×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Cracked CMU Block Repair

Cracked CMU Block Repair

Cracked CMU Block Repair

(OP)
Does anyone know a good method to repair cracked masonary blocks.  I have a situation where I have a block wall that has a almost completely vertical crack, crack goes through mortar joints and through the blocks themselves.  The joints can be tuckpointed, but I am not sure the best approach to repairing the cracked concrete block itself.  See attached picture.

RE: Cracked CMU Block Repair

Looks wider at the top than aat the bottom unless the crack to the right of the door is part of the crack system too.  Interesting that it happened over a door where the wall is weaker in bending from any settlement.

I would suspect that this is a settlement crack and would look for another crack too.  However, it could also be due to temperature - a shrinkage crack.

Best way I know is to seal the crack with a flexible mastic and monitor the crack for further movement to see if iti s due to settlement.   

Mike McCann
MMC Engineering
Motto:  KISS
Motivation:  Don't ask

RE: Cracked CMU Block Repair

I would consider epoxy fill in the cracks.

BA

RE: Cracked CMU Block Repair

(OP)
Yep, crack is wider at the top.

I took a real close look at the area surrounding the crack.  The foundation is in perfect shape.  Also, there is no differential vertical movement between the blocks. So it is not a settlement crack.  Definatly temperature. It is about half way between the control joints. So with the door there, it is the weakest section of wall to resist the cold weather shrinkage.  

Unfortunatly there are cracks similar to this (not as large) all over the building.  So it looks like there is some work that needs to be done.

RE: Cracked CMU Block Repair

Someone makes a graphite (I think) material that is applied with an epoxy.  Supposed to be stronger than the wall.  Sorry I don't have better details

RE: Cracked CMU Block Repair

DWHA...don't rule out settlement.  Wider at the top usually indicates that the ends have settled relative to the center.  It only takes about a 1/4" of differential settlement in 20 feet to cause a crack.  Considering the apparent width of the shown crack, it would only take about a 1/4" on each side to do that.  Not much settlement, but the effect is a bit magnified at the top.  If the crack were caused by shrinkage alone, it would go to one corner of the door or the other...not down the middle.  Further, shrinkage cracks tend to break along mortar joints.

For a permanent repair, break the outer shells, form and pour grout.  Finish won't match so you'll have to stucco or texture coat the side.

Epoxies will work for the repair (Sika SikaDur 32 or similar), but masonry is a bit fickle on rigid repairs...expect another crack nearby.  Mike's approach of sealant and monitoring is a good idea.

The carbon fiber approach mentioned by MikeTheEngineer can be done, it's just a bit expensive and the texture won't match either.  Sika has a carbon fiber product as well. (Carbodur, I believe)

RE: Cracked CMU Block Repair

What will repair of these cracks achieve? If for aesthetics, the repairs will look as bad as the cracks themselves.  Control joints are just straight, planned cracks, and maybe there weren't enough control joints.  Repair or filling of the cracks won't accomplish anything structurally.  If the walls are structurally adequate, why not just make the walls look better by concealing the cracking rather than repairing?  Steel cladding is one way, which has the added advantage of making the wall watertight.

RE: Cracked CMU Block Repair

The crack over the door gets wider toward the top, but the crack to the right of the door gets wider toward the bottom.  Also, there are more cracks just above the door, so I'm not convinced that settlement is a factor.

The only purpose in filling the crack would be for waterproofing, but hokie is quite right that a rainscreen would do a better job.

BA

RE: Cracked CMU Block Repair

Sika does make some amazingly flexible sealants. They cure like rubber and stay flexible virtually forever.  

RE: Cracked CMU Block Repair

What part of the country (seismic, wind, both)?

Actually working on a CMU repair detail right now. And I look at cracks of various widths in CMU every week. They are one of the biggest judgment calls of any forensic engineer, whether or not the cracks are settlement or expansion/contraction related, or long term shrinkage, or a combination of several factors... And does the cracking require repair or is it "normal" settlement cracking, and of a small enough magnitude to not effect the strength.

I think everyone is bringing up good points, because the repair should be based on the cause of the distress and the intended end goal. I think a few overall pics and maybe a sketch that shows dimensions and openings would help everyone, especially in relation to expansion/contraction movements.

Do you know anything about the reinforcing or lack thereof?

I don't like the length, width, and location of those cracks. I am a bit conservative with CMU cracks greater than approximately 1/16", especially if this is a commercial building with walls well over 10ft. Openings already are weakened and have stress concentrations at the jambs. It also looks like there are cracks over the lintel, and that lintel looks like it was CIP with CMU, not a precast, which would make me suspect also.

If this wall is sparsely reinforced, then I'd add vertical bars in solid grouted cells to those jambs if they are not, and maybe adding a couple of horizontal bond beams to tie that crack above the door together may be prudent. I may also add another vertical bar and grout to the left of the downspout and have them sawcut an actual control/expansion joint (inside and out) and of course use a backer rod and elastomeric sealant.

Finally, with forensic and repair jobs, keep in mind that you are going on record with this problem, and I always figure I have bought that section of wall (or whatever it is you were looking at). Any further problems with that section of wall will be your problems too. The owner can always toss your letter or drawings in the garbage but that will be on them, not on you. Don't be afraid to be conservative in this instance with all of the unknowns..

RE: Cracked CMU Block Repair

(OP)
A little info for all to help clarify the situation.  

I did a very close inspection of the foundaion (which is exposed about 2' above grade) and there is definately no differential settlement.  The only cracks in the foundation are hairline.  This is one of the best looking foundations I have seen.  

The repair is to seal up the structure.  It is in a location where no one will ever see the defect.  The door shown is a back door that is never used.

Location is low seismic and normal design wind speed is 90mph.  

Here is a pic of another crack location.  This one is at a corner and the crack is right next to a control joint.

RE: Cracked CMU Block Repair

presuming that the cause of the crack has been determined and rectified, it may be very simple to selectively remove the outer portion of the individual blocks that are cracked and replace with a 4" piece of block, set in mortar.  

RE: Cracked CMU Block Repair

if you think they are shrinkage cracks that may move, you may consider routing and sealing the cracks.   

RE: Cracked CMU Block Repair

Back to whether the wall is structurally adequate with or without the cracks.  Is this wall reinforced at all?  The appearance of the cracks would suggest not.

RE: Cracked CMU Block Repair

(OP)
I have not yet had a chance to determine the reinforcing of the blocks.

RE: Cracked CMU Block Repair

Well, that would be my first step.  No point in sealing cracks if the cracks indicate structural failure rather than just aesthetic nuisance.

RE: Cracked CMU Block Repair

I saw a step crack, I saw a step crack!! :)  In the first picture.

But I would agree the vertical cracks are from the lack of an expansion joint at the corner. The wall has formed the expansion joint for you, I would just make it official.

I think I would still strengthen the CMU around the door, the details depending on the location of grouted cells.

With all due respect, though you may be right about the settlement, I don't agree with this reason to conclude that:

"I did a very close inspection of the foundaion (which is exposed about 2' above grade) and there is definately no differential settlement.  The only cracks in the foundation are hairline.  This is one of the best looking foundations I have seen."

You said it was exposed to 2' above grade, so you have a reinforced concrete stem wall in addition to a strip footing? My point is that if you have a well-reinforced grade beam with a sparsely reinforced CMU wall on top of it, the foundation may show very little distress (cracks held tight as it deflects) while the relatively brittle CMU wall develops many cracks in it.

Just a theoretical point, it may not apply to your case.

   

RE: Cracked CMU Block Repair

It is very easy to determine the vertical reinforcing pattern with a hammer alone.  The sound is very distinguishable as well as the feel.  The size of the bar is another issue, and there are other means for this.

The third photo with the stepped cracking seems to indicate settlement, but the fourth, with it's uniform cracking, shrinkage.

Be mindful, that this could be a combined issue here.  However, until you can determine the cause and nature of the problem, I emphasize the need to temporarily seal the wall with a flexible mastic.  To allow further water penetration will only further compromise the wall.  Sorry BA, but I feel that a rigid seal is not the right thing to do at this time.  Maybe later.

Mike McCann
MMC Engineering
Motto:  KISS
Motivation:  Don't ask

RE: Cracked CMU Block Repair

Okay Mike, you are forgiven for disagreeing with me this time, but only this one time.  From now on, you must tow the line and agree! agree! agree!...O.K.?

BA

RE: Cracked CMU Block Repair

I'll think about it BA...  bigsmile

Mike McCann
MMC Engineering
Motto:  KISS
Motivation:  Don't ask

RE: Cracked CMU Block Repair

Agree with a2mfk...the foundation wouldn't necessarily show any distress from settlement, but the wall would.

Further photos imply other than settlement, but would be good to find actual cause.  As Mike noted, water intrusion appears to be an issue, so seal it, even if it looks awful for a while.

RE: Cracked CMU Block Repair

(OP)
Ok.  I have had a chance to look at the design drawings.  Control Joints are at 48' spacing.  Vertical Cores reinforced at 4' cts with a #5 bars, grouted solid.  Horizontal truss type reinforcing at 16" cts.  There is a CMU beam with a total of 8 - #6 bars (Beam is 3 courses, 24" tall) directly above the door jamb.  

RE: Cracked CMU Block Repair

"There is a CMU beam with a total of 8 - #6 bars (Beam is 3 courses, 24" tall) directly above the door jamb."

That outta hold 'er!!

I wonder what that is about, and if it was built that way. That is not a continuous bond beam, that is just the lintel huh? Something like a mezzanine beam or joist girder in that area? If it was built that way, I guess local deflection of that lintel may be ruled out :)   

RE: Cracked CMU Block Repair

(OP)
A2mfk

Sorry I did not elaborate.  It is a continuous bond beam around the entire structure.  It is not just a lintel.

RE: Cracked CMU Block Repair

Ahaaaa... That sheds some light on the crack over the door, but isn't anyone else surprised by the vertical crack in the first picture by the downspout, through 3 bond beams with 8 #6 bars??

RE: Cracked CMU Block Repair

DWHA:

Did you verify IN THE FIELD that the bond beam is actually there?  It may have been placed for a future mezzanine that was never built, or may have been eliminated if the mezzanine was eliminated.

Mike McCann
MMC Engineering
Motto:  KISS
Motivation:  Don't ask

RE: Cracked CMU Block Repair

(OP)
I did not field verify that the bond beam is actually there.  This info was taken from the as-built drawings though.

RE: Cracked CMU Block Repair

The crack pattern throws considerable doubt as to the presence of a continuous 3 course bond beam reinforced with 8-#6 above the door head.  It would not have been easy to get that much reinforcement into an 8" x 24" CMU beam.  Or perhaps it is 10" x 24"?

The bottom course of the bond beam appears to be less than 8", so the beam height is probably closer to 22" than 24".   

BA

RE: Cracked CMU Block Repair

Control joints at 48 feet is a littttttttttttttle far.  Usually they are in the neighborhood of 25 feet, plus or minus.  This could be the major reason the the cracking seen.

As for the (8) #6 in the 24" bond beam, it is probably there considering the crack pattern seen at the doorway in your photos - they are much tighter together and spread out in the vicinity of the beam, which would be understandable.

Mike McCann
MMC Engineering
Motto:  KISS
Motivation:  Don't ask

RE: Cracked CMU Block Repair

Sorry BA...  Here we go again!  We were typing at the same time.  bigsmile

Mike McCann
MMC Engineering
Motto:  KISS
Motivation:  Don't ask

RE: Cracked CMU Block Repair

In thinking about this more, BA was initially coirrect in his assertion of the problem being temperature related, not settlement.  

What is happening is that the 24" deep bond beam is constraining the cracking just above the door jamb, making it appear that it is settlement related with the varying crack width.  

The problem is temperature related, not settlement.  I'm sure of that now.

Mike McCann
MMC Engineering
Motto:  KISS
Motivation:  Don't ask

RE: Cracked CMU Block Repair

I can't see the difference in crack pattern, Mike, and doubt that all that reinforcement is there.  The 'control joints' are not working, probably just stacked joints, but no actual break in the wall.

RE: Cracked CMU Block Repair

Don't forget, I saw a step crack, i saw a step crack! (second pic)

If I was writing this up I would say that "Settlement is a potential contributing factor to the cracking observed in the CMU walls, but the main contributing cause is likely expansive/shrinkage movements within the CMU walls and a lack of properly placed expansion joints."

That'll be one beer if you use it, uhmmm, Hoegaarden will do.

And I would still do the other stuff I said above, call me conservative but I am not a fan of those cracks. And I'd add expansion joints and filled cells to each side of them, at least where the wall already cracked.

RE: Cracked CMU Block Repair

a2mfk,
Settlement is not the only reason for stepped cracks.  Diagonal cracking at ends of walls is also a typical type of restraint shrinkage cracking.  The footing/stem wall restains the wall at its base, and the body of the wall shrinks up and away from the end.

RE: Cracked CMU Block Repair

Agreed Hokie. But since all foundations settle to some degree, its hard to eliminate it as a contributing factor, even if very minor. But I would also agree the vertical crack above it would also suggest shrinkage.

Doesn't really change the outcome or repair recommendations, just trained now as a forensic engineer where you have to cover every base in your reports because of possible legal proceedings.

RE: Cracked CMU Block Repair

Yeah, I know, I've written a lot of waffle myself.

RE: Cracked CMU Block Repair

Personally, I eat waffle(s).

Mike McCann
MMC Engineering
Motto:  KISS
Motivation:  Don't ask

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources