×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Overlapping Flanges Don't Mitre Inventor 2011

Overlapping Flanges Don't Mitre Inventor 2011

Overlapping Flanges Don't Mitre Inventor 2011

(OP)
Hi,

Can anyone please help me overcome the inability of the flanges to mitre in the corners.

I have tried numerous models, including repairing Inventor, all to no avail.

Any help would be greatly appreciated.

Thank you.

cjj

 

RE: Overlapping Flanges Don't Mitre Inventor 2011

I noticed that your first sketch is not constrained or making use of obvious symmetry about the origin.
http://home.pct.edu/~jmather/skillsusa%20university.pdf

...and I would probably model "as folded" rather than folding up from a flat (let Inventor figure out the flat).

....and do you really want a bend in the middle of what looks to me could be a simple planar face (resulting in this split)? (see attached)

RE: Overlapping Flanges Don't Mitre Inventor 2011

(OP)
Dear rollupswx,

Thank  you once again for coming to my aid.

I am somewhat puzzled by your comment vis-a-vis my face sketch not being constrained.

Although it looks a simple model it is in fact quite complex, hence the reason I have folded from the flat. I will however try extruding from a single face, as per your kind suggestion, to start off with and see how that works.

But, without wishing to appear ungrateful, non of your observations seem to account for the failure of the flanges to mitre in the corners, which is my prime concern.

Thank you.

cjj



 

RE: Overlapping Flanges Don't Mitre Inventor 2011

Inventor is telling you the sketch is unconstrained.
First thing the guy out on the shop floor does is set up absolute datums so he knows how any changes will effect the design.  As your is I can drag the sketch anywhere around the screen. Not predictable.  Same as in MDT.

RE: Overlapping Flanges Don't Mitre Inventor 2011

Notice that when I constrain to the origin the geometry changes to a dark color - visually letting you know that it is fully constrained and needs no more dimension/constraints.

And don't change the properties of your construction geometry - Inventor will do that for you.  Simply toggle to construction (see attached).  If you insist on doing the extra work of changing properties (ACAD users like to change colors - you will quickly get used to it if you let Inventor do it's defaults) at least DON'T use Pink (magenta) as that indicates SICK geometry by default in Inventor.  Use anything but pink.

RE: Overlapping Flanges Don't Mitre Inventor 2011

I've got to run just now - I come back and answer the solution to the Flange Miter in a bit.

RE: Overlapping Flanges Don't Mitre Inventor 2011

(OP)
Dear rollupswx,

I appreciate that I am asking an awful lot but is it possible for you to please modify my file as it should be, that way I can compare it to my original to see what I am doing wrong.

In addition how do I set up the default styles for construction etc. I simply cannot cope with the horribly thick lines that Inventor seems to use as default?

I am most grateful, for I have been struggling with this for nearly 3 weeks now.

My kind regards and sincere thanks,

cjj

RE: Overlapping Flanges Don't Mitre Inventor 2011

You must not have looked at the image I posted.
When you change a line or circle to construction Inventor automatically makes it much thinner (less than half the thickness of an object line) and dashed.

When I get a chance I'll show how to fix your part, and then how I would have done it from scratch.

RE: Overlapping Flanges Don't Mitre Inventor 2011

This image shows Inventor Object lineweight, Iventor's Construction lineweight and YOUR construction lineweight.
If anything, yours looks slightly thicker than Inventors "horribly thick" construction lines.

Quite frankly in my experience teaching someone who exhibits what I see as a glaring lack of geometric observation I expect a long road ahead.  We'll see how it goes.  Stick with me.

RE: Overlapping Flanges Don't Mitre Inventor 2011

But of course, modeling from flat entails way too many calculations and is fraught with chances to make errors.
Notice in the inside of your flanges that the angles aren't even flat.

I know the desired finished dimensions (or at least you do), so I would model the finished part and let Inventor caculate the flat (including bend allowances).

RE: Overlapping Flanges Don't Mitre Inventor 2011

(OP)
Dear rollupswx,

I can only assume my system is not set up correctly for the direct opposite occurs. All the default settings produce lines on my Apple Cinema screen 1.0 to 1.5mm thick; hence my desire to manually alter them.

I must also be somewhat thick as well as lacking in geometric observation for I can find nowhere in the tutorial link you kindly provided how to constrain to a plane, axis or centre point.

I am as previously stated most grateful for your help.

cjj

 

RE: Overlapping Flanges Don't Mitre Inventor 2011

(OP)
Dear rollupswx,

The edges you refer to should not be flat for they meet at a compound angle. Nothing in the model is at 90 degrees.

Thank you.

cjj

RE: Overlapping Flanges Don't Mitre Inventor 2011

(OP)
Dear rollupswx,

I have looked at your kindly modified version of my file and the problem I have is that I must have the flanges right into the corners. If Inventor cannot auto mitre the flanges it would seem my only option is to form the flanges by sweeping but I still run into problems in the corners. I would have to mitre the first flange before sweeping the next etc.

I simply do not understand why Inventor is falling over with the auto corner mitering?

Thank you once again.

Christopher

RE: Overlapping Flanges Don't Mitre Inventor 2011

(OP)
Dear rollupswx,

I apologise for my earlier message. I had failed to see the Corner Seam you had added.

I will go away and look at this feature in more detail.

Thank you so much.

cjj

RE: Overlapping Flanges Don't Mitre Inventor 2011

(OP)
Dear rollupswx,

Your modified version of my file appears to do exactly what I want - thank you so much.

I recognise it must be really basic information but how did you constrain the sketch centre point to the Origin Center Point. The Origin Center Point does not appear to accept any form of association!

Thank you.

cjj
 

RE: Overlapping Flanges Don't Mitre Inventor 2011

Quote:

I recognise it must be really basic information but how did you constrain the sketch centre point to the Origin Center Point. The Origin Center Point does not appear to accept any form of association!

You must not have read that document I posted earlier.
If you have Inventor set up correctly the Origin CenterPoint will automatically be projected to each new sketch.  (it you have by chance deleted the autoprojection at some point you can simply Project Geometry and click the Center Point into the sketch.  Now you can add a coincident constraint.)  Once you get the hang of Inventor you will see that you can set it up to do a lot of automatic work for you.

Here is how I might model this part (there are other ways).  One advantage to modeling in the finished size state is that you can simply edit dimensions to get desired finsished size without any calculations.  I didn't know whether your angle or height was the controlling dimension - so I assumed height.  This could easily be changed.

I assume from an earlier statement you made that there might be more to this part.  Continue adding features and post back to see if there might be other ways.

Of course, becuase my model was done in EDU version - delete it after you have reproduced.

BTW: If you want to tighten up the miter you could do something like MiterGap/2 or whatever.  Keep in mind the manufacturing tolerances.

RE: Overlapping Flanges Don't Mitre Inventor 2011

(OP)
Dear rollupswx,

Thank you for all of the information in your last post.

I will look at your part file now and revert tomorrow if that is OK?

Thank you once again.

Christopher

 

RE: Overlapping Flanges Don't Mitre Inventor 2011

When you take a look at it the obvious question is, "Why not do as a single Lofted Flange - I tried that and it works, but after mitering the flanges it left a bend anomaly that should have been trimmed away.

Therefore I ended up having to do just a bit more work than intended - adding construction fillets to the profile sketches, 3 lofts instead of 1 and 2 bends that otherwise would have been automatic.

For most parts I could have greatly simplified the Contoured Flanges into one feature with automitering, but the angles on this one presented problems.

But I think you will agree it is easy to set up (no angle calculations) and maybe more important - easy to edit.

I try to create most work in such a way that the sketches are independent of the features.  You should be able to describe most of the part from only simple sketches similar to traditional 2d orthographic projection views.

RE: Overlapping Flanges Don't Mitre Inventor 2011

(OP)
Dear rollupswx,

This note may appear out of turn but it is just to thank you and to add that I accept your kind advice over keeping original sketches simple, which is why I had driven my sketch from circles rather than from individual lines requiring many measurements and angles. In subsequent models I have set up layers of sketches each building on each other using blocks that appears to work well, keeping each individual sketch confined to just a few construction lines constrained to the underlying blocks.

In summary, the very meaningful help I received from you last night was:

1. The missing 2 dimensions from my sketches related to not being constrained to the centre of origin.
2. When Inventor fails to corner mitre overlapping flanges, simply use an offset and fix the problem with a separate corner seam.
3. That there is possibly a much better route to folding up from a flat namely to loft.

Finally there is no doubt that without your kind help I would have been stuck on this problem for a goodly while.

So thank you rollupswx, you get my sincere vote of thanks.

cjj

RE: Overlapping Flanges Don't Mitre Inventor 2011

If you do a lot of sheetmetal you are also going to want to become familiar with surface modeling techniques (create surface model and then Thicken to solid) to workaround some difficult parts that the standard sheet metal tools don't include specific needed "easy button" solutions.
I considered that perhaps surface modeling might be a way to make this part, but decided to stay within the sheet metal tools to avoid confusion.  I consider the result I got using a single loft with flanges to be a bug in the program and will be submitting that to Autodesk to take a look.  I came to the conclusion the reason that automiter wasn't working is the edges of the two flanges (on careful examination) are not co-planar, but at a slight angle to each other.  I am not considering the failure to automiter (in this specific case) to be bug or lack of functionality.  Purely a logical geometry problem. Conditions not met for the functionality to work.  Making the sheetmetal much thicker might make the reasoning more obvious.

RE: Overlapping Flanges Don't Mitre Inventor 2011

(OP)
Dear rollupswx,

Thank you for your added dimension vis-a-vis the surface modelling solution.

Is this still a suitable solution bearing in mind that my model has to be controlled via iRules to make it fully adjustable in size whilst retaining the various features in tact?

I am also intrigued by your observation of the edges not being co-planar causing the failure of the auto-mitering and will look at this also.

Thus far I have managed to loft in one piece i.e all sides together, without a hitch although as yet have not added my XML file or iRules to control the part.

I am new to sheet-metal work as well as Inventor and wondered if you can point me at the limitations that exist for fabricators to actually fold a component.

Presumably when a model becomes in a sense closed i.e. a fabricator cannot access a flange or face then it becomes unviable.

I ask because my model is only half of the finished article which i am having to bolt together. Could it be folded as one component with just one seam?

As previously stated I am most grateful.

You cannot know yet just how profound my particular model is and the influence it will have in due course.

Thank you.

cjj

RE: Overlapping Flanges Don't Mitre Inventor 2011

Surface modeling in Inventor is fully parametric.

RE: Overlapping Flanges Don't Mitre Inventor 2011

(OP)
Dear rollupswx.

Thank you.

cjj

 

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources