×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

mechanical turn signal blinker.
3

mechanical turn signal blinker.

mechanical turn signal blinker.

(OP)
I'm curious about how a (not so) simple electro-mechanical turn signal auto blinker works.

The simple and incorrect answer, given by the how does it work sites, is a heater on a bi-metallic strip. This doesn't explain the blinker properties.

The blinker is in series with the load. A simple bi-metalic strip would have a shorter on time with more load (more current) and once open it would cool at a fixed rate so the off time would not depend on the load.

This would also delay the turn signal lamps while the bi-metal strip first heated up.

In fact the turn lamps are initially on and have shorter on and off times with less current (a single bulb instead of two).

Does anyone know how this actually works?

Thanks

Stephen Van Buskirk

A human being is a computer's way of making another computer. Yes, we are their sex organs.--Solomon Short (aka David Gerrold, US science-fiction author)

RE: mechanical turn signal blinker.

I think the "how it works" explanation is accurate, the one I found shows a picture of a blinker's internals. There isn't any magic going on, it's just a heater and bimetallic strip.

http://auto.howstuffworks.com/turn-signal2.htm


 

RE: mechanical turn signal blinker.

Take one apart and look at it.

RE: mechanical turn signal blinker.

Yes, it's not just one bimetallic strip - there are two that interact and the resistor is a separate item.

Do like Mike, take one open and watch it work.

Good on ya,

Goober Dave

RE: mechanical turn signal blinker.

I'm fairly certain that the quicker blinking feature to indicate a burned out signal light bulb is a later development. The 'original' simple blinker device didn't include this helpful feature. Perhaps that's why things don't match.

If one was really curious, one could probably look up the patent(s) for the feature on the USPTO.gov website.
 

RE: mechanical turn signal blinker.

3
I noticed that fast blink thing long time ago. I had a Morris 1000 at that time (we are in 1962 now) and when one lamp burned out, I could tell from the higher blinking frequency.

I thought that was the way it should be. But was curious about why it increased frequency and decided to find out - aometime. I still haven't found out. So I am looking forward to someone finding out any year now.

If that fast blink feature is a later development, then later has a new meaning. Must have been more than 50 years ago.

Gunnar Englund
www.gke.org
--------------------------------------
100 % recycled posting: Electrons, ideas, finger-tips have been used over and over again...

RE: mechanical turn signal blinker.

What Gunnar said!!

Bill
--------------------
"Why not the best?"
Jimmy Carter

RE: mechanical turn signal blinker.

Well, my recollection differs...

There may be a clue in that the flasher modules, the little can-shaped modules of the sort used in North America, came in several flavours. The general application ones were either 2-terminal or 3-terminal types.

The simple 2-terminal versions of the simple bi-metallic strip design probably don't include the current sensing feature.

Here's an image of a 2-terminal version, with the "MAX6" presumably being the maximum numbers of signal bulbs. So it obviously wouldn't react to one of N being burned out. The DOT probably indicates the flash rate meets requirements.



The next step in this study would be to determine what's different between the 2-terminal and 3-terminal flasher modules.

Maybe that's the explanation, maybe not...

RE: mechanical turn signal blinker.

My conclusion is that the simple bi-metallic flasher modules (the simple sort, as described) do not provide the burned-out lamp, rapid flash indicator feature.

 

RE: mechanical turn signal blinker.

The flash rate is determined by the power input, the heat capacity of the bimetallic strip and heating element, and thermal resistance in the heat flow path. Too little power (burned-out lamp) and it will take longer to heat to the switch-off point, but it will cool quickly, so the lamp will blink-off only for a short time. Too much power (due to a high wattage bulb) will cause a quick flash and a longer off period. The exact effects depend on the specific design.  

RE: mechanical turn signal blinker.

With you so far. But I am still not satisfied. Remember, I have been wondering around fifty years!  smile

Gunnar Englund
www.gke.org
--------------------------------------
100 % recycled posting: Electrons, ideas, finger-tips have been used over and over again...

RE: mechanical turn signal blinker.

I thought that these days the once humble blinker would require at least a fast 32 bit microcontroller to make it go.

RE: mechanical turn signal blinker.

(OP)
I looked at the web site listed and it didn't have a detailed explanation. It showed one yheater and bi-metal strip and w2ouldn't work as I expect. I'm fairly sure the lamps are on as soon as power is supplied, not after the strip heats up.

My observation is that the blinker on AND off times are faster with less load. I have tried to watch one and still don't understand it, though I'm sure it must involve heat dissipation, different resistors and materials. I was hoping for a specific explanation for no particular reason, just curiosity.

I was looking at the SAE specs. They call for a very narrow range of operating frequencies, +- 5 or 10%, as I remember.
Since blinkers can have more load (4 bulbs instead of 2) and still work, but blink faster with only one this must be quite complex. I did not find any allowance for faster blinking in the SAE specs but it's probably there somewhere.

Stephen Van Buskirk

RE: mechanical turn signal blinker.

Mr. Speed: "..32 bit microcontroller..."

My car puts a message on the dash (in any of several languages) telling me that a light bulb is burned out, exactly which one (*), and if it was able to reconfigure a nearby alternate bulb as a temporary replacement.

(* It fails to distinguish between the two rear license plate illumination bulbs.)

 

RE: mechanical turn signal blinker.

VE1BLL,
And I bet the CIA can also monitor every single lamp in your car on a big display screen back at Langley.

RE: mechanical turn signal blinker.

Good news!

Daughter and son-in-law will visit tomorrow. He builds hot rod and vintage cars and will bring one of those devices.

We will cut it open, make photographs, push currents of different magnitudes through it and record the blinking.

It will be a major scientific undertaking and it will happen on a Sunday. I think it is worth while.

Stay tuned!

Gunnar Englund
www.gke.org
--------------------------------------
100 % recycled posting: Electrons, ideas, finger-tips have been used over and over again...

RE: mechanical turn signal blinker.

"...major scientific undertaking..."

CERN's got nothing on you.  smile

 

RE: mechanical turn signal blinker.

Wonderful Gunnar. I'm looking forward to the results of your research.
Thank you.

Bill
--------------------
"Why not the best?"
Jimmy Carter

RE: mechanical turn signal blinker.

I'm going to say the flasher units flash faster running fewer bulbs because they heat up slower.  This makes them just creep up to the open temperature instead of a massive I2R blast that overshoots the opening point dramatically.

If the flasher normally runs, say, only two lamps and one opens, the heating coil will only be seeing 1/4th the power.

By virtue of them heating up slower and not blasting past the opening temp the coil also cools sooner to below the make-temp.

Keith Cress
kcress - http://www.flaminsystems.com

RE: mechanical turn signal blinker.

I agree Keith. It's a cleverly designed interaction of thermal time constants - which create a lag or delay - and differing power inputs which determine the energy input to the device before the bi-metal 'catches up'. Operation with the full complement of lamps dumps energy in at a high rate and internal temperature significantly overshoots the bi-metal switch point and takes longer to recover; operation with a failed lamp causes an overshoot to a lesser degree and recovery is much faster.

Looking forward to Gunnar's report! smile
  

----------------------------------
  
If we learn from our mistakes I'm getting a great education!
 

RE: mechanical turn signal blinker.

There will be some delay before we can start the investigation. Have to have a meal and also entertain grandson before the hard work begins. In the meantime, one could plan the experiment.

Test set up:

Variable DC supply.

Blink relay.

Adjustable power resistor to simulate different lamp loads (this will not simulate inrush, will find and use real bulbs if necessary).

Shunt resistor 1 ohm (lower part of load, actually) to measure load current.

Temperature transducer (miniature NTC thermistor fastened to representative part of heated member) to see temperature vs time.

Recorder.

Recordings will be made with different DC voltages and different loads and the relation between U, P, ON and OFF time, blink frequency plotted with U as the independent variable with one set of curves for each load setting.
 

If lamps available, the light output from them will also be recorded with an uncalibrated photodiode pick-up.

If lamps available, the UxI product (lamp watts) will also be recorded.

Anything else we should consider? Or any comments as to the feasability? And, above all, who will pay for this investigation? Remember that it is a Sunday, with double hourly rate.




 

Gunnar Englund
www.gke.org
--------------------------------------
100 % recycled posting: Electrons, ideas, finger-tips have been used over and over again...

RE: mechanical turn signal blinker.

As this is an altruistic Sunday project for the good of all mankind, a double beer ration might be in order.

RE: mechanical turn signal blinker.

That's a VERY GOOD IDEA! But that may delay the project somewhat. The beers are imminent now.

I done the initial measurements on a blinking device (UP-552.12V) and I must say that it doesn't behave at all as I thought or remembered.

First: The lamps are not at all on for the first second. Instead, there is a weak current heating the switch so that the lamps go on after a little more than 1 second.

Second: There doesn't seem to be any big difference in blinking frequency regardless of running with three, two or just one 21 W 12 V lamp (yes, borrowed a complete setup with lamps in reflector housing).

I will make the recordings available as soon as I have finished the beers and put them together in a pdf document.

Stay tuned!

Gunnar Englund
www.gke.org
--------------------------------------
100 % recycled posting: Electrons, ideas, finger-tips have been used over and over again...

RE: mechanical turn signal blinker.

Gunnar,

If you open the packages up, the heating rate will be different due to now-flowing ambient air.

You need to reseal in transparent aluminum casing for a proper test...


:D

Dan - Owner
http://www.Hi-TecDesigns.com

RE: mechanical turn signal blinker.

Strangly my car flashers won't flash if one of the main bulbs are burned out (I don't know what happens if side marker light are burned out).
And also when I replaced the rear lights with LED's, they also did not flash (The LED's are now somewhere else).

The emergecy flashers don't act that way. They will flash no matter what.

Strangly all these light bulbs have two filiments, and just the one burns out.

RE: mechanical turn signal blinker.

Yes Dan, I noticed that. I can even stop it from working at all by blowing gently on the filament.
 

Gunnar Englund
www.gke.org
--------------------------------------
100 % recycled posting: Electrons, ideas, finger-tips have been used over and over again...

RE: mechanical turn signal blinker.

Gunnar, is that by any chance an infernal "Lucas" device, designed by the prince of darkness ??

Then any type of behavior is possible, absolutely anything.

RE: mechanical turn signal blinker.

Not Lucas. I really don't know what brand it is.

Result can be found on http://gke.org/arcus/ Look for document named "MEASUREMENTS ON AUTOMOTIVE..."

Now, hunting for the older type. The one that is ON from start and where blink frequency changes when load changes.

BTW: Any good explanation why heating current stays constant as filament resistance decreases during OFF period??

Gunnar Englund
www.gke.org
--------------------------------------
100 % recycled posting: Electrons, ideas, finger-tips have been used over and over again...

RE: mechanical turn signal blinker.

Awesome, Gunnar!

I'm a little too frazzled (Monday morning headaches) to think straight about the constant-current issue, but your report's comment about the heater resistance rising as the lamp filaments' resistance falls certainly makes intuitive sense.

While you await an older flasher, I'll just throw out that my 1972 Pontiac Bonneville would just about double its frequency when I plugged in dad's boat trailer (approximately doubling the lighting load). However, it would simply stop on a burned-out lamp. This leads me to believe it had a single bimetal element perhaps.

Perhaps someone can countribute a make, model, and year of a vehicle whose blinkers sped up on lamp outage? That would help narrow the search.

Double good on ya,

Goober Dave

RE: mechanical turn signal blinker.

Skogs,

I am surmising that insufficient quantities of beer were consumed to arrive at conclusive answers.  Recommend larger quantities be laid in prior to next weekend.  

RE: mechanical turn signal blinker.

Report: "So the sum of ON and OFF period stays relatively constant when lamps are switched from three to one. This is contrary to common belief and makes us think that there has been a change in technology sometimes during the last decades. This remains unanswered until we have found an older type blinker relay and made the corresponding measurements."

Good work. Mark me down as unsurprised. smile


Regarding "older"...

It's been my assumption that someone, way back in the depths of time, invented the bimetallic flasher of the perfectly simple sort you just tested. And I assumed that "later" someone figured out how to make a **NEWER** version that includes the 'operator feedback' about lamps being burned out. It would be illogical for this sequence to be reversed.

Obviously not all models would have included the extra feature even if it only cost a penny. My 1970s Chryslers didn't as far as I can recall. But that doesn't imply that it hadn't been invented even in the 1950s.

It should be a simple matter to order up an OEM flasher module, new or used, for any given car (even a 1962 Morris 1000) to check your recollection.

But once you get into the era of electronic modules (early 1970s ? for SOME models), there's no mystery.
 

RE: mechanical turn signal blinker.

(OP)
Thank you all.

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources