×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Liquid Thermal Expansion causing leaks
3

Liquid Thermal Expansion causing leaks

Liquid Thermal Expansion causing leaks

(OP)
Hello,

I have a pipeline of fuel which is currently leaking and I am suspecting that it is due to thermal expansion. I have a section that is closed between two ball valves and then then the ambient temperature increases and the pressure increases to the points where leaks are caused.

I'm assuming the easiest solution is a hydraulic accumulator. Are there any other alternatives?

ps. I need to keep the liquid in the line, so a pressure relief valve is not an option.

Thanks

Gabriel

RE: Liquid Thermal Expansion causing leaks

thermal expansion of the pipe will not increase pressure within the system, only increase stress on the material.  And if your increase in temperature is due to ambient alone these stresses would be quite small.

Whats the process conditions, fluid etc.... this could be one of many different things.

RE: Liquid Thermal Expansion causing leaks

(OP)
The system is a closed circuit, and if the ambient temperature increases, the fluid pressure within the closed circuit will also increase. The fluid is jet fuel and is not compressible.

RE: Liquid Thermal Expansion causing leaks

Ah I see...you could have regulator that vents to a small drum that would basically act as a pressure regulator for the system.

RE: Liquid Thermal Expansion causing leaks

Yes material closed between two valves can heat up and begin to leak at flanges or other connections.  You could put in a relief valve or regulator with a small discharge that relieves back to the supply vessel.  Or clear the line prior to blocking in.

RE: Liquid Thermal Expansion causing leaks

Most likely impractical due to air entrainment and being active vs
passive but at least an alternative. Also assuming the fluid past
the second ball valve is discharged.


What about a third ball valve? Close the loop as usual then close a
third ball valve beyond the second then reopen the second ball
valve. Lower initial pressure lessens thermal effects.

RE: Liquid Thermal Expansion causing leaks

Might be cheapest and possibly effective to expose the pipe (if sheathed or insulated) and paint it white.  

Regards,

SNORGY.

RE: Liquid Thermal Expansion causing leaks

2
A typical jet fuel coefficient of thermal expansion is approx 0.00099 per Celsius degree. This means that a temperature increase of 30 °C will lead to a 3% volume expansion.

Now you can:
1) Prevent thermal expansion keeping the fuel temperature increase as low as possible

2) Consider an expansion tank that would accommodate the expanded volume

RE: Liquid Thermal Expansion causing leaks

Thank You ione.  Yes,

Jmore1,  thermal expansion of both the jet fuel and the pipe will result in a pressure increase, because the expansion modulus of the jet fuel is greater than the pipe's increase in volume for the same temperature difference and the jet fuel's bulk modulus is high, resulting in great pressure increases with only a very small amount of compression of the jet fuel.

galeblanc,  all fluids are compressible.  In fact everything is compressible.  Ask a rock that is 20,000 feet below the Earth's surface, a piece of steel in a bridge pier, or what was 1 cubic foot of seawater at 0 MSL when it finally gets down to a depth of 5000 ft.

What is needed here is in fact a code required device known as a thermal relief valve that is needed whenever fluid in a closed off space (trapped between two valves, etc.) can become heated, when due to ambient temperatures, or emergency conditions, such as fire, arise.

Let your acquaintances be many, but your advisors one in a thousand'  ...  Book of Ecclesiasticus

RE: Liquid Thermal Expansion causing leaks

I agree with ione and biginch, either an expansion tank or modified "seal pot" type device(with vent back to supply). However, biginch, although fluids are compressible, I have to disagree with "all fluids" being compressible. Liquids are only compressible to the absolute slightest degree physically, yes(assuming ideally closed system). But in this application, its way more than negligible.   

RE: Liquid Thermal Expansion causing leaks

willhammett, you were doing better than just fine until you decided to disagree about the all fluids being compressible thingy, then things turned totally pear-shaped.  Ignoring the matter of degree of compressibility, or how compressible a fluid might be or not be, or if its compressibility actually makes a difference to your calculations or not, and if steel is compressible... right?, why would you think a fluid (any fluid) is not.  

But OK, I'll bite.  Which fluid do you think would be an example of your noncompressible theory?  Be sure you know the value of its bulk modulus property before answering.

Is the bottom of the ocean open or closed?  Open or closed doesn't matter, only thing that matters is if there is pressure or not and how many significant figures is important to you.

If water didn't compress, sound would not travel through it, but we all know that water manages to carry sound 6 times faster than air.  How far away can you hear the engine coming when you put your ear on a steel railroad track.

Let your acquaintances be many, but your advisors one in a thousand'  ...  Book of Ecclesiasticus

RE: Liquid Thermal Expansion causing leaks

willhammett,

I agree there are cases where liquids can be considered not compressible, and this implies a certain degree of discretion, which is related to "engineering sensibility".
Anyway I think this is not the case. I think it's worth the effort to take a glance at the FAQ below


http://www.eng-tips.com/faqs.cfm?fid=1339
 

RE: Liquid Thermal Expansion causing leaks

Whatever the piping code requires  would be a starting point, and it might not require the use of a thermal relief valve- such items are required on "pressure vessels", but some piping codes do not treat pipelines as conservatively as do pressure vessel codes. But the original suggestion to install a compressible bladder is not a bad idea.

So either a thermal reilef valve discharging to a storage tank or use of a compressible bladder may be the way to go.

RE: Liquid Thermal Expansion causing leaks

Would not a vertical piece of capped pipe act as an expansion chamber.  Like a water hammer absorber for lack of a better description.

Ted

RE: Liquid Thermal Expansion causing leaks

(OP)
hydtools, yes that was another alternative that i considered but i will most likely opt for an accumulator with a precharge pressure slightly above the max operating pressure. in this case, in normal operation i guess the fluid won't go up the pipe? (sorry if its a stupid question)

biginch, a thermal relief valve is installed in series or you have to install a tee and then link it back to the tank? doesn't it act as a pressure relief valve? do you know of any manufacturers? i am looking at a pipe size of 1-1/2 in. with jet fuel in the lines.

ps. i did some calculations and it's pretty crazy that the pressure rises significantally with an increase in temp. just 2 deg F, will cause an increase of pressure of 180 psi, and 20 deg F will cause an increase of 3600 psi. i didn't think it was that big of a pressure increase. it's no wonder that everything leaks.

RE: Liquid Thermal Expansion causing leaks

Ladies I give you B31.3 p 301.4.2
Fluid Expansion Effects.

Quote:

Provision shall be made in the design either to withstand or to relieve increased pressure caused by the heating of static fluid in a piping component. See also para. 322.6.3(b)(2).

A vertical piece of capped pipe, or any capped pipe, is capped or otherwise closed off, ie. isolated by being trapped between two closed valves, etc. and thereby also presumedly subject to fluid expansion and subsequent increased pressure and even if the capped portion of pipe was filled with vapor (saturated vapor in equilibrium with the fluid below) and the fluid expanded into the vapor space thereby only compressing the vapor, then the pressure would still reach that of the saturation pressure at whatever temp the system had at any given moment, which, if higher than the design pressure, must be relieved in accordance with the above clause.

Let your acquaintances be many, but your advisors one in a thousand'  ...  Book of Ecclesiasticus

RE: Liquid Thermal Expansion causing leaks

opps

Quote:


622.6.3 b-  

(2) For a liquid thermal expansion relief device
which protects only a blocked-in portion of a piping
system, the set pressure shall not exceed the lesser of
the system test pressure or 120% of design pressure.

Let your acquaintances be many, but your advisors one in a thousand'  ...  Book of Ecclesiasticus

RE: Liquid Thermal Expansion causing leaks

(OP)
On a similar topic... The use of a single block & bleed valve only provides a way of isolating the system and incorporates a port to vent trapped pressure? Since this is jet fuel, it would have to be sent back upstream where an open circuit is present and the pressure can be relieved. I guess it comes to the same as installing a tee with a pressure relief valve that sends back upstream in case the pressure increases too high above design pressure.

What about a double block and bleed valve? Would it be useful in our case?

RE: Liquid Thermal Expansion causing leaks

Yes its common to vent the thermal reliefs across a block valve  to a line that connects onward to a main pressure relief going directly to an oily water sump or some other approved point of disposal.  But not across a double block and bleed as those are usually reserved for guaranteeing products do not become contaminated by one leaking across the valve into another product.

Let your acquaintances be many, but your advisors one in a thousand'  ...  Book of Ecclesiasticus

RE: Liquid Thermal Expansion causing leaks

Can't see the need of a block or double block and bleed valve. A thermal relief valve, which is basically a pressure relief valve, does the stuff you need. Check standards API 520 and API 521.

RE: Liquid Thermal Expansion causing leaks

A BB valve isn't required for pressure relief.  He's asking how to vent across one if its there for other purposes, such as preventing product contamination.  Supposedly you could vent to the DBB or SBB cavity and out to a drain as long as the vented fluid could not find its way across to the other fluid.  I'm just saying I'd rather not deal with that and vent across it to  someplace eventually going to a relief header, rather than chance contaminating products.

Let your acquaintances be many, but your advisors one in a thousand'  ...  Book of Ecclesiasticus

RE: Liquid Thermal Expansion causing leaks

I didn't not mean to start a debacle, sorry for bringing up a moot point, the fact that not all fluids are compressible in certain situations does not pertain to this topic and I should not have brought it up.  Thanks for the links ione and biginch.  

RE: Liquid Thermal Expansion causing leaks

Will, as it happens it is one of my biggest triggerpoints.  That said, it's more important to realize that if you have the problem, one needs to know that relief valves are probably going to be required by the design code.  For fluids, you must calculate the pressure of the fluid's volume (volume of the pipe at fabrication temperature) when expanded to max temperature and then restrained to the volume of the pipe at that temperature.  For partially filled pipe segments you should be conservative and assume that they are completely full of liquid.  If you know they can never be completely full of fluid, you must determine the vapor pressure of the fluid at the max temperature you expect to reach.

Let your acquaintances be many, but your advisors one in a thousand'  ...  Book of Ecclesiasticus

RE: Liquid Thermal Expansion causing leaks

(OP)
Biginch, I didn't want to use a Block & Bleed valve as I didn't see how it would solve the problem of thermal expansion in a closed circuit. Do you see how it can be useful? The only option I really see if a properly sized accumulator with a pre-charge just above max operating pressure.

I need to start working on the schematics to really study the situation.

RE: Liquid Thermal Expansion causing leaks

galeblanc, also consider a spring-loaded accumulator, if available, then you don't have to routinely check precharge.

Ted

RE: Liquid Thermal Expansion causing leaks

Is your pipe a pipeline going from city A to city B, or is it a fuel line in some airplane or rocket ship.  We do not like rocket science and keep things simple in pipeline work, so we do not use accumulators.  We us pressure relief valves and relieve to a drain to an oily-water hydrocarbon sump tank.  

Let your acquaintances be many, but your advisors one in a thousand'  ...  Book of Ecclesiasticus

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources