×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Check Valve In Relief Valve Discharge Line
2

Check Valve In Relief Valve Discharge Line

Check Valve In Relief Valve Discharge Line

(OP)
A survey of an existing steam relief valve installation shows the 4" valve outlet connected to a 4" discharge line that connected to an 8" vent header to the roof. (There are other lines tied into the 8" vent header.)  There is a 4" check valve in the 4" relief discharge line where it connects to the 8" vent header.  Aside from the backpressure questions, is a check valve in a relief discharge line allowed? I would have thought that there could be a situation where the check valve fails to open.

RE: Check Valve In Relief Valve Discharge Line

2
check valves are not allowed in installations i approve/sign off on.

RE: Check Valve In Relief Valve Discharge Line

Agree with BenThayer.

RE: Check Valve In Relief Valve Discharge Line

Me too.  Just too many ways that they could go terribly wrong.

David

RE: Check Valve In Relief Valve Discharge Line

yes dear........i am fully agreed with zdas04.

RE: Check Valve In Relief Valve Discharge Line

API 520, Part II 5th Ed. Section 6.3 Isolation Valve Requirements does not allow check valves.  It only allows valves that can be locked open.

Aside from the code requirements prohibiting check valves please know that check valves have been known to fail in the closed position.  Imagine that happening in a relieving situation.

RE: Check Valve In Relief Valve Discharge Line

Despite the many concerns listed above, how would you prevent the reverse migration of sour vapours from a flare system back into a sweet package without a check valve?

RE: Check Valve In Relief Valve Discharge Line

You don't comingle sweet and sour streams in your flare header.  

David

RE: Check Valve In Relief Valve Discharge Line

ok, this is just not a practical answer.  Not every facility has isolated flare systems - and if they are, they're often isolated from a LP or HP flare.  If you're lucky, you might get an acid gas flare, but that's often used in lieu of a LP flare.  Bottom line, segregation just isn't always possible in the real world.

RE: Check Valve In Relief Valve Discharge Line

I wonder if continuous inert purging of a header and careful piping layout might let you mix sour and sweet in header?

I'm with David on this - I can think of no situation where a non-return valve would be acceptable in a relief header.

Matt

RE: Check Valve In Relief Valve Discharge Line

ok, don't get me wrong.  I'm not advocating the use of check valves in PSV discharges. I was trying to make a point that we don't always have a choice over how flare systems are segregated when working in existing plants and was looking for some input on how this is dealt with.

The only time I've used a check valve in a flare system is on gas engine starter exhaust that ties into the flare header.  You're correct - no other use of check valves would be appropriate in a code based relief system.

RE: Check Valve In Relief Valve Discharge Line

Let's look at your gas engine starter.  Say the PSV is set at 125 psig.  Now let's say that you are observing a problem developing in the plant that might be solved by putting another compressor in service.  While staging to start the compressor a big PSV lifts and raises the flare header pressure to 200 psig at the point where the engine starter enters.  Now lets say that the starter system exhausts into the flare header between the PSV and the check valve (I know it sounds dumb by itself, but I've seen the near-religous fervor to reduce "greenhouse" gases lead people to interesting decisions).  When you turn the starter on, it will come up against the check valve held closed by the big PSV.  A few seconds later, the starter PSV will lift with no place to go.  A few seconds later you have a 60% overpressure on the starter system and the check valve starts to open.

That scenario is credible and doesn't require unrelated events to happen concurrently.

Flare-header analysis is very complex and needs to consider a really wide range of possible scenarios.  When a new stream is tied into it, the entire analysis is required again.  In a plant where management has decided to bring in a fundamentally different stream, one of the costs of bringing that stream into the plant is an analysis of the flare header and the associated costs of modification.  If you have a sweet-gas plant and the decision is made to add an amine system to handle sour gas, you need to build a new flare header as part of the cost of conversion.

David  

RE: Check Valve In Relief Valve Discharge Line

Interconnecting piping between protected equipment and its pressure relief device shall be free of block valves (unless by locks or car sealing), control valves, and equipment that may fail or stop in a closed in a restrictive position, suchas check valves, expanders, etc. Use of maintenance blinds for equipment isolation upstream of a relief device is acceptable.

RE: Check Valve In Relief Valve Discharge Line

For Sweet vs. Sour isolation, if necessary, put a Sour-rated rupture disk right at the inlet to the Flare header.  Now your Sweet PRV and discharge piping will not see Sour service.

End of the day, its cheaper to rate everything for Sour service, or run two Flare headers.

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources