×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Heat recovery ventilation unit
2

Heat recovery ventilation unit

Heat recovery ventilation unit

(OP)
Hi ,

I am designing  the ventilation  system for a condo building,  I am using a heat recovery ventilation unit  to recover  the energy  from the bathroom. Do you think I need to add an electric duct heater for the cold air, or is enough using the heat exchanger? Is it better to put the heater after the recovery unit?

Thanks
 

RE: Heat recovery ventilation unit

You can put a duct heating coil after the ERV depending upon the temperature you required to raise.  You can utilize any free available energy in the building through this heating coil, which I doubt in your case.
 

RE: Heat recovery ventilation unit

Duct heater mostly comes after recovery, except if you have two-stage heater, where first, pre-heater has anti-freeze protection as primary function.

Otherwise, you cannot have recovery, isn't it? Heater will lower temp. difference "killing" recovery efficiency.

Actually, using bathroom heat is not something I fully grasp. Bathroom has latent heat mostly, and only on ocassional basis, while all regenerating recovery system have problems with undesired pollution transfer.

RE: Heat recovery ventilation unit

Drazen:

I think you are thinking about a different form of heat recover. An HRV would be a plate type heat exchanger than recovers heat from the exhaust air stream and transfers to the incoming make-up air stream. Pollution transfer is negligible.

These are used heavily in cold climates.

http://www.venmarces.com/products/

RE: Heat recovery ventilation unit

you are using HRV to exhaust from WC that mean you have small amount of cfm, you don't need duct heater(think about the operation cost not only about a fancy design)

residential HRV's is designed as per manufucturers to exhaust air from wet areas such as kitchens, bathrooms ..etc
  

RE: Heat recovery ventilation unit

Also check with the HRV maker for the place of the unit, in condo some makers don't recomend to install unit under the bedroom of the higher floor

RE: Heat recovery ventilation unit

Chris, I was thinking exactly about cross-plate exchanger, the most commonly used in residential application.

Pollution transfer is non-existant, but latent heat transfer as well, which renders it useless for bathroom-only application.

Normally, bathroom air is mixed with all other exhaust, so its influence is small.

Speaking of kitchen exhaust, I would never put it in there, that is even fire hazard. Some Swedish manufacturers offer residential recovery units with spigot for kitchen exhaust which bypasses exchanger, which does make sense, as grease condensation makes much more trouble than anything else, and completely different filtering is needed.

RE: Heat recovery ventilation unit

(OP)
Actually I have 75 CFM, I decided to put a 0.5 kw heater after the HRV to raise the temperature of the ventilation air in the winter.
Thanks 317069, do you think we can make the design without the duct heater even with -23 C in the winter?

Thanks
 

RE: Heat recovery ventilation unit

I just reread your post again Drazen and realize where I made my error.

Have you seen/used the cross plate HX that allows latent transfer? I call it the soggy cardboard HX (which they hate) but the HX really does look like a waxed coated piece of cardboard.

http://www.lifebreath.com/en/consumer/products/residential/erv/

camago

If you are exhausting warm humid bathroom air, and replacing with -23C air you'll have to consider a defrost strategy.

For a low volume non critical application I'd recommend exhaust only defrost, but there are several ways to skin this particular cat.
 

RE: Heat recovery ventilation unit

Thank you for your question

- My answare would be yes we can use 75 cfm without duct heater after the HRV.
- HRV usually gives up to 50F raise and after that the air will mix with the return air which is about 22C or 72F.
- if we mix a 20% fresh air(-23C)with 80% return air(22C) (even without HRV)the result would be about 13C, So with using an  HRV unit it would be higher than 13C.
- what if someone open a window in the winter for one minut?  

RE: Heat recovery ventilation unit

I saw several manufacturers offer that, and indeed, they look like some biscuit on the inside, never saw it installed.

Noone talks much about pollution transfer, this "washable by water" is probably meant to be overall solution for cleanliness.

What I did not see by now is a unit designed specifically for cooling recovery.

RE: Heat recovery ventilation unit

Heat recovery for a 75 CFM exhaust. Why bother waste of money and what doyou think will happen when moisture ladden exhaust cooler air is about to be exhausted to an ambient temperature of -23 dC.  Ice up of course

RE: Heat recovery ventilation unit

Drazen,
You mention some swedich manufacturer including kitchen exhaust with general exhaust.
I would caution all in using these "fancy" european designs, most of them are conceived for their own local codes in mind AND for their own climate. Their codes and climates are Way different than ours, most of their systems are not applicable to us.
Check IMC, pantries and kitchens, etc, cannot connect to bathroom exhaust, they require their own dedicated exhaust systems.
when it comes to HVAC, I say stay away from european designs, they are not to be copied, especially when codes and life safety are involved. I just read today that it is only now that they are requiring smoke detectors in houses (by... 2015).

No ofense to Europeans of course.

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources