Stonehenge: Could You Make A Monument For 5000 Years Service?
Stonehenge: Could You Make A Monument For 5000 Years Service?
(OP)
Just a question:
Stonehenge began to be built between 2500 and 3000 BC, or about 5000 years ago.
If you were charged with making a memorial to commemorate Stonehenge - with today's materials - so that it would be accurate to the north star, the rise and set of the sun at the solstices, the stars, solar eclipses and lunar eclipses in the year 7100 - 5000 years from now, what would you use to build a similar size and shape monument?
How would you set the foundations and material so they would withstand that long in the open air, but still be accurate to the (future) position of the stars? Granted, many stones at Stonehenge have fallen, and it is very crude model, so you'd have the responsibility of not "re-making" the rough outlines we see now, but (for example) you'd have to carve sharp, accurate edges and making the monument so the "bridges" would not fall.
But how would you do the job? If you pour concrete for the foundation, what would you use as rebar to keep the concrete good that long? Would you make everything of stainless steel? Granite and stainless?
Stonehenge began to be built between 2500 and 3000 BC, or about 5000 years ago.
If you were charged with making a memorial to commemorate Stonehenge - with today's materials - so that it would be accurate to the north star, the rise and set of the sun at the solstices, the stars, solar eclipses and lunar eclipses in the year 7100 - 5000 years from now, what would you use to build a similar size and shape monument?
How would you set the foundations and material so they would withstand that long in the open air, but still be accurate to the (future) position of the stars? Granted, many stones at Stonehenge have fallen, and it is very crude model, so you'd have the responsibility of not "re-making" the rough outlines we see now, but (for example) you'd have to carve sharp, accurate edges and making the monument so the "bridges" would not fall.
But how would you do the job? If you pour concrete for the foundation, what would you use as rebar to keep the concrete good that long? Would you make everything of stainless steel? Granite and stainless?





RE: Stonehenge: Could You Make A Monument For 5000 Years Service?
The point was made that the stones have been moved around quite a lot in recent years ... rebuilt if you like. Lintels repositioned, etc.
- Steve
LinkedIn
RE: Stonehenge: Could You Make A Monument For 5000 Years Service?
As to how I'd build it, well I'd look at building techniques that have been shown to last a long time and go from there.
Also, building in a place with low seismic activity, weather that isn't too agressive... would also help.
The real problem is pesky humans wanting to destroy or modify it for some reason. Not sure what you can really do about that.
Sure making the 'blocks' really, really big so they're hard to move has worked moderately well in various places. However, with the technology we have now, one suspects it's not the deterrent it was even a couple of hundred years ago.
What is Engineering anyway: FAQ1088-1484: In layman terms, what is "engineering"?
RE: Stonehenge: Could You Make A Monument For 5000 Years Service?
RE: Stonehenge: Could You Make A Monument For 5000 Years Service?
My understanding is that the ancient Egyptians maintained structures that were anywhere up to 3000 years old. Structures can last a very long time if the people around them want them to. Most structures are actively destroyed either because of warfare, or because someone wanted them replaced with something else.
The critical factors with Stonehenge are that it is a very solid stone structure, and it was abandoned by the the time the Romans arrived. The Celts worhsipped in oak groves not circular temples. Stonehenge predates the Celts, and the Indo-European invasions. We know almost nothing about the people who built it.
I understand it is out in the middle of nowhere, so no one has leveled it and built something else on top of it. Your monument will cease to exist when somebody decides that it is a good site for a Walmart.
How stable is English soil? Maybe Stonehenge was extremely accurate way back when they built it.
RE: Stonehenge: Could You Make A Monument For 5000 Years Service?
Stonehenge is passed by millions of motorists every day. There are plans that get passed and then binned to build a tunnel underneath it to avoid the inevitable damage from huge amounts of traffic.
"middle of nowhere"?
"middle of everywhere" more like.
England is a really small country.
- Steve
LinkedIn
RE: Stonehenge: Could You Make A Monument For 5000 Years Service?
It is next to a throughfare now. The people who built it did not anticipate automobiles.
Here in Toronto, Canada, there is a fancy street called the Bridle Path. Back in the fifties, this was developed with all sorts of fashionable bungalows, designed by name architects, for rich people. Most of these will have a hard time lasting 1% of the time Stonehenge has. They are being pulled down and replaced with the "monster homes" fashionable with rich people now.
Religious sites can last a very long time, at least until the religion becomes unfashonable. Forts last until an enemy captures them and destroys them. Sites in the middle of active cities get built over and over as the city's needs change. In that sense, Stonehenge is in the middle of nowhere.
RE: Stonehenge: Could You Make A Monument For 5000 Years Service?
That worked well for the Egyptians too: "Stay out or the mummy will curse you"*. The bodies were likely still warm when the first tomb robbers broke in.
*or more equivalently to marauding Frenchmen: "$%&%** &$%&& #$%(&^(#$%!"
RE: Stonehenge: Could You Make A Monument For 5000 Years Service?
Check it out on Google Earth if you want.
Sure, it's not in the middle of a city right now, however the factors that decide where large cities are vary with time.
I mean, there were few large permanent settlements anywhere in North America a few hundred years ago, where as now...
What is Engineering anyway: FAQ1088-1484: In layman terms, what is "engineering"?
RE: Stonehenge: Could You Make A Monument For 5000 Years Service?
So, not all ancient structures survive intact; the Parthenon has been bombed out, vandalized, incorrectly restored, etc. Stonehenge is probably an exception; while not necessarily in the "middle of nowhere," England never got invaded by the Ottoman Turks and Stonehenge never had to be used as a weapons storage building, since it wasn't even really a building.
The Sphinx might be considered to be another edifice that dates from more than 4000 yrs ago, but it likewise has suffered erosion, defacement, multiple poor restorations/repairs.
Stonehenge, in actuality, is the 3rd or 6th iteration of a structure, so it too has not really remained intact over the millenia. The main reason reason for the sarsens' and lintels' longevity is that they are basically igneous rocks, which are as good as it can get.
A potential competitor to Stonehenge for future longevity is Mt. Rushmore, which is carved out of granite, and supposedly will only experience about 1 inch of erosion every 10,000 yrs. So, 10 millenia from now, hopefully someone will verify this effect.
TTFN
FAQ731-376: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies
Chinese prisoner wins Nobel Peace Prize
RE: Stonehenge: Could You Make A Monument For 5000 Years Service?
RE: Stonehenge: Could You Make A Monument For 5000 Years Service?
- Steve
LinkedIn
RE: Stonehenge: Could You Make A Monument For 5000 Years Service?
For my money, Avebury is the more impressive monument.
For a serious attempt at concept design for a monument to last that long, try Googling "Sandia 92-1382"
A.
RE: Stonehenge: Could You Make A Monument For 5000 Years Service?
How would you do it?
http://longnow.org/clock/
RE: Stonehenge: Could You Make A Monument For 5000 Years Service?
On the plus side it is a great benefit that modern construction will barely last the lives of the owners.
Thing is, Stonehenge was in the middle of nowhere - when it was built - by today's standards that is.
Reminds me of the American tourists visiting Windsor castle. "Gee that's real cute but why did they build it so near the airport?"
There are a number of chemical plants along the Thames that were built on marshland that no one wanted. Encroachment means that today they are surrounded by housing stuffed full of idiots complaining to their MPs that the chemical plant is too close to their homes.
JMW
www.ViscoAnalyser.com
RE: Stonehenge: Could You Make A Monument For 5000 Years Service?
What is Engineering anyway: FAQ1088-1484: In layman terms, what is "engineering"?
RE: Stonehenge: Could You Make A Monument For 5000 Years Service?
Cheers
Greg Locock
New here? Try reading these, they might help FAQ731-376: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies http://eng-tips.com/market.cfm?
RE: Stonehenge: Could You Make A Monument For 5000 Years Service?
Mike McCann
MMC Engineering
Motto: KISS
Motivation: Don't ask
RE: Stonehenge: Could You Make A Monument For 5000 Years Service?
Then we go through another dark age and all knowlege of these tools disappears. what do you think future generations would do?
Would they speculate as we do, as to how these things were done?
B.E.
The good engineer does not need to memorize every formula; he just needs to know where he can find them when he needs them. Old professor
RE: Stonehenge: Could You Make A Monument For 5000 Years Service?
Several years ago I was sharing a house with a "recreational" smoker and we visited all these places in one afternoon. Or was it one weekend? Where did I leave that car?
- Steve
LinkedIn
RE: Stonehenge: Could You Make A Monument For 5000 Years Service?
US National Cathedral
This took 83 years to build and supposedly will last 1000 years.
RE: Stonehenge: Could You Make A Monument For 5000 Years Service?
According to http
TTFN
FAQ731-376: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies
Chinese prisoner wins Nobel Peace Prize
RE: Stonehenge: Could You Make A Monument For 5000 Years Service?
An important issue with monolithic structures like Stonehenge is that you cannot steal building materials, at least, not without hundreds of people helping you.
RE: Stonehenge: Could You Make A Monument For 5000 Years Service?
Absolutely, that's why there are gaping holes in the Great Wall, and only fragments left of Troy, since not only did the latecomers steal building materials, they simply built on top of the previous ruins. I'm a bit unclear to me how everything flattens out, but supposedly it was done multiple times.
Nonetheless, it would seem that what the OP asks for is not that hard, in of itself, i.e., just build a structure out of granite or similar igneous rock, located on a seismically, and climatically stable site, and KEEP PEOPLE FROM MESSING WITH IT.
TTFN
FAQ731-376: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies
Chinese prisoner wins Nobel Peace Prize
RE: Stonehenge: Could You Make A Monument For 5000 Years Service?
RE: Stonehenge: Could You Make A Monument For 5000 Years Service?
The trick with Stonehenge is that the finished appearance wasn't that alluring. (Some suggest it had a wooden roof at one time).
Plus for a long while no one recognised it for what it was. Some farmer even tried to get rid of the "nuisance stones" by lighting big fires against them but gave up.
The military is a good idea.
Much of Salisbury Plain is/was army test ranges, tank training etc. If they could have included Stonehenge, so much he better. Some of the best wild life habitat is to be found on land used only by the army. They have a low and infrequent impact and when finances are so bad the troops run around pointing guns and shouting bang because they can't afford ammunition, they do even better.
So make sure to pick a site the army likes.
Oh, except if they can afford ammunition in which case don't build above ground. Witness the use of the Sphynx as an artillery target. Large monuments can be to the military what Greenhouse glass is to a small boy with a catapult. Plus the average squaddy isn't exactly a respecter of ancient or modern monuments. I remember visiting a company in an old country house which the Americans had taken over during WWII. Some idiot GI had decided to drive a jeep up the grand staircase and collapsed it. After that its fate was sealed.
JMW
www.ViscoAnalyser.com
RE: Stonehenge: Could You Make A Monument For 5000 Years Service?
Have you had trouble finding the paper? There was an article, I think in SciAm, around the time it published, discussing the monument designs etc. etc. from the Sandia teams.
RE: Stonehenge: Could You Make A Monument For 5000 Years Service?
Nagasaki 1945, after the atomic bomb
Nagasaki 2011, after the earthquake and tsunami
RE: Stonehenge: Could You Make A Monument For 5000 Years Service?
TTFN
FAQ731-376: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies
Chinese prisoner wins Nobel Peace Prize
RE: Stonehenge: Could You Make A Monument For 5000 Years Service?
RE: Stonehenge: Could You Make A Monument For 5000 Years Service?
The good engineer does not need to memorize every formula; he just needs to know where he can find them when he needs them. Old professor
RE: Stonehenge: Could You Make A Monument For 5000 Years Service?
RE: Stonehenge: Could You Make A Monument For 5000 Years Service?
JMW
www.ViscoAnalyser.com
RE: Stonehenge: Could You Make A Monument For 5000 Years Service?
RE: Stonehenge: Could You Make A Monument For 5000 Years Service?
And, to top that off, there's a blog with the same photos and a different story:
http://b
As a further nail in the coffin, there are pictures of the same type of gate surviving the earthquake in northern Japan, and possibly, the same gate in the other photo:
http
However, there's a example of a similar Torii gate that didn't survive the earthquake:
ht
TTFN
FAQ731-376: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies
Chinese prisoner wins Nobel Peace Prize
RE: Stonehenge: Could You Make A Monument For 5000 Years Service?
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Japanese_architecture
And the Chinese developed an earthquake sensor that would both sense the event and give some indication of the direction of event.....htt
and http://
and we should not forget the shaking minarets of Sifahan....htt
Wehave to recognise that modern technology does not mean that earlier cultures were not sophisticated. In many cases the label "primitive" is extremely patronising and very inaccurate.
It is one reason why I was so impressed by the very sophisticated theory of pyramid construction which featured in one of these threads and I was fortunate enough to see a TV show on the theory much later.
Some people may tend to think that when we try to understand early construction that the theories we bring to it are too sophisticated for the time despite being rooted in the "available technology".
We might perhaps consider that the modern engineer is actually handicapped when considering ancient construction methods by the fact that he hasn't spent his entire life living within the ancient construction methods.
The thing that has evolved is knowledge and technology. What we might suppose is that men are no more clever today than in the past. So a clever engineer in any era will perform challenging tasks and push the envelope. Indeed, back then with no 'elf 'n safety and an unlimited supply of materials and cash who knows what they could or could not do?
Hence, if we can visualise a way to do things "within the available technology" we might suppose we are still not as adept in using the available technology as a good engineer of the time might be.
JMW
www.ViscoAnalyser.com
RE: Stonehenge: Could You Make A Monument For 5000 Years Service?
Note that the Japanese have been building structures in an earthquake zone since the beginning of their habitation of those islands, so they should have learned something about building earthquake resistant structures in those thousands of years.
TTFN
FAQ731-376: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies
Chinese prisoner wins Nobel Peace Prize
RE: Stonehenge: Could You Make A Monument For 5000 Years Service?
The Jew's House the Strait.
The Norman House in Steep Hill.
Somehow, the buildings have been perceived as useful for 900 years.
RE: Stonehenge: Could You Make A Monument For 5000 Years Service?
"Good to know you got shoes to wear when you find the floor." - Robert Hunter
RE: Stonehenge: Could You Make A Monument For 5000 Years Service?
Isn't it amazing how precisely the Normans could reproduce a house back in 1170. Of course, there is no possibility I got the URL wrong on one of them.
RE: Stonehenge: Could You Make A Monument For 5000 Years Service?
Norman House Steep Hill
Apparently, both houses have Jewish connections, although the latter house is apparently known as Aaron the Jew's House: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Norman_House And, they both are in the same town.
TTFN
FAQ731-376: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies
Chinese prisoner wins Nobel Peace Prize
RE: Stonehenge: Could You Make A Monument For 5000 Years Service?
http://www.triptojerusalem.com/
- Steve
LinkedIn
RE: Stonehenge: Could You Make A Monument For 5000 Years Service?
What is Engineering anyway: FAQ1088-1484: In layman terms, what is "engineering"?
RE: Stonehenge: Could You Make A Monument For 5000 Years Service?
RE: Stonehenge: Could You Make A Monument For 5000 Years Service?
TTFN
FAQ731-376: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies
Chinese prisoner wins Nobel Peace Prize
RE: Stonehenge: Could You Make A Monument For 5000 Years Service?
JMW
www.ViscoAnalyser.com
RE: Stonehenge: Could You Make A Monument For 5000 Years Service?
JMW
www.ViscoAnalyser.com
RE: Stonehenge: Could You Make A Monument For 5000 Years Service?
RE: Stonehenge: Could You Make A Monument For 5000 Years Service?
RE: Stonehenge: Could You Make A Monument For 5000 Years Service?
- Steve
LinkedIn
RE: Stonehenge: Could You Make A Monument For 5000 Years Service?
What is Engineering anyway: FAQ1088-1484: In layman terms, what is "engineering"?
RE: Stonehenge: Could You Make A Monument For 5000 Years Service?
Maybe they'd better stop messing with it.
JMW
www.ViscoAnalyser.com
RE: Stonehenge: Could You Make A Monument For 5000 Years Service?
Maybe it's making them impervious to all the big Cs. That would be cool...
TTFN
FAQ731-376: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies
Chinese prisoner wins Nobel Peace Prize