How to Account for Positive Suction Pressure in Pump-System Curve?
How to Account for Positive Suction Pressure in Pump-System Curve?
(OP)
You think you know something, then a question comes at you forcing you to re-evaluate what you know, or at least think you know...
Question: How do you predict the operating point when a pump takes suction from a pressurized line?
Does it act like two pumps in series, i.e. add the heads at every Q?
Would I construct a 'virtual' series operation pump curve, i.e. the pressurized line acts like the first pump (a virtual pump), and the second pump in series is the actual pump? Then, overlay this 'series' curve over my system curve to obtain the operating point?
Thanks guys!!!
Question: How do you predict the operating point when a pump takes suction from a pressurized line?
Does it act like two pumps in series, i.e. add the heads at every Q?
Would I construct a 'virtual' series operation pump curve, i.e. the pressurized line acts like the first pump (a virtual pump), and the second pump in series is the actual pump? Then, overlay this 'series' curve over my system curve to obtain the operating point?
Thanks guys!!!





RE: How to Account for Positive Suction Pressure in Pump-System Curve?
RE: How to Account for Positive Suction Pressure in Pump-System Curve?
A pressurized suction does not change the pump curve. It does change the system curve. The pump will operate at the intersection of the pump curve and the system curve.
Let me know if I misunderstood your question.
Johnny Pellin
RE: How to Account for Positive Suction Pressure in Pump-System Curve?
Just add the pump's differential head at any given flowrate to the head at its intake at the same given flowrate.
"I am sure it can be done. I've seen it on the internet." BigInch's favorite client.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hpiIWMWWVco
"Being GREEN isn't easy." Kermit
http://virtualpipeline.spaces.live.com
RE: How to Account for Positive Suction Pressure in Pump-System Curve?
I attached the pump and system curve.
This system has one pump that can either take suction from an atmospheric tank OR a pressurized line at 150 psig. The destination is 10,000' away and 300' uphill.
Note the system curve is negative when the system takes suction from the pressurized line, just as JJ said.
I created a fake 'series pump' curve by doing what Big Inch said: adding the heads at every Q.
Now: When the pump is taking suction from the 150 psig line, i.e. the system curve is the olive green line, which is the correct operating point: Point 1, or Point 2?
RE: How to Account for Positive Suction Pressure in Pump-System Curve?
According to how I read your description, each discharge system curve (from either source) has a static head at 0 gpm of 300 ft. You calculate and draw the discharge system curve separately from the suction head + pump differential head beginning those curves at 0 gpm with the static head in that pipeline.
The suction line graph starts with the tank pressure head equivalent or the pipeline pressure head equivalent.
As I see it, you are pumping to the same destination using the same flowrates, so the discharge system curve is the exact same for both.
I made a corrected spreadsheet for you.
BTW, the NPSHR curve is relative to absolute pressure. I don't know if those values are already corrected to 0 psig reference or not. If the 6 to 9 ft are NPSHR values not corrected to 0 psig, they would appear as a nearly flat line at -24 to -27 feet on my diagram, which is referenced to 0 psig = 0 ft head. In other words, a suction pressure of 0 psig is actually 33 "feet absolute" of NPSHA.
"I am sure it can be done. I've seen it on the internet." BigInch's favorite client.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hpiIWMWWVco
"Being GREEN isn't easy." Kermit
http://virtualpipeline.spaces.live.com
RE: How to Account for Positive Suction Pressure in Pump-System Curve?
RE: How to Account for Positive Suction Pressure in Pump-System Curve?
After beginning with that 300 ft head, my curves are the same as yours, except they plot on top of each other. Those curves would be different only if you were pumping up different hills, which would change the biginning static pressure of each pipeline, if you had two pipelines of different diameters, which would change the slopes of the curves, or were pumping two products of different viscosities, or densities from your tank or pipeline source, which would change both static head and curve slopes.
I ignored NPSHR, since that doesn't affect any of the system curve values; just nice to confirm that the suction heads (33 ft and 346 + 33 = 379 ft) are always above R.
I do have one question though. Typically your suction heads will drop as flowrate increases due to friction losses in the suction piping, or may change as your tank fluid level goes down, but yours appear to stay the same at all flow rates. As long as you're happy with that, I've no problem.
You know what to do if you have more questions.
"I am sure it can be done. I've seen it on the internet." BigInch's favorite client.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hpiIWMWWVco
"Being GREEN isn't easy." Kermit
http://virtualpipeline.spaces.live.com