×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Any ideas on how to share/collaborate a FEM with a colleague?

Any ideas on how to share/collaborate a FEM with a colleague?

Any ideas on how to share/collaborate a FEM with a colleague?

(OP)
My company uses Femap as our pre- and post-processor. Does anyone have any ideas or creative solutions for sharing a finite element model with a colleage? This is not something that can be divided into submodels. I have already considered and pitched working 2 shifts to management. They would prefer if 2 people could be optimizing at the same time during the day due to shop workload issues.  

RE: Any ideas on how to share/collaborate a FEM with a colleague?

two people simultaneously editting a model ... "i don't think so"

i think the only way would be to divide into two super-elements, you can divide the model at a reasonably arbitary boundary (section plane), maybe at a "convenient" set of nodes ??

if you Had to, work on different groups of nodes/elements, export the bdf for each then combine the two altered sets ... but i feel really dirty even suggesting that approach ...

you could check this horrible approach by keeping a master bdf and comparing both altered bdfs  to it ... nodes elements should change in only one or the other of the altered bdfs, but not both.

but then that approach would probably double the amount of time to change the model ... but rationality was never a convincing argument with mgmt.

RE: Any ideas on how to share/collaborate a FEM with a colleague?

(OP)
Thanks. Just thought I'd poll to make sure there was some elegant trick I was missing out on. :)

RE: Any ideas on how to share/collaborate a FEM with a colleague?

Could you provide a little more detail regarding the model? You state you can't submodel it, so that tells me there's no convenient boundary for you to segment the model between the two analysts. Is it a solid model? Is it an assembly? If it's a single solid component could you consider cutting it at a plane and use certain solver techniques to connect the two solids? I'm thinking you could use NX Nastran surface-surface glue capabilities or ABAQUS tied contact.

As far as sharing the data, you can start with edited geometry in the form of a PARASOLID or STEP file. Maybe there's a better solution depending on your CAD package. Both of you work independent on your half, then 2 Nastran input files could be read into the same FEMAP model for the analysis runs.

As you can see, I've got more questions than answers at this point. I'm mostly speculating and throwing out suggestions for a still unclear problem you're trying to solve. It is an interesting one though.

Regards,
Mark

Mark Lamping
CAE Technical Consultant
Siemens PLM Software

RE: Any ideas on how to share/collaborate a FEM with a colleague?

(OP)
mlamping, you are correct in that there is no convenient boundary to segment the model. It is an assembly model and the global loads are shared across the structure - what can be removed and modeled separately has already been done. I really do not see a workable solution apart from the 2 shift proposal I made earlier. I considered the super-element approach, but again I struggle with an appropriate boundary plane. I don't really need a model review, I was just curious if there was a tip or trick that I was unaware of for finite element model sharing. I know there are CAD tips and tricks but I just couldn't seem to apply them to the FE world in my mind.

Thanks for your time.

RE: Any ideas on how to share/collaborate a FEM with a colleague?

if you're just dividing up the model so two people can edit it at the same time, you can divide it anywhere ... draw a box on the model, pick "items entirely within", ...  not nice, but better than anything else i can think of ...

RE: Any ideas on how to share/collaborate a FEM with a colleague?

Can you define an interface of certain nodes that have specific numbering, and each analyst works his/her respective half of the model in 2 distinct Femap files?

Then, for example, 1 analyst uses only elements numbered 1 - 10 000, and the other uses elements numbered 20 000 to 30 000, such that there is no overlap.

Same for the nodes, except the common ones.

Then, you could export each of these halfs to 2 Nastran files, then, using a text editor, combine the Nastran files.

In theory, very doable, but you have to manipulate the Nastran  text files.

You also have to each be working in consistent global coordinates, so you don't end up with an arm where your foot should be...

Once combined, you could import into a new Femap file and add loads, etc.

Hope it helps.

tg  

RE: Any ideas on how to share/collaborate a FEM with a colleague?

(OP)
rb1957 & trainguy -
Thank you both. I think those ideas are very workable solutions. I guess one bit of the puzzle that I have not mentioned is that one of the analysts is a very disorganized person, so I've been trying to avoid things that require work and rules and I know will be ignored. Again, thanks for all the comments and I think I've got a viable path forward that will hopefully minimize rework for all.

RE: Any ideas on how to share/collaborate a FEM with a colleague?

debugging it (as i'm sure you'll have to) will be a nightmare !

RE: Any ideas on how to share/collaborate a FEM with a colleague?

(OP)
Yes, that's the part I'm dreading.

RE: Any ideas on how to share/collaborate a FEM with a colleague?

maybe get your colleague to do that part ?  ;)

RE: Any ideas on how to share/collaborate a FEM with a colleague?

Jetgirl8,

You mean there are people in Aerospace who avoid things that require work?

Sounds like some of my Rail people...

tg

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources