×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Sensing lift on a wing

Sensing lift on a wing

Sensing lift on a wing

(OP)
I have a proposal that needs to sense the forces on a wing due to air turbulence which either enhances or degrades wing lift.
If I placed many sensors on top and bottom of the wing measuring the force applied to these spots (capacitance change due to air pressure, not G force acceleration), can a computer analysis of those forces give an assessment of the change in lift due to forces caused by turbulence?

i.e. is measuring the forces on different parts of a wing enough to calculated change in lift and then correct for it?

I read the Wikipedia lift description, but couldn't answer my question.

Thanks.  

RE: Sensing lift on a wing

I think strain gauging the spars would be a less haphazard approach.

Alternatively you may well find that detecting turbulence acoustically is a better approach, that's what we do in wind tunnels.

Cheers

Greg Locock


New here? Try reading these, they might help FAQ731-376: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies  http://eng-tips.com/market.cfm?

RE: Sensing lift on a wing

(OP)
This is for tiny UAV's to help them handle turbulence better and auto adjust for it.

My first thought was accelerometers in a few places (4) along the wing, but that seems obvious and probably too simple.

it needs to be ultra light, so a simple printed circuit adhered with flexible adhesive forming an airgap at the sensor so that the turbulence pressure can move the membrane and it's capacitance will change quickly. Similar to a MEM's gforce sensor, but in a printed circuit, which could double as the skin of the UAV.  

with alot of small squares or circles (0.1" to 0.5" sisze) of printed mylar attached to , you could sense the forces along the entire wing surface. Then you have to do something (have a fast processor and adjust control surfaces.

might be a foolish proposal, just looking for some clarity here.

 

RE: Sensing lift on a wing

Isn't mylar film a little bit piezoelectric, like kynar is?

Okay, just skin the thing with kynar; piezo film seems to be available from many sources, in pieces large enough to skin a complete micro-UAV.

Subdividing the metallized faces could work to form individual sensors.  I'd want to compare the weight accrued to arrays of capacitance sensors to the weight accrued to arrays of charge amplifiers, which might be simpler, but troublesome in high humidity.

Sounds like great fun.

 

Mike Halloran
Pembroke Pines, FL, USA

RE: Sensing lift on a wing

Not sure what exactly you are trying to see, but one time worn method is tufts of yarn and filming the patterns with an external camera.  I don't know how scalable that it.  It won't give you quantitative data but will let you identify when and where the areas of interest are.  

RE: Sensing lift on a wing

Maybe not what you are looking for - but I fool around with electric radio controlled helicopters.

You can buy "autopilots" for them very cheaply!!

And they do a remarkable job of stabilizing these very lightweight machines!!

Just a thought!!

RE: Sensing lift on a wing

Do you want to know the local pressures, or the integrated load on the wing ?  why not attach the wing to a small load-cell ?  

when you say "turbulence", do you mean local turbulence (like separated flow, vortex generators, ...) or macro turbulence (like the wake of an airplane, storm, ...) ?

RE: Sensing lift on a wing

With MAVs you don't really care what the lift is doing, just what the plane is doing.  Rather than trying to detect variation in lift between the wings, just detect the roll response to this difference.

You don't need multiple accelerometers across the wing as you said, just one multi axis IMU (inertial measurement unit, basically a bundled accelerometer).  The poling rate of modern arduino based systems are fast enough to correct for even minor changes in orientation, and correct for them before they become noticeable to flight.

If you just want to level out the flight of a R/C type MAV then you can simple use a cheap piezo-gyro.  Put the gyro in line with your ailerons and as the plane begins to bank, the gyro with normalize the response, resisting deviations from level.

Your pressure based method would be very heavy and computationally intensive for a onboard AP system.  I also believe you will have a lot of sensor noise to deal with as the pressure naturally fluctuates of the wing.

-AAFuni

RE: Sensing lift on a wing

(OP)
I'd posted this a half hour ago, but it didn't make it thru.


Here's the verbage of what's needed;
Design a concept for equipping small and micro Unmanned Aerial Systems with equivalent capability to sense and respond to small scale turbulent motions in the atmosphere.

so it seems that micro uav's can't handle turbulence and limits their applicability. The requirements sometime hint that current methods don't work.

rb1957, I believe turbulence is due to wind gusts when you are flying right next to and into a building. These are micro uav's, 12" in size typically.

aafuni, seems like you have experience here. I agree the computational challenge in evaluating 10-20 sensors is a limit, and just a few is much friendlier for a real solution. I'd hazard a guess that the wind gusts affect micro-uav's so quickly that the response time might need to sense forces on the tip of a wing before the wind gust hits the opposite wing (purely a guess).   

RE: Sensing lift on a wing

May I ask what this is from?

RE: Sensing lift on a wing

(OP)
It's a SBIR for the Army.
sometimes the requested technology is pie in the sky and totally unrealizable, but that's partly the nature of SBIR's. Asking for new technology.

Topic Number:      A11-015 (Army)
Title:  Direct Sensing of Micro Unmanned Aerial Vehicle Lift
 

RE: Sensing lift on a wing

that sounds interesting ...

is the problem that inertia effects are swamping aerodynamic effects ?  is the gust picking up the UAV like a toy (such as it is) and throwing it ?

or is it an aerodynamic problem ?  is the gust acting on the UAV like a micro-burst, essentially stalling the wing ??

or both !? wing stalls so there's nothing to react the inertia load (so Newton takes over, and the UAV accelerates out-of-sight), or vice versa ?

intersting, verryy interesting

RE: Sensing lift on a wing

I'm not convinced that current UAVs can't "handle" turbulence.  The issue, invariably, is SWaP, so they could probably do it, but it might be too large, too heavy, or too power hungry or all three.  Even a simple quartz rate gyro might be too much weight penalty.  

Certainly, UAVs in the Shadow-class and above can deal with whatever comes along.   

TTFN

FAQ731-376: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies
Chinese prisoner wins Nobel Peace Prize

RE: Sensing lift on a wing

(OP)
I really can't answer the questions rb1957.I'd expect all your assumptions are correct.

These microuav's fly through turbulence just inches away from structures and the ground. I'm guessing that's the challenge. Reaction time needs to be quick, and they also have to be able to take a hit, then restart.

Sounds like one could improve in the flight characteristics for normal turbulence, but to stop a gust from blowing a microuav into a wall from 10 inches away sounds impossible. I think it'll need to fly backwards too.  

It feels to me like that improvement is what they're looking for, not a solution.  

RE: Sensing lift on a wing

how do yo guys calc stability for microUAVs ?  it's an awfull long time since i did an aero. calc, but i remember (perhaps faultily) that conventional airplane configurations (tailplane, or canard) are stable (ok, not always) ie the H.Stab naturally counters the up-set moment due to a gust.  now i imagine in this app you're looking at flight-path deviation which would be less for a more stable plane, yes?  if this fixes your problem, it'll create another ... the damned thing will be too stable and won't want to maneouvre ! ... maybe varible stability ??

RE: Sensing lift on a wing

thinking about this problem, i think you want to control the flight-path; i think it's less of a problem of lift force.  i don't think you can create a driven system that will sense the gust and react quickly enough to prevent an excessive deviation from the flight-path (ie crash into the building inches away).  i think you need novel aerodynamic solutions, like the Virgin galatic sub-orbital plane ... with it's variable configuration (the tails can unlock and rotate about the fuselage to create a high drag return mode).

maybe you wnat something like blow-out panels in the wing surfaces, so that the high pressure of the gust isn't reacted by the wing surface (and so doesn't affect the airplane's CG ??

RE: Sensing lift on a wing

(OP)
Just heard from the tpoc.
They want a sensor set to add to the body of the  micro uav. No particular microuav has been designated.

Once in place, they'll later develop the control computer to adjust the control surfaces.

rf1957, I think you're correct, something novel is needed.

But designs of microuav's take a long time to get results. This is a low budget "see if you can make a sensor" project.

 

RE: Sensing lift on a wing

A variation of the idea floated about using the wings themselves as sensors might be interesting.  Accelerometers used in pairs can be used to measure angles, and the long lever arms of the wings would add to the sensitivity of the combined sensor.  If the accelerometers can be directly incorporated into the wing structure, the added weight might be minimal.

TTFN

FAQ731-376: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies
Chinese prisoner wins Nobel Peace Prize

RE: Sensing lift on a wing

Yup, I think we've been distracted. The problem is not sensing turbulence, the problem is maintaining the flight path in the presence of turbulence. It may be that sensing turbulence is the best way of achieving that, but it seems to me that a more powerful stability system is a more conventional approach.

Cheers

Greg Locock


New here? Try reading these, they might help FAQ731-376: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies  http://eng-tips.com/market.cfm?

RE: Sensing lift on a wing

Greg I agree, but if you read the link the problem is directly stated to be to measure wing lift.  It is a SBIR, that is specifically asking for wing lift detection for mavs.

RE: Sensing lift on a wing

i doubt that any control system will be fast enough ...  sense, analyze, react, reaction takes effect ...

maybe something in the piezoelectric line ?

my sense is that the micro uav is getting blown about by the gusts, scaling things a 10fps gust on a mUAV would be equivalent to a 100 fps gust on a plane, maybe worse ??  you might see this if you measure pressure on the gust side and on the other side of the wing ... very high pressure on the gust side, low pressure on the other.

RE: Sensing lift on a wing

A lot of the talk here has focused on detecting lift on a "wing" as in those on a fixed wing aircraft. But Higgler mentioned flying in and out of building this would lead me to believe we are talking about rotorcraft?

If we are talking about up and or downdraft on a mUAV nearing a wall what about measuring the load resistance on the electric motors?

RE: Sensing lift on a wing

(OP)
The proposal says microuav and discusses Lamb vector measurement on the wind/body. There is no mention of rotocraft.

from the proposal request
PHASE I: Identify and define the potential of such biologically inspired sensors to more directly sense the critical parameters controlling lift, including total circulation or the integrated Lamb vector. Design a concept for equipping small and micro Unmanned Aerial Systems with equivalent capability to sense and respond to small scale turbulent motions in the atmosphere   

RE: Sensing lift on a wing

If you could see what the air was doing before the UAV entered it then you could make decisions.  Maybe Doppler Radar?  

It and the computer and software would probably be more expensive than the UAV but then this is the military.

RE: Sensing lift on a wing


 My suggestion (for what it is worth) is to attach small strain gauge-like "feathers" to the wing surface. This would mimic a bird wing where I suppose the bird has some input as to when the feathers move out of their streamlined position, indicating stall or reversed airflow.
Lots of input channels, but who said it would be easy?
See attached sketch. I do not know if weight will be a problem, maybe you would need to develop the "strain-feathers" as a separate project. Sounds like a lot of fun...

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources