×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Easy fix for AC Motor Starter Chatter?
2

Easy fix for AC Motor Starter Chatter?

Easy fix for AC Motor Starter Chatter?

(OP)
I have read several of the historical threads related to AC motor starter chatter.  I have a similar issue with an 80HP 480 VAC motor controlled by an IEC starter with a 120VAC coil.  System is powered from a 208 service stepped up to 480VAC.  The 120 control voltage (300VA) dips to around 100-105vac (with fluke meter not scope) while attempting to pull it in.  The coil is rated for 95-180vac.  Sometimes it does pull in, but mostly it doesn't and chatters something fierce.  I have seen comments on changing to a DC coil starter and using rectifiers.  I am looking for the right solution or other ideas.  As a PLC guy I am mostly use to just firing the output.

Sorry to bring up a recurring topic.


Marc Whitney
www.thelogicongroup.com

RE: Easy fix for AC Motor Starter Chatter?

You can power the 120 V control circuit from a separate UPS source.  This has some drawbacks, but I've seen it done in situations like this.  



 

David Castor
www.cvoes.com

RE: Easy fix for AC Motor Starter Chatter?

If you can't easily get an independent 120V source, a constant voltage transformer (ferroresonant; such as from SOLA) will work well for this application.  They are big and lossy, but reliable and maintenance free.

RE: Easy fix for AC Motor Starter Chatter?

Or you could change out your 300 VA transformer for a 500 VA transformer.  

Bill
--------------------
"Why not the best?"
Jimmy Carter

RE: Easy fix for AC Motor Starter Chatter?


try using latching magnetic contactor of cutler-hummer freedom series which is tolerable with your voltage dip range,  but not sure if still in the market.

other, try LG magnetic contactor power by AC but inside the contactor itself, imbedded the DC ckt that tolerates the voltage faults.


"..the more, the merrier" Genghis Khan

 

RE: Easy fix for AC Motor Starter Chatter?

Don't do anything and the problem will cure itself. MWAAAHAHAHA




Ah ok.  Not feasible.

Your coil is good for 180V.  Jack your control voltage just to the contactor.  Do this by using an auto-transformer. Look that up if you need a refresher.

Make one using a little control transformer.  Find one that has a 120V tapping on the primary and 24V secondary.  Use those properly phased to make a 1.20 step-up.  It will suck in 120V and output 144V.

That means during the drop to 100V,(it's lower than this in reality), you'll still be feeding the contactor with 120V.

 

Keith Cress
kcress - http://www.flaminsystems.com

RE: Easy fix for AC Motor Starter Chatter?

PLS for Smoked. That IS a good and simple solution! And you do not need the full coil wattage - only about a quarter (24/120 + margin).

Gunnar Englund
www.gke.org
--------------------------------------
Half full - Half empty? I don't mind. It's what in it that counts.

RE: Easy fix for AC Motor Starter Chatter?

(OP)
Some more info...

The 480 VAC feed from the transformer is tapped high and is around 497 volts.  This has given the control xfmr about 130 VAC before startup.  Still diping to 105vac.  I bypassed the control xfmr with an extension cord from an external building outlet at 124vac with similar chatter results.  With the 80hp motor load disconnected the starter pulls in fine.

Also had tried a 750VA XFMR thinking the power just wasnt enough.  It should also be noted that I am workinng on a factory delivered Ingersol Rand air compressor package.  This is a cookie cutter design that they have in all systems.  Pointing me to the main power feed more than the components inside the panel.  

Could this be power factor related from the utility or am I mostly likely just dealing with the voltage dip issue?  
 


Marc Whitney
www.thelogicongroup.com

RE: Easy fix for AC Motor Starter Chatter?

Can you drag in a desktop computer UPS and try this as that decouples you from the entire building grid during transients.

If it does it then you know you have a contactor with a problem.  Broken springs, improperly mounted, mounted to a vibrational wall, mounted to a wall that gets jolted during the start, incorrectly oriented, or located in an intense magnetic environment.

Take it out of service and disassemble it to investigate. A couple of chatters is all it takes to take off a huge amount of the contacts. If too much are gone chattering can become endemic.  If you seen nothing wrong change it out with a spare.  If no spare is around consider changing brand.  

Keith Cress
kcress - http://www.flaminsystems.com

RE: Easy fix for AC Motor Starter Chatter?

Check the voltage drop on the primary side of the control transformer.
The voltage is OK until the contactor closes and the motor tries to start, right? If the contactor is rated for 95-190 Volts, it should hold in at less than 95 Volts.
I suspect that the coil may have turn to turn shorts and be failing. That would explain the severe voltage drop during starting.
Another strong possibility is high resistance in the control circuit. A quick check is to check the voltage from each transformer terminal to the corresponding coil terminal. If the circuit is good the voltage drop should be nil. A bad connection or, more likely, contacts going bad in an overload relay will show up as a voltage drop when the coil tries to pull in.  

Bill
--------------------
"Why not the best?"
Jimmy Carter

RE: Easy fix for AC Motor Starter Chatter?

Before we too far afield here chasing phantoms, you have not really described the entire picture adequately for us to be making any real suggestions yet in my opinion. We know very little about how you are powering this. A couple of things jump out at my right away:

1) What size transformer did you use to step up from 208 to 480V? A really common mistake people make is to ASSume that all you need to cover is the motor FLC, probably around 115A at 480V? If you made that assumption and installed a 112.5kVA transformer (rated 135A), it's way way too small. It's not going to be able to handle the starting current of an 80HP motor going across-the-line, so it will saturate as soon as the motor gets to LRC and the PRIMARY voltage at the CPT will drop precipitously, maybe too fast to be captured by your meter. What size the CPT is becomes irrelevant at that point. For an 80HP motor starting X-Line, I would recommend at LEAST a 225kVA transformer.

2) How are you feeding that transformer on the 208V side? 80HP at 208, PLUS the losses in the transformer, is going to equate to about a 250A feeder circuit which means the cables need to be 350kCMIL even BEFORE you start allowing for voltage drop over distance. Any appreciable distance and you might be looking at 500kCMIL cables! That is not in the least bit trivial. Undersized cables will seriously increase the likelihood of a voltage drop on start up.

Please describe the WHOLE installation in detail before chasing symptoms instead of problems that exist elsewhere.

"Dear future generations: Please accept our apologies. We were rolling drunk on petroleum."
— Kilgore Trout (via Kurt Vonnegut)
  
For the best use of Eng-Tips, please click here -> FAQ731-376: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies  

RE: Easy fix for AC Motor Starter Chatter?

Another thought. What do you mean by "Chatter"? Most of us think of chatter as small magnitude vibration that may be annoying but may be harmless. With chatter the load stays energized. The frequency of chatter noise is often 120 Hz.
On the other hand, "Machine Gunning" is much more serious. It is the rapid pull-in and drop-out of a contactor and the repeated energization and de-energization of the load. The frequency of machine gunning is much slower than chatter. This is often a sign of seriously undersized cables or transformers as jraef has mentioned.

Bill
--------------------
"Why not the best?"
Jimmy Carter

RE: Easy fix for AC Motor Starter Chatter?

Never heard it described as "machine gunning" but I have to admit, it's a better description than "chattering" if you have ever experienced it.

"Dear future generations: Please accept our apologies. We were rolling drunk on petroleum."
— Kilgore Trout (via Kurt Vonnegut)
  
For the best use of Eng-Tips, please click here -> FAQ731-376: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies  

RE: Easy fix for AC Motor Starter Chatter?

IMO, Chattering and Machine Gunning is exactly identical.  No difference.  I can't conceive of what anything else would be, that could be less serious.

A "Buzzing Relay" would just be that.  A fist full of reasons.  Annoying as hell but not likely to result in a fatal result right away.

Keith Cress
kcress - http://www.flaminsystems.com

RE: Easy fix for AC Motor Starter Chatter?

(OP)
Some more info...

The "Chattering" in this instance I am referring to could best be described by the result if we were firing the motor starter rapidly from an output so fast that the motor doesn't get a chance to turn.

Power System - seems the installation is a little goofy in my opinion.  The 208 service has paralleled 250kcmil off of parallel 200amp breakers.  This must have been the electricians attempt at a 400 amp feed?  This is fed through a main disconnect to the 225KVA 208:480 XFMR.  4/0 wire is then run from the XFMR as the main 480 power feed to a machine mounted disconnect with only 60amp fuses in it.  

Though the wire sizing is legal for the protection levels, it would appear to be undersized for the load (factory label says 81Amps).  That being said, we haven't blown any fuses or tripped any breakers.  Using a clamp, we measured the current on the primary and load side of the large XFMR.  196A was largest seen on primary and 86A was largest seen on secondary.  These readings were taken during the time when the compressor actually engaged and ran.  Data during the chatter is unknown.

Lights in the entire building dim and flicker during the chatter as well.  No issues if it happens to pull in immediately. I am told the main feed from the pole is on a 600amp service of 208 3ph.


Marc Whitney
www.thelogicongroup.com

RE: Easy fix for AC Motor Starter Chatter?

Now, it sounds to me like the whole building has a voltage drop problem. You mention "from the pole". The building is likely on three pole mounted transformers and it wouldn't surprize me if the utility only brought in something like a 1/0 overhead. It's funny how you need a stack with dual 3/0 or 4/0 on your building yet then the utility connects a puny little wire to it.

Overall, the power system sounds like it's basically not suitable to full-voltage start that motor. A UPS or a constant voltage transformer are likely your only possible solutions. I would highly recommend you use an online sinewave output UPS. I have seen cheaper switching ones, even with a sinewave output, cause their own issues.
 

RE: Easy fix for AC Motor Starter Chatter?

I agree, if the lights in the entire building are flickering, the problem may go beyond this machine or the feed to it. But the lights may also be flickering as a RESULT of the contactor chatter too, keep that in mind.

I don't think your meter is adequate for the task at hand though. An 80HP 460V motor starting across-the-line like that should be showing you 550-660A peak, regardless of the load on it at start-up. If you are only seeing 86A on your meter it is obviously too slow to be of any use for this kind of troubleshooting. Either that or you are not using the "Peak Hold" function (assuming it has one). If you are using Peak Hold and it is still only showing 86A, it's useless. I still think this is a starting current / system capacity issue, you just don't have the necessary tools to see it.

By the way if that contactor has been chattering / machine gunning like that for more than a few minutes, the contacts may already be toast. Nothing destroys contacts faster (short of a direct lightning strike). I've seen them burn in as few as 3 start attemps like that. Be prepared, order the replacement contacts now before a shutdown costs you production time or they weld and create a safety hazard.
 

"Dear future generations: Please accept our apologies. We were rolling drunk on petroleum."
— Kilgore Trout (via Kurt Vonnegut)
  
For the best use of Eng-Tips, please click here -> FAQ731-376: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies  

RE: Easy fix for AC Motor Starter Chatter?

(OP)
I asked the electrcian to test the system this morning with an inverter he had on his truck 12vdc - 120vac and it worked like a champ.  External 120vac that isn't subject to the dip seems to have solved the problem.  I have ordered a constant voltage power conditioner with high hopes.  I will post results once complete.  

Thanks to all!


Marc Whitney
www.thelogicongroup.com

RE: Easy fix for AC Motor Starter Chatter?

Quote:

I have ordered a constant voltage power conditioner with high hopes

I would use a true UPS with an inverter fed from a battery that is floating on a charger.  

Not sure a power conditioner is going to keep the voltage up well enough when the source voltage tanks.   

David Castor
www.cvoes.com

RE: Easy fix for AC Motor Starter Chatter?

I don't know why you guys are so strong on the UPS recommendation.  They require battery replacement or complete replacement every few years.  In an industrial environment where preventive maintenance is always "tested", the UPS will likely run to failure resulting in more contactor chatter when the battery fails.  The CVT will be there for 20+ years without giving it a second thought.  They have suprising voltage hold up capability depending on loading.  Even at full load, 80% input voltage provides 100% output continuously.  

Their disadvantage besides generating heat and being extremely inefficient is they have no fault current capability.  Max output current is basically the rated load output so it will not clear protective devices.
 

RE: Easy fix for AC Motor Starter Chatter?

Laplacian,

If it can support the voltage, it's probably a good solution.  I don't have any confidence that we actually know what the voltage is dipping to.  

I don't actually like the UPS solution for a lot of reasons, but it will definitely work, as the OP has already proved.  The CVT may or may not work.  Seems like an expensive experiment.

The real solution is to get a bigger source or put in a reduced voltage starter or VFD.  

 

RE: Easy fix for AC Motor Starter Chatter?

In my opinion the UPS solution is like trweating pneumonia with cough syrup. It may take care of a symptom but it's not taking care of the problem.

FWIW.

RE: Easy fix for AC Motor Starter Chatter?

My recommendation for a UPS is only to prove/disprove a screwed up contactor.  Not a permanent solution.

Keith Cress
kcress - http://www.flaminsystems.com

RE: Easy fix for AC Motor Starter Chatter?

Regarding the UPS - Sometimes, you have to work with what you have even if that not the preferred solution.

I personally don't feel a CVT is such an easy solution either. Capacitors often fail well inside 20 years.
 

RE: Easy fix for AC Motor Starter Chatter?

Here is another idea.  Use a quite high boost transformer (maybe double the voltage) with a resistor in series with the relay.  The resistor is selected to supply nominal voltage to the MCR when things are back to normal.  An ON DELAY relay is powered in parallel with the MCR.  The relays NC contacts short out the resistor for a boost and then open after motor is up to speed. On delay must be a relay type and universal voltage type capable at the higher voltage.  Creates a little heat but uses all standard components.

I worked on a friends Miller welder years and they used (I think)a lower voltage MCR with a resistor in series to handle line drop.  Thought it interesting at the time.

RE: Easy fix for AC Motor Starter Chatter?

(OP)
******************  RESOLUTION  *******************

SUCCESS - with a 500VA power conditioner.  Wired 120vac from exisitng 300VA control XFMR through new power conditioner from Sola and fed 120vac for the system.  Works like a champ.  Special thanks to Laplacian for the early suggestion.

I was not on site to monitor or inspect the resulting voltages but my electrician called to indicate 100% success and no sign of chatter in the starter.

Thanks to all for the information.  I have learned a lot!


Marc Whitney
www.thelogicongroup.com

RE: Easy fix for AC Motor Starter Chatter?

Thank you for the update, Logicon.

Bill
--------------------
"Why not the best?"
Jimmy Carter

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources