×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Concrete Surface Defect - Reinforce Pattern Shows on Surface

Concrete Surface Defect - Reinforce Pattern Shows on Surface

Concrete Surface Defect - Reinforce Pattern Shows on Surface

(OP)
We have a project in which the reinforcing pattern is showing in the surface of the concrete after it has set (photo attached).  The clear cover over the reinforcing is 2 inches.  Does anyone have any idea why this is occurring and how to prevent it?

RE: Concrete Surface Defect - Reinforce Pattern Shows on Surface

This is slumping or settlement over the rebar.  Usually caused by segregating mix or segregation caused by over-vibration during placement.  I would also bet that your cover is not as required.

This can be prevented by using a lower water-cement ratio and controlling the slump of the mix.  Over-vibration is also a common cause.

Check the actual cover on the rebar.

RE: Concrete Surface Defect - Reinforce Pattern Shows on Surface

If I were on the gameshow "The Price Is Right", I would put in a bid of 3/4" cover.

RE: Concrete Surface Defect - Reinforce Pattern Shows on Surface

(OP)
Thanks for the feedback!  The clear cover over the reinforcing is definitely not the issue here (photo attached).  The top mat of reinforcment is set to elevation with a laser and the top of concrete is at elevation.  Slump is just under 4" prior to plasticizer being added on site.  Only half the maximum dosage of plasicizer is being used.  Our resident engineer doesn't think over-vibration is the issue, but he will watch more closely during subsequent placements and finishing operations.

RE: Concrete Surface Defect - Reinforce Pattern Shows on Surface

What size is your coarse aggregate?  
What is the slump after Super-P addition?
Why are you adding plasticizer at site?  What brand?
How is it being added?

RE: Concrete Surface Defect - Reinforce Pattern Shows on Surface

How thick is the slab?  Is there cracking along the bars?  I doubt that over vibration is the issue, as plastic settlement problems are normally associated with under vibration.

RE: Concrete Surface Defect - Reinforce Pattern Shows on Surface

(OP)
Answers to questions:

Q: What size is your coarse aggregate?
A: ASTM C33, No. 57 (from 1" to No.4).

Q: What is the slump after Super-P addition?  
A: Slump not taken after the addition of Super-P.  Half the maximum recommended dose is being used.

Q: Why are you adding plasticizer at site?
A: Monitor slump prior to the addition of Super P.

Q: What brand?
A: DARACEM 55 by Grace.

Q: How is it being added?  
A: Measured in a calibrated container and then added to the drum and thoroughly mixed.

Q: Is there cracking along the bars?
A: No.

Q: Slab thickness?
A: 20 inches.
 

RE: Concrete Surface Defect - Reinforce Pattern Shows on Surface

Another question...hard to tell from the photos, are there ridges or valleys over the bars, or is there just a variation in colour?

RE: Concrete Surface Defect - Reinforce Pattern Shows on Surface

(OP)
There are valleys over the bars.  

RE: Concrete Surface Defect - Reinforce Pattern Shows on Surface

This fellow had a similar problem, albeit in a slab on grade.  Ron diagnosed segregation, and I agree that the mix is at fault.  I disagree that overvibration caused it, mainly because I have never experienced an instance of overvibration.  It is always undervibration that causes differential plastic settlement in "normal" concrete.
thread507-293677: Concrete Slab Reinforcement Rippling

RE: Concrete Surface Defect - Reinforce Pattern Shows on Surface

1" is quite a large aggregate size and 4" is quite a high slump these could have contributed along with the possibly inadequate vibration.

RE: Concrete Surface Defect - Reinforce Pattern Shows on Surface

csd72,
I doubt those are the reasons.  You could use much larger aggregate in a 20" slab, and 4" slump is pretty standard stuff.  I would look more to the plasticizer...not sure why it was required.

RE: Concrete Surface Defect - Reinforce Pattern Shows on Surface

I typically spec 3" slump for slabs... and with 20", if 1-1/2" agg is readily available, would have spec'd that, too... 1" is not large.

Dik

RE: Concrete Surface Defect - Reinforce Pattern Shows on Surface

Yes, forgot to mention the plasticiser, definately our main suspect, particularly if it has increased the slump above the 4 inches.

RE: Concrete Surface Defect - Reinforce Pattern Shows on Surface

I vote for segregation over the rebar.  Starting with a 4" slump and 1/2 the maximum dose of high-range water reducer, I'd suspect the slump is in the 8-10" range.  At that kind of slump you really need to police the guy on the vibrator in proper use.  Only vertical penetration of the vibrating head into the concrete with no contact to the reinforcing steel or formwork.  If he hits the steel, it energizes the whole mat, contributing to the problem you are seeing.  Vibrator guys normally like to drag the head through the concrete, over the rebar and whatever.  This haphazard approach will not work well in this application with the high slump and a deep cross section.

Greg

RE: Concrete Surface Defect - Reinforce Pattern Shows on Surface

I agree with Ron that the problem is slumping over the rebar.
Overvibration  or vibration of the rebar mat and too high slump of concrete are the main reasons.
Consider dropping the plasticizer and use the coarse and fine aggregates from the same source.  

RE: Concrete Surface Defect - Reinforce Pattern Shows on Surface

Just want to toss this out there to see where it goes.....

My opinion....temperature.  Particularly of the steel before placement, but also of the mix.  We generally use 1 1/2" aggregate in a slab of this thickness to reduce heat.

RE: Concrete Surface Defect - Reinforce Pattern Shows on Surface

(OP)
It was definitely not related to the temperature of the concrete or steel.  Concrete placement began at 5:00 a.m. one morning and ice was added to the mix to keep the temperature within spec.   

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources