×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Section Modulus for Trap Members 10'-6" On Center

Section Modulus for Trap Members 10'-6" On Center

Section Modulus for Trap Members 10'-6" On Center

(OP)
NFPA 13 gives a table of Section Modulus for varying spans of trapeze members based on 15' of water filled pipe. Not sure if anyone else installs main hangers on 15' centers but we use 10'-6" spacing and 5'-3" from each end (typical 21' lengths. 2 hanges per pipe.

Is there a formula available (maybe I missed it in 13) or another preengineered table for Section modulus based on 10'-6" centers?

Seems like I should be able to get the trapeze pipe member size down if I didn't have to use 15' centers.

TIA, ShawnO

RE: Section Modulus for Trap Members 10'-6" On Center

Shawn,  

You may need to get help from a qualified (competent) engineer on this one.  If you do not use the tables and parameters outlined within NFPA 13 (which many have argued contains all the engineering so you don't have to), then (as others have argued previously), you are interpretting, or worse, doing a calculation that by rights is "engineering", which is outside the scope of a NICET technician.

Fire Sprinklers Save Lives.
Can You Live Without Them?
 

RE: Section Modulus for Trap Members 10'-6" On Center

'you are interpretting, or worse, doing a calculation that by rights is "engineering", which is outside the scope of a NICET technician.'

But not all is lost, there are easy and correct workarounds.

For a 10'-6 trapeze simply keep the pipe away from the center using A9.1.1.6 to find the equivalent length.

If the span is 11'-0" simply keep the pipe within 3'-9" of the left or right side for an equivalent length of 9.89'.

If the job is so big, so complex you can't offset pipe in the trapeze then pay the few hundred it will take to have a PE look at it.  
 

RE: Section Modulus for Trap Members 10'-6" On Center

His trapeze span is not necessarily exceeding the tables in NFPA 13, but he is just questioning why he should have to use the spacing in NFPA 13 which is based on 15' hanger spacing when they are using 10'-6" hanger spacing.  It seems to make sense that you could reduce the section modulus for hangers at 10'-6" on center and could mean changing your trapeze member from 3" to 2" Sch 40 or something similar. It could be a huge savings in today's market.

Travis Mack
MFP Design, LLC
www.mfpdesign.com
 

RE: Section Modulus for Trap Members 10'-6" On Center

Remember also that you can delete alternating trapeze hangers on cross mains as long as you hang these branch lines at first available joist "excluding side feed systems".Also I think you are required to have a hanger between each branch line, and this should determine your hanger spacing, not the length of pipes.

We see a lot of companies shift cross mains to the side of the nearest truss and adjust starter pieces accordingly to maintain plan head locations. This eliminates trapezes, but I would careful if it is a large shift, so as not to affect pipe lengths too much.  

RE: Section Modulus for Trap Members 10'-6" On Center

You might be able to hire a PE to create a new table for you (similar to Table 9.1.1.6.1(a)) based on 10'-6" of pipe.  If he/she stamped it and wrote a supporting letter, I'd think you could use it on any future project.  

Ed Kramer
Kramer Design, LLC

RE: Section Modulus for Trap Members 10'-6" On Center

I agree with Ed's suggestion.

Fire Sprinklers Save Lives.
Can You Live Without Them?
 

RE: Section Modulus for Trap Members 10'-6" On Center

I recall this being addressed in a previous Tech Alert from the NFSA years ago.
The technician was told to make the necessary adjustments.
You dont need to hire a PE to perform basic math for you.

Forest Wilson
Cherokee Fire

RE: Section Modulus for Trap Members 10'-6" On Center

(OP)
Helpful links...
https://www.wheatland.com/SpecSheets/Sprinkler/Sway%20Bracing/NFPA_13_2010_Sway-Seismic_Bracing_Sch10%20pipe.pdf

https://www.wheatland.com/SpecSheets/Sprinkler/Sway%20Bracing/NFPA_13_2010_Sway-Seismic_Bracing_Sch40%20pipe.pdf

Thanks for all of your advice. I have an engineer buddy that's helping research this. I'll update as I get more information. He'll explain to me how he got there. Then we'll see if it is actually basic math or not.  

RE: Section Modulus for Trap Members 10'-6" On Center

"we'll see if it is actually basic math or not."

I tried and while the math was basic and easy I messed up by not knowing 1)the correct terminology and 2)where to apply the correct numbers to arrive at a correct answer.

While I would like to know more, I would like to be able to do it, I recognize it's engineering so I throw the responsibility to someone else.  

It's like knowing when a 13R system becomes a full 13 through the building code.  I pretty much understand it, most of the time I can get the right answer but why would I want to accept the responsibility when it's clearly the practice of engineering and architecture?  I have enough responsibility without volunteering.

 

RE: Section Modulus for Trap Members 10'-6" On Center

Shawn:

Shoot me an email.  I have a spreadsheet that a PE buddy of mine created a couple of years ago that calculates the section modulus for various hanger spacings and distance from side of the structural member.  The table in 13 is for center loading and 15' on center.

Mine is not signed/sealed by the PE that created it.  Your guy may want to use it as a starting point.  He may find it is correct or needs to be changed.

Travis Mack
MFP Design, LLC
www.mfpdesign.com
 

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources