×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Short-Circuit protection of a three phase motor with two fuses?

Short-Circuit protection of a three phase motor with two fuses?

Short-Circuit protection of a three phase motor with two fuses?

(OP)
I am designing a vacuum circuit breaker that will be used to feed three phase motor circuits.  I am using a neutral grounding resistor to limit my ground fault current to a safe level.  I want to fuse phase A and phase C.  I want to leave the B phase un-fused.  This will provide the short-circuit protection I need for any fault.  Does anyone know of any regulations that this may be in violation of?  Any help would be appreciated! Thanks guys!

RE: Short-Circuit protection of a three phase motor with two fuses?

It would help to know where, what voltage, and any other information you have.

RE: Short-Circuit protection of a three phase motor with two fuses?

Most NGRs are short-term rated, so an uncleared fault on the B phase will kill the NGR. This will probably not be a good thing.

Circuit breakers are normally designed to clear fault current. Normally fuses are used to back up an HV contactor of limited breaking capacity. What are you actually dealing with here?
  

----------------------------------
  
If we learn from our mistakes I'm getting a great education!
 

RE: Short-Circuit protection of a three phase motor with two fuses?

(OP)
The NGR I am using is rated for continuous operation.  This application is for 3 different 3 phase voltages.  480vac, 600vac, and 1000vac.  All voltages are 60 cycle.  This vacuuum circuit breaker will be used as a feeder in underground mining applications.  I have CTs for overcurrent but the fuses are required for short-circuit protection.  All of MSHA's documents only require "short-circuit protection".  They do not specify how this is accomplished.  When I brought this before them, they didn't want to let me use only 2 fuses to accomplish this.  They could not however provide me with any information on why.  They then informed me that if I could find a similar application already in use in the industry that it would help my case.  I am not acutally using a circuit breaker.  I am combining a protection relay with fuses and a vacuum contactor to accomplish the equivalent.

RE: Short-Circuit protection of a three phase motor with two fuses?

Since you cite MSHA, I'm assuming a US installation. Have you reviewed NEC Section 430.225(C)(1)(b)? It applies to all motors over 600V.

RE: Short-Circuit protection of a three phase motor with two fuses?

(OP)
This is for a US application.  I have reviewed that section of the NEC but this vacuum circuit breaker will be feeding motors and "other" equipment such as welders and things of the like.  Would that classify it as a feeder circuit instead? In section 240.1 the informational note references the overcurrent section 110.10 for protection against fault currents.  Does this cover me for circuits of not more than 600vac?  If so, what about the 1000vac circuits?

RE: Short-Circuit protection of a three phase motor with two fuses?

All motor circuits are required to have protection in all 3 phases. Even if you think it qualifies as a feeder circuit, all that means is that the motor circuit requirements are then going to be satisfied again somewhere down stream.

"Dear future generations: Please accept our apologies. We were rolling drunk on petroleum."
— Kilgore Trout (via Kurt Vonnegut)
  
For the best use of Eng-Tips, please click here -> FAQ731-376: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies  

RE: Short-Circuit protection of a three phase motor with two fuses?

(OP)
I have just found a related article in the NEC.  Section 240-20 Ungrounded Conductors.(a) states: "Overcurrent Device Required.  A fuse or an overcurrent trip unit of a circuit breaker shall be connected in series with each ungrounded conductor.  A combination of a current transformer and overcurrent relay shall be considered equivalent to an overcurrent trip unit."

Would this allow me to eliminate the B phase fuse as long as I have overcurrent protection for all 3 phases?

RE: Short-Circuit protection of a three phase motor with two fuses?

If it were acceptable then likely the major manufacturers would have implemented it as a cost saving, but I haven't seen it on US-origin equipment I've been involved with.

Why are you so determined to remove the fuse?
  

----------------------------------
  
If we learn from our mistakes I'm getting a great education!
 

RE: Short-Circuit protection of a three phase motor with two fuses?

(OP)
The first reason I want to remove the fuse is because I can provide the protection I need with two fuses(if code allows).  The second reason is because the fuses I am using are so expensive.  The third reason is the downtime involved in replacing the "extra" fuse.  I don't see the need to replace two fuses when one fuse could be replaced all while keeping the protection required.  The customers this application will be geared toward actually don't want fuses, but the the vacuum contactor technology available doesn't meet the interrupting ratings for short-circuit current.  That being said, the best idea I could come up with was to eliminate the B phase fuse...

RE: Short-Circuit protection of a three phase motor with two fuses?

(OP)
I think you don't see this in the industry is because of the neutral grounding resistor.  MSHA requires a continuous duty  25 Amp current limiting resistor from a neutral to ground.  So even if I were to get a ground fault, it wouldn't blow the fuse of the phase it occurred on, no matter the duration.  

RE: Short-Circuit protection of a three phase motor with two fuses?

Quote (crthompson):

I have just found a related article in the NEC.  Section 240-20 Ungrounded Conductors.(a) states: "Overcurrent Device Required.  A fuse or an overcurrent trip unit of a circuit breaker shall be connected in series with each ungrounded conductor.  A combination of a current transformer and overcurrent relay shall be considered equivalent to an overcurrent trip unit."

Would this allow me to eliminate the B phase fuse as long as I have overcurrent protection for all 3 phases?
I don't understand how you are getting the EXACT OPPOSITE of what is stated here!

To me it clearly says EACH ungrounded conductore. If you have a 3 phase Y system, as implied by having an NGR, you have 3 ungrounded cunductors. How is it that you seem to think this means you do NOT need the fuse on the B phase then?

"Dear future generations: Please accept our apologies. We were rolling drunk on petroleum."
— Kilgore Trout (via Kurt Vonnegut)
  
For the best use of Eng-Tips, please click here -> FAQ731-376: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies  

RE: Short-Circuit protection of a three phase motor with two fuses?

You may be confused concerning the terms:
overload and over current.
Overload is overload protection. This is provided by the motor overload relay.
Overcurrent is short circuit protection  (which may be set to also provide overload protection). Your fuses are your overcurrent protection required on each conductor. You have stated that the vacuum contactors will not break the levels of fault current available. Hence you can not provide overcurrent protection by tripping a vacuum contactor.
A simple ground fault may not be a problem. Ground faults are often not simple. Phase to phase faults often involve a ground path as well as the phase to phase fault particularly where arcs are involved. A phase to phase to ground fault will generally take out both fuses. If only one phase is fused you may be left with a 25 Amp arc to ground. That may do a lot of damage and may soon involve adjacent conductors and cables.

Bill
--------------------
"Why not the best?"
Jimmy Carter

RE: Short-Circuit protection of a three phase motor with two fuses?

(OP)
240-20 a states: "A fuse or an overcurrent trip unit of a circuit breaker shall be connected in series with each ungrounded conductor.  A combination of a current transformer and overcurrent relay shall be considered equivalent to an overcurrent trip unit." This clearly states that an overcurrent trip unit can be used instead of fuses.  Then it clearly states that CTs and an overcurrent relay can be used on each ungrounded conductor to accomplish the same.  I do have ground fault protection and in the event that any phase goes to ground the breaker would open.  If two phases get together or go to ground then the speed of the fuses will open the fault before the contactor opens.  Then after the phase fault is cleared the ground fault protection will open the contactor (after high fault currents have been cleared)

RE: Short-Circuit protection of a three phase motor with two fuses?

Well, do what you want but I wouldn't accept it because it's a really, really dumb thing to do. Think about this. Phase A has a ground fault upstream of this "circuit breaker" and phase B has a ground fault downstream of this "circuit breaker". Which fuse is clearing this fault? Oh yeah, the vacuum bottle "fuse"...

On another note, how exactly are you going to allow for a maintenance lock-out with a vacuum contactor?

RE: Short-Circuit protection of a three phase motor with two fuses?

Overcurrent Protection is to protect the Conductors & the Devices they feed during normal operation. In this case, this is the job of your circuit breaker.

Your Conductors & your Overcurrent Protection Device (your breaker) have specific short circuit ratings. The short circuit rating is the amount of current the device can handle before the overcurrent device opens.
Your over current device should have a series rating..."Current Limit Rating When Fused" This will state the type of fuse and the maximum let through. e.g. Your Over-Current device may be 1000A. Your Current-Limiting fuse may be 1600A. This will allow the the over-current device to act first. Fuses will only blow on a dead short.

That said, To provide Short-Circuit Protection to a 3-phase device, and to all conductors, you will need to provide fuses on all phases.    

RE: Short-Circuit protection of a three phase motor with two fuses?

(OP)
The phase A ground fault would be opened by the ground fault protection. The primary of the supply transformer will have all 3 phases fused and in the event of a secondary phase to phase fault, the primary fuses would clear the fault.

The nominal current for this application is 600A.  The vacuum contactor I am using has an interrupting rating of 4,500A.  The fuse that is used to protect the contactor is a 700A fuse.  The specifications I am building this to require the fuses to open first in the event of a short-circuit.

I don't want anyone to think I am just trying to cheapen a design or anything like that.  Safety is my number one concern when designing this.  If I can find any reason to "need" the B phase fuse, then it will be there.  As of yet I see no danger in removing it. In the long run, the final decision on this will be made by MSHA but I am looking for information to strengthen my case. Thank you all for input!!

RE: Short-Circuit protection of a three phase motor with two fuses?

If there is a short on B-Phase, any available current will pass through the B-Phase of your contactor. If the avaible current is above 4500A, the contactor will fail.

RE: Short-Circuit protection of a three phase motor with two fuses?

(OP)
If there is a short from B phase to ground it will be current limited to 15 or 25A.  If B phase goes to phase A, the phase A fuse will blow clearing the fault.  If B phase goes to phase C, the phase C fuse will blow clearing the fault. If phase A & C fault then at least one if not both fuses will blow, clearing the fault.

RE: Short-Circuit protection of a three phase motor with two fuses?

You have no case to strengthen. If there is a phase A ground fault upstream and a phase B ground fault downstream of this contraption then the upstream fuses are the only thing in the circuit that can protect the contactor. Your use of the combination of fuses and contactor is implying that you already checked the fault numbers and know that the main fuses won't protect the contactor. The contactor will fail if the main fuses won't protect the contactor and there is no branch fuse.

Besides, even if it did work, I'm sure the mine will not appreciate you taking out the main and shutting down their whole power system, compared to just shutting down this branch system.

 

RE: Short-Circuit protection of a three phase motor with two fuses?

(OP)
We have upstream ground fault protection that will remove control power from the contactor control circuits so they can't be closed.  If they have any phase to ground fault upstream it will take the entire power center offline anyway. I meant to say strengthen or weaken my case.

RE: Short-Circuit protection of a three phase motor with two fuses?

I wouldn't want to be your lawyer when this goes sideways.
The best result that I can see is that you push this until the wording in the code is strengthened.
Bad idea! Bad idea!
The one way around this will be to corner ground the system.
Of course that introduces several other negative factors.
If the contactor was suitable for overcurrent (fault current) protection you would not need any fuses. The contactor is not suitable for overcurrent protection so you do need three fuses.
No "What ifs" no "Ya buts" "no I thinks" just three fuses.
It's the code and the code is quite clear.

Bill
--------------------
"Why not the best?"
Jimmy Carter

RE: Short-Circuit protection of a three phase motor with two fuses?

(OP)
The code states that three CTs in conjuction with an "overcurrent" relay ON ALL THREE UNGROUNDED CONDUCTORS will suffice for fuses. At this point the fuses are only there to interrupt short-circuits before the contactor has the chance to open.  Two fuses accomplish this perfectly fine. Lionel did make a great point... That was something I hadn't thought of, but we protect our transformers with ground fault protection so that if any phase goes to ground upstream of the contactor the incoming power feed is removed.

BTW... Thank you all so much for your input!!!

RE: Short-Circuit protection of a three phase motor with two fuses?

[sarcasm]Oh you will be fine. Nothing could possibly go wrong. I've ~never~ heard of an electrician bypassing or miswiring a protection relay. I've also ~never~ heard of a protection relay failing either. I'm sure no-one else here has ever any of these possible failures happen either...[/sarcasm]

 

RE: Short-Circuit protection of a three phase motor with two fuses?

(OP)
If they bypass the relay they are in violation of the law.  You can tamper with anything to make it fail as far as that goes.  These devices would be sold in a completed power center and fully wired and operationally tested.  I am required by MSHA to use a relay that is failsafe just in case of such a failure.  All of that aside I am now actually leaning toward the third fuse...

RE: Short-Circuit protection of a three phase motor with two fuses?

I don't live in the USA and don't have a current copy of the NEC to check the wording,
but if you depend on the relay to comply with the code requirement for protection in all ungrounded conductors the contactor that it operates must be rated for the available fault current.
You may encounter bolted faults when commissioning new installations but faults on existing installations may often be arcing faults with considerably less than full available fault current. An arcing fault may be enough to destroy your contactor but not enough to ensure that the fuse blows instantly or in time to save the contactor.
 

Bill
--------------------
"Why not the best?"
Jimmy Carter

RE: Short-Circuit protection of a three phase motor with two fuses?

(OP)
I don't see how a third fuse would prevent arcing faults...

RE: Short-Circuit protection of a three phase motor with two fuses?

(OP)
Thanks to everyone for your help!  I have found a case where only using two fuses would compromise the protection of the circuit.  If the neutral from the transformer gets grounded before passing through the neutral grounding resistor, it becomes a solid grounded system with no current limit for ground faults. I really appreciate everyone's ideas and comments!! Thanks again!

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources