INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS
Come Join Us!
Are you an Engineering professional? Join EngTips now!
 Talk With Other Members
 Be Notified Of Responses
To Your Posts
 Keyword Search
 OneClick Access To Your
Favorite Forums
 Automated Signatures
On Your Posts
 Best Of All, It's Free!
*EngTips's functionality depends on members receiving email. By joining you are opting in to receive email.
Donate Today!
Do you enjoy these technical forums?
Posting Guidelines
Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Multivariable regression in Excell

wcmzsp (Civil/Environmental) 
9 Dec 10 11:59 
Does anyone have any suggestions how to do a multivariable and power regressions in Excel and calculate the coefficients and some statistical characteristics of the fitted equation?
For example: y=a*x1+b*x1*x2^c Here, x1, x2 are the independent variables; y is the dependent variable; a, b and c are coefficients.
Any suggestions for this one?
Thank you,
Fang 

Clyde38 (Electrical) 
9 Dec 10 13:12 

katmar (Chemical) 
9 Dec 10 13:15 
Fang, a very useful and powerful regression capability is already built into Excel. MicroSoft seem to enjoy making their help files as unhelpful as possible, and if you just type "regression" into the help search box it is unlikely you will find what you really want. The trick is to type "Analysis Toolpak" into the help search box, and then all will be revealed. In the default installation of Excel this Toolpak is not installed, but the Analysis Toolpak entry in the help file explains how to install and then use this function. A very nice feature of Excel is that you can then set up a table to use the calculated regression coefficients to see how well the curve fits the data  especially if you make a scatter chart of the data. As soon as you calculate the coefficients the graph is updated and gives you a very clear idea of how good the fit is. As you, for example, change the degree of the fitting polynomial you can see how the fit improves (or not!). The help file (as I remember it) talks about multivariable regression. For polynomials just use x, x^2, x^3 etc as the different variables. Katmar Software Engineering & Risk Analysis Software http://katmarsoftware.com 

First thing I notice is that in your example you have:
a*x1 + b*x1
This is the same as (a+b)*x1, so without more information the best you can do is find (a+b), but not an exact value for a or b.
For example, say a+b = 10. Your function will be the same for:
a=1, b=9 a=10, b=0 a=5.23, b=4.77
There is no way to determine which values of a and b are correct for the equation you provide.
So, step one is to determine if you NEED to know both a and b, or if just knowing the sum of a and b is acceptable. If you need a single solution for a or b, you need more information than just the equation you provided.
 MechEng2005 

Denial (Structural) 
14 Dec 10 16:12 
Unless there is a typo floating around somewhere, Wcmzsp has actually asked for a form of hyperbolic regression. Spacing it out to make it a bit clearer, he wants Y = a*x _{1} + b*x _{1}*(x _{2})^c This cannot be handled by Excel's inbuilt regression capabilities. However the values of the coefficients a, b and c can be estimated by converting the problem into a minimisation exercise and using the Solver to achieve the minimisation. The approach is spelled out / discussed (albeit in a different context) in the following two posts thread77082805: Higher order polynomial trendlines in Excelthread770231694: Excel Trend LineHowever this approach will not give you the statistical characteristics of the resulting regression. I cannot offer any suggestions for those. (But I'm all ears...) 

Oops. I misread the equation. Disregard my previous post. Sorry.
 MechEng2005 



