Comparison industry vs. academia?
Comparison industry vs. academia?
(OP)
I have a good first MS degree, and quite a lot of experience as an 'applied' engineer, but have often liked the idea of research studies, and perhaps even becoming a researcher. This career dilemma has bothered me quite a lot, particularly as I like the very detailed and analytical end of engineering work, which tends not to be what industrial engineering organisations want (often, they send that stuff to Universities), although, paradoxically, industry has to solve problems on real applications, which often have serious complications requiring in-depth analysis.
However, when I look at actual PhD work, it often looks quite divorced from reality - obviously, it can only use open-source material - but also there often seems little effort made to make the link to industrial considerations, in terms of realistic design possibilities, analysing trade-offs etc. Perhaps this is the nature of engineering research. Theses often seem to be written primarily for personal/academic goals (unsurprising), which would not reflect my primary reasons for getting into it, as much as I would fulfil the requirements.
At the moment, I attempt to 'bridge the gap' by undertaking personal study work, to educate myself beyond what I did at university, in order to define my own career in a way that reflects my interest, however, it still feels a bit like I am in a 'no-mans-land'; wanting to do creative analytical work, but unsure whether to stick it out in industry, or make the big leap into a PhD programme. Does this make sense? Is this something others can recognise?
However, when I look at actual PhD work, it often looks quite divorced from reality - obviously, it can only use open-source material - but also there often seems little effort made to make the link to industrial considerations, in terms of realistic design possibilities, analysing trade-offs etc. Perhaps this is the nature of engineering research. Theses often seem to be written primarily for personal/academic goals (unsurprising), which would not reflect my primary reasons for getting into it, as much as I would fulfil the requirements.
At the moment, I attempt to 'bridge the gap' by undertaking personal study work, to educate myself beyond what I did at university, in order to define my own career in a way that reflects my interest, however, it still feels a bit like I am in a 'no-mans-land'; wanting to do creative analytical work, but unsure whether to stick it out in industry, or make the big leap into a PhD programme. Does this make sense? Is this something others can recognise?





RE: Comparison industry vs. academia?
Later I was a facilities engineer and needed a way to predict the timing of a suite of capital expenditures. I approached it by writing a totally bizarre reservoir/wellbore/pipeline model that worked quite well. Along the way I ran into a bunch of things that the conventional techniques reached 70% of potential and I went looking (not always successfully) for ways to make that 90+%.
To have an thoroughly unconventional career in a totally conventional field (Oil & Gas in my case), requires that you personally take control of your activities. When you get an assignment ask yourself "how can I make this better, faster, cheaper, more productive, safer?". And then do what is expected of you very well, while developing (usually on your own time) a strategy to make it better. A few times being successful at that and you start getting first call on all the hard problems. It is a blast.
One last anecdote. Three years before I retired, a friend of mine at our research center was retiring and his boss called me to come to Tulsa to interview for the job and go house hunting. I went and they told me the job was mine if I wanted it, then they described the job (it was all consulting, training, and meetings), I asked "when do I do research?". My friend said "you are doing more research in the San Juan Basin than this whole group put together does, you'd be an idiot to come here". I thought about it and realized that my normal job responsibilities gave me an amazing amount of latitude to do the researchy stuff. I didn't take the job. I mention this because a disturbing number of people in formal research positions (either in colleges or companies) are just over-educated clerks who resent innovation so picking one over the other because of the "opportunities it offers you" is a dead end--you create your own opportunities.
Getting the PhD is still on my list and I expect to start on it when I turn 60 and can start drawing on my retirement savings. This is a long winded way of saying that work and academia do not have to be isolated from each other and neither one is going to give you a damn thing.
David
RE: Comparison industry vs. academia?
TTFN
FAQ731-376: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies
Chinese prisoner wins Nobel Peace Prize
RE: Comparison industry vs. academia?