Continuous Footing for Garage
Continuous Footing for Garage
(OP)
Situation: We have designed a residential garage slab with a reinforced turn down edge (24" below grade)under the garage door. Code official requires a continuous strip footing & foundation wall under garage door.
Worth fighting for?
Worth fighting for?






RE: Continuous Footing for Garage
BA
RE: Continuous Footing for Garage
RE: Continuous Footing for Garage
RE: Continuous Footing for Garage
If the entire foundation uses a downturned slab refer the code official to details R403.1(1) and R403.1.3.2 for typical down turned slab details.
RE: Continuous Footing for Garage
RE: Continuous Footing for Garage
Seems like a small amount of concrete to get into a pissing match over. I'd say that it is a small price to pay to avoid ruining a good relationship with the local jurisdiction. Just do it their way and move on.
Mike McCann
MMC Engineering
Motto: KISS
Motivation: Don't ask
RE: Continuous Footing for Garage
Another issue here with that plan is if the 2'- 3 3/4" center wall is a shear wall or not. I would assume probably not.
So. Then they are concerned about spreading of the endwalls in a seismic event and want a tie beam to limit that. From the plan, this does not seem like that should be an issue.
Mike McCann
MMC Engineering
Motto: KISS
Motivation: Don't ask
RE: Continuous Footing for Garage
RE: Continuous Footing for Garage
RE: Continuous Footing for Garage
On the other hand, you have not given us any reason why you prefer your detail over his other than volume of concrete. We don't know if you are in a seismic zone, the depth of frost penetration or the soil properties.
Your detail would not work well in my locale because of frost heave but that may not be a consideration for you. For the small amount of concrete involved, I would likely have gone with the footing and wall as it is easier to form than the downturn. In my locale, the bottom of footing would have to be at least four feet below grade.
Alternatively, a grade beam 8" x 16" spanning across the door openings would be an option. The grade beam would require a 4" or 6" deep frost cushion below it and would certainly have more reinforcement than you have detailed in the downturn. The top of grade beam would be at the underside of slab. If the driveway is concrete, I would want it to bear at least 2" onto the grade beam and be tied to the garage floor slab but not to the grade beam thus allowing the driveway to heave freely. A couple of inches of rigid insulation under the driveway for 2' from the grade beam is a good idea to reduce frost penetration.
If a building official told me he wanted a different detail, I would ask him to kindly seal and sign the foundations plans.
BA
RE: Continuous Footing for Garage
This turn-down is NOT a foundation - that is your "out". It is not supporting anything and is only serving to stiffen the edge of a slab. Therefore the code requirement for a strip footing doesn't apply.
RE: Continuous Footing for Garage
The code is a "model code". It is not enforceable unless states, cities and municipalities adopt it as part of their codes. They usually have some change or input, frost depth is a prime example; these changes are made on the recommendation of the code official. Much is left to the code officials judgment as to whether a design is in compliance or not. The code official does not design, he simply will not sign off until he gets the type of design he wants.
Michael.
Timing has a lot to do with the outcome of a rain dance.
RE: Continuous Footing for Garage
I am like BA, code officials don't say much in Florida unless you do something really obviously out of the ordinary.
RE: Continuous Footing for Garage