×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Beam/Column Moment Capacity Ratio

Beam/Column Moment Capacity Ratio

Beam/Column Moment Capacity Ratio

(OP)

While designing special moment frame in ETABS, I have the following situation:

I have 20"x20" reinforced concrete columns supporting 16" Wide x 36" Deep beams on the top floor. Since there is no column above the joint, and at least 3 beams frame into my column at every joint, the Beam/Column Moment Capacity Ratio is exceeded. I would need too big of a column section to get it to work. Please advice as to any other possible solutions.   

RE: Beam/Column Moment Capacity Ratio

What is the problem?  You either increase the size of the column to make it work or you satisfy yourself that a crack in the column is not the end of the world.

BA

RE: Beam/Column Moment Capacity Ratio

BA...right as usual

RE: Beam/Column Moment Capacity Ratio

(OP)
Thanks for your response. But is a crack in the column the only result of not complying with the Beam/Column Capacity Ratio?

RE: Beam/Column Moment Capacity Ratio

I think BA is saying make it bigger bro, and it sucks that you have to tell the architect to bump his wall out a few inches but sometimes we have to do that, even if we already committed to asmaller dimension....

Did you play around with the beam size at all?

Though I don't think its recommended, fixing it at the base and designing the foundation for moment is another option...

RE: Beam/Column Moment Capacity Ratio

If this is a gravity condition then maybe a column with a smaller I would reduce the moment to an acceptable level.

RE: Beam/Column Moment Capacity Ratio

I'll often go to pinned top of the column at the roof level by using minimal dowels centered in the column and some bearing pad material to form a cold joint.  May require a little more reinforcement in the slab/beam structure but better than telling an architect that the top floor columns drive the overall column design.

RE: Beam/Column Moment Capacity Ratio

Are you running the full amount of required positive moment steel at midspan through the beam-column joint?

RE: Beam/Column Moment Capacity Ratio

Regarding the post about cantilevered columns...I'm not sure that's allowed by the code where a special moment frame would be required, I could be wrong. And the literature I've read says it's typically required to hook all longitudinal column bars at the tops of the columns, because the axial demand of columns at the roof basically makes the column act more like a beam than column. So, a hinge will want to form right under the roof framing in the column.

NIST has a good paper on special moment frames.

http://www.nist.gov/manuscript-publication-search.cfm?pub_id=861617

RE: Beam/Column Moment Capacity Ratio

(OP)
I'm not too comnfortable with the idea of assuming a pinned condition at the top but will sure give it a try. PUEngineer I am running the full amount of required positive moment steel at midspan throught the joint.  

RE: Beam/Column Moment Capacity Ratio

In cases where the joint exceeds the 6/5 moment ratio, why not try cutting off some of the bottom steel prior to the joint. At the face of the column, your positive moment capacity only needs to be half of your negative moment capacity.

RE: Beam/Column Moment Capacity Ratio

(OP)
Thank you all for your recommendations.

RE: Beam/Column Moment Capacity Ratio

(OP)
On that same note, what is the difference of having a concrete column below and a steel column above the floor, and a concrete column below and no column above the floor. ETABS does not run the Beam/Column Moment Capacity for the first condition but does so for the second condition. Why is that?

In addition to cutting of some bottom steel prior to the joint and increasing the size of my columns, wouldn't increasing the steel area of reinforcement at each face of the beam help as well?

 

RE: Beam/Column Moment Capacity Ratio

(OP)
I meant at each face of the column to increase the moment capacity of the column.

RE: Beam/Column Moment Capacity Ratio

I'm not an ETABS guy, so I can't really comment on the first. I can say that they sound like they should be treated similarly, because I wouldn't count the steel column above into the strong column / weak beam equation.

Increasing the column strength would help. I assumed you'd done this prior to trying to increase the column size. But the column vertical bars need to be developed according to the beam requirements.

Did you download that NIST paper that I referenced? It's very good, deals with detailing procedures also.

RE: Beam/Column Moment Capacity Ratio

What not redistrubute some of the moment from the connection i.e. top moment into the mid-span of the beam.  I would have no problem reducing the beam top moments at the support by 30 percent and then adding 30% moment into the beam bottom steel as a trade off.

You obviously have to calculate the redistrubtion a bit more accurately than I have outlined.  Will reducing all you beam end moments at the column by 30% be enough to get the column to work for the size you have chosen?  

Your columns seems quite big for roof loadings.  Do you have very long beam spans or cantilevers?

RE: Beam/Column Moment Capacity Ratio

(OP)
FinnB,

I am currently working with the moment redistribution.

Thanks all for all your helpful comments.

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources