a clause for short duration or temporary works check in the back of the code. There also may be a seasonal factor.

If the job is going on during hurricane season then you may need to consider the consequence of failure.

RE: Wind on Shoring/Bracing for tiltwall panels during construction

Take a look at ASCE 37-02 Design loads on structures during construction.

 

RE: Wind on Shoring/Bracing for tiltwall panels during construction

See TCA's GUIDELINE for TEMPORARY WIND BRACING of TILT-UP CONCRETE PANELS DURING CONSTRUCTION, available at tilt-up.org.

 

RE: Wind on Shoring/Bracing for tiltwall panels during construction

Not to be fececious here, but is this project in Indiana?  

Seems like we have covered this wind gust reduction/mitigation scenario very recently.  

I could see a reduction outside of the June to September hurricane season (October to May), but not during it.  So what if the contractor has to use super struts instead of the normal ones.  Include it in the bid.  Failure is not an option.

Mike McCann
MMC Engineering

 

RE: Wind on Shoring/Bracing for tiltwall panels during construction

As stated by FancyPants, ASCE 37-02 Design Loads on Structures During Construction is the governing document in this case.  This document clearly spells out the wind loads to be used on temporary structures, including several options for handling hurricane season.   

RE: Wind on Shoring/Bracing for tiltwall panels during construction

We do a lot of tiltwall and yes, it is standard practice to reduce wind loads to some lower return period (don't know it off the top of my head).

When we receive shop drawings, the design wind speed is 72 mph (we are located in a 90 mph area), so it seems reasonable to me that the reduction from 120 is 90.

Titlwall needs to be braced until you get the roof structure (and, obviously the LFRS, if not entirely tiltwall) in. If you get a major hurricane during construction, well that's just really bad luck, but it's not like anyone will be at the job site during construction. I don't think it's reasonable or cost effective to design every stage of construction for the maximum possible loading.

RE: Wind on Shoring/Bracing for tiltwall panels during construction

Yes that was the type of thing that I was trying to infer.

If there was a hurricane then people wouldnt be hanging out at the construction site and most of these sites are in the middle of a vacant lot. So very unlikely to be alife safety risk.

BUT if the panel could fall on say a public highway, a school, a hospital or similar then I would design the propping for the full wind load.

RE: Wind on Shoring/Bracing for tiltwall panels during construction

Ever try to keep a kid out of a construction site?

Mike McCann
MMC Engineering

 

RE: Wind on Shoring/Bracing for tiltwall panels during construction

Ever try to re-lift a tilt panel once the bracing has failed? You are exposing you client to a lot of risk of damages if the bracing was to fail during a cyclonic event that his insurance dose not cover. I recommend getting your client involved before making this change of wind speed decision.  

ANY FOOL CAN DESIGN A STRUCTURE. IT TAKES AN ENGINEER TO DESIGN A CONNECTION."
 

RE: Wind on Shoring/Bracing for tiltwall panels during construction

msquared48,

by that logic we should reduce all highway speeds to 30mph to allow for the occasional kid that may try to cross it!

Rowingengineer,

This reduction of wind speed is standard practice for temporary works. The cost of the additional bracing would far outweigh the risk. I think you will find that the onus is on the construction insurance policy rather than the owners.

Lets make this clear, we cannot completely eliminate risk! We can only allow for those reasonably foreseen risks and do our best to reduce them to an acceptable level.

Even if we designed for a hurricane, there is always the chance that nature will hit us with an even bigger hurricane.

This is not just a matter of bigger props, the footing or structure at the bottom of the prop needs to be designed for uplift and would need to be twice as big if the higher pressures were used. If these anchors are into the building structure then it may not be possible to make them work without completely rechanging the whole structure.

RE: Wind on Shoring/Bracing for tiltwall panels during construction

M^2..

I almost always agree with you. However, a kid in a construction site during a hurricane?!

csd72 hit the nail on the head. We cannot eliminate risk. We can only try to manage it in a reasonable and, frankly, conservative way. 90 mph is already at the upper end of a category 1 hurricane.

RE: Wind on Shoring/Bracing for tiltwall panels during construction

Everybody seems to forget the fact that tilt-up bracing design, like everything else, is done using safety/load factors. Designing for 90 mph means it shouldn't fail until about 115 mph using a 1.6 factor.

RE: Wind on Shoring/Bracing for tiltwall panels during construction

good point spats, although much of that factor of safety is allowing for wear and abuse of the bracings.

RE: Wind on Shoring/Bracing for tiltwall panels during construction

csd72,
this maybe true for us law, but in Australia if the propping is design below the code requirements it will fail the insurance requirements and the onus will fall on the owner.  

ANY FOOL CAN DESIGN A STRUCTURE. IT TAKES AN ENGINEER TO DESIGN A CONNECTION."
 

RE: Wind on Shoring/Bracing for tiltwall panels during construction

rowingengineer,

I know exactly what you are talking about but AS1170 does have provision for seasonal and short term factors (I think this is in the importance factor now) in the wind section. This is also acknowledged in much of the correspondence from workcover, worksafe e.t.c.

By the way, I think the regulations in Australia regarding tilt-up and precast are some of the best in the world. Many things that you would never get away with in Australia are still regular practice in the US and UK as well as most other parts of the world.

A few good australian references:

http://www.commerce.wa.gov.au/worksafe/PDF/Codes_of_Practice/Code_Tiltup_Precast_.pdf
http://www.concrete.net.au/publications/pdf/briefing08.pdf
http://www.worksafe.vic.gov.au/wps/wcm/connect/2e4eea004071f586a814fee1fb554c40/tilt_up.pdf?MOD=AJPERES

RE: Wind on Shoring/Bracing for tiltwall panels during construction

Agree with CSD, this all boils down to actuarial probabilities and economics. During the 2004 hurricane season in central FL there were plenty of failures of CMU and tilt panels under construction. Like was said above, we know about hurricanes for several days out and nobody is anywhere near a construction site. This is why the GC's have insurance. Sure, the BEST thing to do would be design for full design wind loads, though that would ignore the probability and economic factors.

Since a braced tilt wall during construction usually has no axial load other than dead load, the failure mode we all agree on is pullout failure of the bolts at the slab level?

RE: Wind on Shoring/Bracing for tiltwall panels during construction

Or buckling of the braces.

RE: Wind on Shoring/Bracing for tiltwall panels during construction

Usually a combination of pullout and shear on the anchor bolts.

The panel is unlikely to fail as the span is much less and the critical bending stress is usually during the lift from the casting bed.

Actually, thats one more point, I expect you will find that at 120mph wind most panel propping arrangements will fail due to uplift of the panel!  

RE: Wind on Shoring/Bracing for tiltwall panels during construction

72 mph is the tilt-up industry standard wind load for temporary bracing.

RE: Wind on Shoring/Bracing for tiltwall panels during construction

So then, who pays the bill when the brace fails at 73?  Certainly not the "insurance" company...  They'll litigate until the cows vcome home and never pay.

And if the contractor and shoring engineer adhered to the established "standard of care", certainly not them.  

So it's out of the owner's pocket.  Wonderful, just wonderful.  So the insurance companies get richer and the clients, who pay us and create thae projects, get poorer.  

Just can't agree here guys.  I see nothing wrong with the 120 mph provision and extra bracing as needed, maintaining the protection of insurance for the client to a higher level in area prone to these winds during the construction season.  This is a minor project cost compared to the potential level of risk.  In fact, in the southern areas, that "season" is year around.

Now I'll step back and dodge the flack.

Mike McCann
MMC Engineering

 

RE: Wind on Shoring/Bracing for tiltwall panels during construction

Mike-

The reduced wind force is per the code.  People are not making it up, it is in ASCE 37, Loads on Structures During Construction.  If every stage of every project had to be designed for full 500 year return periods, the costs of engineering and bracing them during construction would be astronomical (not to mention at some stages of construction not even feasible).  As always, you have to weigh risks vs costs vs life safety.  The risk of a hurricane or storm strong enough to exceed the reduced wind loads hitting the structure during construction is very small compared with the costs of designing and bracing the structure to withstand the full forces.  Could we design all buildings with an R=1 to withstand the full force of an earthquake?  Sure - but we don't - because it is too expensive and we are willing to take some risk.   

RE: Wind on Shoring/Bracing for tiltwall panels during construction

Here here! I agree with Willis V wholeheartedly. Renting braces is not cheap, especially when you wind up with 3x the number of braces. I've been designing tilt-up in Florida for 30 years, including doing a lot of bracing design. I can only think of one instance in all that time where a hurricane hit one of my tilt-up buildings under construction. In preparation for the storm (there was plenty of warning) they buried the base of the panels using sand, and tied the panels together across the joints to facilitate load sharing. Maybe we were lucky (I can't recall the actual wind speed) but, again, there is a factor of safety. 72 mph design is good for 90 mph plus, at a minimum. It's not often that braces are at their full capacity under ultimate loads.

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources