×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

PWHT of CS Channel with 316L SS Cladding or Weld-Overlay

PWHT of CS Channel with 316L SS Cladding or Weld-Overlay

PWHT of CS Channel with 316L SS Cladding or Weld-Overlay

(OP)
We have a CS tube exchanger (both SS and TS) where CS tubes have corroded.

TEMA type: CKU (channel butt-welded to tubesheet, originally PWHT for Code reasons, not service)
Shell side: hydrocarbons boiling (corrosive agents)
Tube side: high pressure saturated steam
Channel = SA-516-70N, thks = 75mm
Tubesheet: SA-266-2N, forging, thks = 250 mm

To address shell side corrosion, we plan to purchase a new tube bundle c/w channel with:
- 16BWG 316L SS tubing in lieu of 14BWG CS tubing
- 3/8" min. 316L SS cladding or weld-overlay on shellside of tubesheet (to expand 316L SS tubing into the 316L SS layer on TS and prevent corrosive agents from contacting CS)
- 1/4" min. 316L SS cladding or weld-overlay on tubeside of tubesheet (to accommodate strength welding of SS tubes to tubesheet).

I have discussed PWHT of the channel with in-house metallurgists, and they have advised that
- the CS tubesheet forging could be clad with 316L (explosion bonded), or could be weld-overlaid
- than 316L SS layers would be machined
- tube holes pre-drilled (not finished),
- 75mmthk channel but-welded to the tubehsheet,
- channel PWHT'd @ 1150°F c/w 316LSS cladding / weld-overlay
- tube holes finished
- tube-to-tubesheet joints welded.

The have no concerns with sensitizing of 316L SS cladding/weld-overlay. Any advantages of cladding vs. weld-overlay? (cost is not an issue).

Do you see any issues with our plan?
Any comments would be appreciated.

RE: PWHT of CS Channel with 316L SS Cladding or Weld-Overlay

I am in agreement with your in-house metallurgists on the plan. I would go with weld overlay of the tubesheet versus cladding. I prefer cladding in pressure retaining locations where you do not have multiple openings (tubesheet holes). Have you evaluated a solid 316L tubesheet?

RE: PWHT of CS Channel with 316L SS Cladding or Weld-Overlay

(OP)
metengr,

Thanks on your feedback. We also prefer weld-o'lay :) We do not want to go with solid SS tubesheet as it is a CKU type of exchanger (channel integral with TS) and:
1. 316L SS has lower allowable stresses than CS, TS thks would grow, tube-side nozzles c-lines would move.
2. Big and thick H-type channel nozzles would be hard to get in SS (I think) and we need the replacement bundle urgently.

Paramount is to get the sequence of fab. operations correctly. We just want to avoid any surprises after placing the PO as vendors are not responsive at bidding stage. If you could comments of 2 "last" things:
a) We intend to heat-treat U-bends of 316L tubes after forming {that would have been required by the SA-213 spec after forming anyways. Additionally, our internal specification calls for: Non-stabilized low-carbon grades shall be solution heat treated by the electric resistance method (1095°C [2000°F] for 15 seconds, followed by rapid air quench).
b) We will strength-weld SA-213-TP316L with 2 passes to 316L weld-o'lay, and then additionally roller expand the tubes into 2 grooves in CS, and 1 groove in the shell-side overlay. Care will be taken to stay away at least 3/8" from the strength welds, and 3/16-1/4" away from the TS shell-side face.

Thanks again.
 

RE: PWHT of CS Channel with 316L SS Cladding or Weld-Overlay

thermmech;
Here are my comments as you requested;

Quote:

) We intend to heat-treat U-bends of 316L tubes after forming {that would have been required by the SA-213 spec after forming anyways. Additionally, our internal specification calls for: Non-stabilized low-carbon grades shall be solution heat treated by the electric resistance method (1095°C [2000°F] for 15 seconds, followed by rapid air quench).

Agree,with your internal specification.

Quote:

b) We will strength-weld SA-213-TP316L with 2 passes to 316L weld-o'lay, and then additionally roller expand the tubes into 2 grooves in CS, and 1 groove in the shell-side overlay. Care will be taken to stay away at least 3/8" from the strength welds, and 3/16-1/4" away from the TS shell-side face.

I would roller expand first to 8 to 10% wall reduction, 2-pass weld the 316L tube followed by a light tube roll.
 

RE: PWHT of CS Channel with 316L SS Cladding or Weld-Overlay

(OP)
Thanks again!

Quote:

I would roller expand first to 8 to 10% wall reduction, 2-pass weld the 316L tube followed by a light tube roll.
Would it be better to expand a bit less since this is a SS tube which work hardens?

RE: PWHT of CS Channel with 316L SS Cladding or Weld-Overlay

Yes, you can use the lower bound value.

RE: PWHT of CS Channel with 316L SS Cladding or Weld-Overlay

thermmech, something to think about....

The weld / roll process is often done opposite of what metengr describes, i.e. light contact roll to set the tube, weld, full roll. The purpose is to allow gases generated by the welding to escape out the backside of the tubehole to help prevent defective welds.

Regards,

Mike

 

RE: PWHT of CS Channel with 316L SS Cladding or Weld-Overlay

(OP)
SnTMan;
thanks on your comment. I am aware of the issue leading to porosity. We have lots of food for thought on this one.  

RE: PWHT of CS Channel with 316L SS Cladding or Weld-Overlay

thermmech, you're welcome, worth what you paid for it, hey?

Regards,

Mike

RE: PWHT of CS Channel with 316L SS Cladding or Weld-Overlay

(OP)
It will work out, I am sure. If everything was straightforward oil companies wouldn't need engineers but just secretaries and technicians. winky smile

Cheers,
Sean

RE: PWHT of CS Channel with 316L SS Cladding or Weld-Overlay

If it was EASY, anybody could do it:)

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources