×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Do torsional shears add to overturning moment for shear walls?
2

Do torsional shears add to overturning moment for shear walls?

Do torsional shears add to overturning moment for shear walls?

(OP)
I have an 8 storey structure with a rigid diaphragm.

The lateral load resisting system is a RC core at the centre.

I only have to resist wind loads. No seismic.
Assume the building is square with plan dimensions of 100' x 100' and the core is 4 walls with dimensions of 20'x20'.
And the floor to floor height is 10'.

Let's say the wind load per floor is 10 kips. So each wall takes a shear force per floor of 5 kips.

Let's not consider torsion for a moment and look at only ONE of the shear walls.
The cumulative direct shear force at the bottom floor would be: V = 40 kips (= 10kips /floor * 8 floors / 2 resisting walls in that direction)
The overturning moment would be: M = 1800 kip-ft

Now consider torsion.
There will be some accidental torsion on the structure. My Canadian code says to use 10% of the width. e = 10ft
So the torsional moment per floor is 100 kip-ft
The cumulative torsional moment at the bottom floor is: T = 800 kip-ft.
Converting this torsional moment is equivalent to a shear force of 20 kips.

Now my questions are:

1. When designing a wall at the first floor, I would design for a M = 1800kip-ft and a total shear force Vtotal = 60 kips?
Or, should I take the shear force due to torsion, 20 kips x the floor height, and add this to the overturning moment so the loads become M = 2000 kip-ft and V = 60 kips?

2.
If you analyze it a different way, and you convert each storey's torsional moment to shear force per floor, that would add 2.5 kips to each wall per floor.
But if the shear force per floor is now 7.5 kips (= 5kips direct shear + 2.5 kips torsional shear), then the moment at the base would be: M = 2700 kip-ft. Quite a big difference compared to 1800 kip-ft or even 2000 kip-ft.
The total shear force at the bottom would still be 60 kips.

What is correct?

Thanks for your help.
  

RE: Do torsional shears add to overturning moment for shear walls?

For one wall, using your numbers, I get (40 + 20) x 40 = 2400 ft-k.

RE: Do torsional shears add to overturning moment for shear walls?

Torsional moments should be converted to additional shears at each floor and moments at the base would be cumulative based on the direct+torsional shear applied at each floor.   

RE: Do torsional shears add to overturning moment for shear walls?

(OP)
WillisV,
That's what I suspected....

I was doing it wrong. I had taken the cumulative torsional moment and then converted that to a torsional shear and then used that multiplied by a single floor height to get an overturning moment due to torsion at that floor.

Instead what I should be doing is what you have stated.
  

RE: Do torsional shears add to overturning moment for shear walls?

Would'nt the torsional moment result in opposing shears for a shear wall, which would then end up canceling each other for overturning moments at the base? Am I missing something?

RE: Do torsional shears add to overturning moment for shear walls?

slickdeals,
The torsional moments do offset globally, but when considering just one wall, the torsional moment adds or subtracts in a given load case.

RE: Do torsional shears add to overturning moment for shear walls?

(OP)
Slickdeals,

This is the way I understand it.

The torsional moment (twisting moment) is converted to a shear force per floor. Call it the torsional shear. This acts along all 4 walls in my example.

This torsional shear would ADD to the direct shear for one wall, because the torsional shear and the direct shear are in the same direction.

But for the other wall, the torsional shear is in the opposite direction as the direct shear.

However, I still have to design the individual walls for the combined effect of direct shear + torsional shear.

But for OVERALL or global building overturning, the torsional shears would cancel each other out.


 

RE: Do torsional shears add to overturning moment for shear walls?

Understood. The shears on each wall segment will be higher due to torsional shear + direct shear, but the overall overturning moment on the wall is independent of the amount of torsion in the wall. Right?

RE: Do torsional shears add to overturning moment for shear walls?

Not exactly.  The global overturning is unchanged by eccentricity, but the individual walls see increased shear.  If a wall carries more shear, it also carries more moment.  Of course, in a core it is more complicated than that, as intersecting walls form flanges, etc.

RE: Do torsional shears add to overturning moment for shear walls?

If the core is a monolithic concrete tube, then we are essentially analyzing a cantilevered tubular beam subjected to an eccentric point load at each floor.  The analyses noted above assume all four walls act independently, which would be unusual for a core.

RE: Do torsional shears add to overturning moment for shear walls?

AZengineer,
No, the analyses indicated above are precisely with all the walls acting as a tube.  I don't think you can say anything is unusual in a core.  There are concentric cores, eccentric cores, coupled cores...the imagination of architects is unlimited.

RE: Do torsional shears add to overturning moment for shear walls?

(OP)
Thanks for all your respsonses.

So just to sum up:

Torsional moments should be converted to additional shears at each floor and moments at the base would be cumulative based on the direct+torsional shear applied at each floor.    

And using my example, for each wall:
The direct shear per floor = 5 kips.
The torsional moment per floor is 100 kip-ft.
This torsional moment converted to a shear force into each wall per floor = 2.5 kips.
Total shear force per floor = 7.5 kips

At the base of the wall, M = 2700kip-ft and V = 60 kips

 

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources