×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Partially Fixed Cantilever

Partially Fixed Cantilever

Partially Fixed Cantilever

(OP)
I need to aproximate the deflection stiffness of an "L" shape frame (one with a vertical section supporting a shorter horizontal section - see attached *.png). The existing steel supporting the vertical member (not shown in picture) is assumed to provide complete fixity.

I am going to assume small rotations and deformations to keep it all in the elastic range. For discussion purposes, assume the point load at the end of the horizontal member. I'm using Stadd Pro to validate my equations and I'm clearly missing something; I'm assuming its the partial fixity of the cantilevered horizontal member.

Where:
  Member S1 has length = L1 and IZ = I1
  Member S2 has length = L2 and IZ = I2

Then the vertical deflection at point P2 can be approximated as:
        [Part 1]                    [Part 2]
Delta = (P*L2^3 / (3*E*I2)) + (2 * L2 * sin(P * L2 * L1 / (E * I1)))

Part 1 is simply the fixed cantilever deflection w/ a point load at the end.

Part 2 is the deflection caused by rotation at P1 from the moment applied at P1. The 2 at the front of part 2 is my assumption to account for the partially fixity of member S1.

Where am I going wrong?

RE: Partially Fixed Cantilever

egc,

The first part is right, just a cantilever beam call it Delta1.

The second part should be Delta2 = Theta (L2) where Theta = (Moment (L1))/EI1

And the Moment at P1 is just P(L2)

Then Delta2 = (P(L2)(L2)(L1))/EI1

Total vertical deflection a P2 is Delta1 + Delta2

RE: Partially Fixed Cantilever

(OP)
So your saying that since the angle is small to just use the fact that sin(theta) = theta (Theta is in radians)?

RE: Partially Fixed Cantilever

Yes,

Unless you have deflections which are large compared to the beam lengths then sine Theta = Theta, and Theta is in radians is a good assumption.

If you really think about it, all of our BASIC assumptions of beam deflection theory are that loading remains orthogonal to beam centerlines.

RE: Partially Fixed Cantilever

(OP)
Well I found my biggest issue as I was using the sin(rads) when the code I'm using expects angles in degs. I fixed that and then compared to sin(tehta) = theta and the results are the same (surprise!).

But my calculations and Staad still don't agree. P1 actually deflects horizontally a small amount. This would add an additional rigid body rotation to the P2 deflection so I'm going to add that in and see what happens.

RE: Partially Fixed Cantilever

You asked where you were going wrong.

Quote:

Delta = (P*L2^3 / (3*E*I2)) + (2 * L2 * sin(P * L2 * L1 / (E * I1)))

This should read:
Delta = (P*L2^3 / (3*E*I2)) + (L2 * sin(P * L2 * L1 / (E * I1)))
which for a small angle is approximately equal to:
Delta = (P*L2^3 / (3*E*I2)) + (L2 * P * L2 * L1 / (E * I1))

You had a misplaced factor of 2 in the second expression.   

BA

RE: Partially Fixed Cantilever

(OP)
Thanks but I had already removed the 2.

RE: Partially Fixed Cantilever

The angle has to be in radians, not degrees.  If the angle is in degrees, sin(theta) is not equal to theta.  

P1 deflects horizontally by M1*L1^2/2E*I1 where M1 = P*L2.  The horizontal deflection of P1 does not add a "rigid body rotation to the P2 deflection" as you stated earlier.  It adds a horizontal rigid body translation to point P2 but has no effect on the vertical deflection of point P2.

BA

RE: Partially Fixed Cantilever

(OP)
I forgot that we also have the lengthing of the vertical member so the equation is actually:
Delta = P*L2^3 / (3*E*I2) + L2*P*L2*L1/(E*I1) + P*L1/(A1 *E)

Now I'm within 5% of Staad. Why I can't get closer I don't know.

RE: Partially Fixed Cantilever

My guess would be that Staad is including shear deformation.

BA

RE: Partially Fixed Cantilever

(OP)
Yes it was. Once I turned it off, we're exactly the same. Thanks BA and Brad.

RE: Partially Fixed Cantilever

"partially fixed" cantilever always sounds to me like "partially pregnant"

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources