×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Shear Strength of a Concrete Drilled Pier

Shear Strength of a Concrete Drilled Pier

Shear Strength of a Concrete Drilled Pier

(OP)
Anyone have a reference that discusses the shear strength of a straight shaft reinforced concrete drilled pier (caisson)?  ACI-318 specifically excludes them, but I have always used it anyway.  Anyone know of another source?

Thanks

RE: Shear Strength of a Concrete Drilled Pier

ACI 336 "Design and Construction of Drilled Piers". It has equations and nomographs for laterally loaded piers.

RE: Shear Strength of a Concrete Drilled Pier

That's interesting that ACI 318 specifcally excludes them.  That's what I use.  If you're referring to 1.1.5 - I read that as ACI 318 not legally governing teh design of caissons, not that the provisions of ACI 318 don't apply to caissons.  It says that (except for regions of high seismic risk) caissons embedded in ground are regulated by the general building code (which requires some % of steel in the top 1/3 of the caisson, I believe - going from memory).

I believe that, especially for caissons supporting lateral resisting elements and where shear and moment diagrams are provided by a geotech, ACI 318 is perfectly valid to use for the design of caissons.

I use ACI 318 to design caissons for shear and bending.

RE: Shear Strength of a Concrete Drilled Pier

ACI 336 Section 3.3 Strength Design of Piers states, "....may be designed using reinforced concrete in accordance with the provisions in ACI 318...sections 7.10, 10.2, 10.3, 10.8.4, 10.9, and 10.15..."

RE: Shear Strength of a Concrete Drilled Pier

ACI 336 Section 3.3 Strength Design of Piers states, "Design of plain concrete piers is governed by the provisions in ACI 318.1."

RE: Shear Strength of a Concrete Drilled Pier

(OP)
My problem is the piers are in the ground and were designed with no shear reinforcing (ties less than minimum shear steel), yet have large horizontal shears that exceed 0.5*2sqrt(F'c) limit in ACI 318 Chapter 11 for beams.  I am trying to find a way around the 0.5 requirement for beams so I can use the full 2*sqrt(F'c) or some other manner of getting higher shear capacities.  I have already included the axial loads but they are not high enough to get me where I need to get.





 

RE: Shear Strength of a Concrete Drilled Pier

Is there no shear reinforcing at all or just less than ACI's minimum?

How close are you?  Would a slightly higher f'c get you where you  need to be?  Do you have access to the break information for the caissons so you can see if the strength came in higher than spec'd?

 

RE: Shear Strength of a Concrete Drilled Pier

(OP)
The ties might as well be nothing at all, too small and too far apart to realistically count for anything.

If I take everything into account that can help me I am around 2*sqrt(F'c) so bumping up the F'c even another 1ksi isn't helping enough.   

RE: Shear Strength of a Concrete Drilled Pier

What about Shear Friction if there is longitudinal reinforcing?

RE: Shear Strength of a Concrete Drilled Pier

Den32 - I don't think that would work since the longitudinal reinforcement would have to be fully developed past the shear plane to allow shear friction to work.  The shear plane, in this case, can be 3 inches below the top of the pier.

RE: Shear Strength of a Concrete Drilled Pier

I agree with JAE regarding the shear friction not being appropriate here.  

I would even go a step further and say that even if the bar were able to be fully developed in that 3" that shear friction doesn't apply to an inclined shear crack.  Shear friction assumes a shear plane at some assumed crack location.  An inclined shear crack is not a shear plane, it's a principle tensile stress plane.   

It's the same reason you can't use longitudinal beam reinforcement at the ends for shear friction.

RE: Shear Strength of a Concrete Drilled Pier

This might be more of a thought experiment than a practical solution, but is it possible to core thru the center of the pile, install a prestressing bar (grout the bottom, top unbonded), and PT the entire pile so you get to use the prestressed shear values?
 

RE: Shear Strength of a Concrete Drilled Pier

(OP)
PMR06, that is what we plan on doing, but am trying to find a legitimate engineering way around having to do it.

RE: Shear Strength of a Concrete Drilled Pier

If the piles end 1 or 2 levels under street level you may try to pass the horizontal forces to passive push in the corresponding wall. A thorough reexamination of model and path of loads might be required.

If just at ground level you can still count slippage against the friction of the soil if a mat on the piles, or some passive push against the pile caps, if embedded ... of course if appropriate and permissible, that might not be.

You may also try to pass the shear as pure friction, i.e., a coefficient of friction to be developed between pile cap and pile. That of course would be forfeiting entirely the customary practice and usual intent and detail in RC construction, but the mechanism could be considered just to have some other appraisal of what available. Then it might be considered, would the piles stand the applied friction forces? A dynamic coefficient of friction would need to be considered if from earthquake. Everything here adventurous since not really a friction mechanism present, but of shear, and no clear real surface available for the friction.


 

RE: Shear Strength of a Concrete Drilled Pier

Of course if the same shear needs to be passed even through a conceptual mechanism of friction, you are in the same problem for the laterally loaded piles. Only the cases that alleviate the applied shear should be useful to then see as valid a lower available shear strength.

RE: Shear Strength of a Concrete Drilled Pier

An even when passive soil stands to restrain the lateral forces the possibility of the earth being naturally or artificially removed needs to be considered.

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources