×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Arc Flash Mystery

Arc Flash Mystery

Arc Flash Mystery

(OP)
OK, this is a strange one.  We build industrial machinery which we test in our shop via temporary pigtails to a fused bus system.  Our QC guy was reaching onto a 480V panel to read voltage across the distribution block.  All of a sudden, there was an arc flash.  The distribution block he was reaching for didn't have a mark, but the fuse block for the hydraulic tank heater about a foot to the left had it's fuses melted on the tops only.  They did not clear.  His multi-meter probes were also melted.  The main 400A molded case breaker disconnect did not trip, nor did the buss-plug fuses.  I took apart the meter and power obviously went through it.  Our guy swears he has the meter on voltage, was no where near the melted block, and was reaching behind some temporary wires to read voltage.  The temporary run is SO cord from a VFD to a motor we use for testing VFDs.  

Here's the only thing I can think of.  Either our very qualified QC guy is lying, or there was some sort of harmonic arc between the VFD leads and his meter.  He swears that he was no where near the melted fuse block and that he hadn't even touched the probes to the distribution block yet.  He was wearing a nice metal watch and a ring (yes, not the smartest thing), but other than a slight UV burn from the arc, not a scratch on him.  
 

RE: Arc Flash Mystery

It would be very easy to inspect the instrument to see what the setting was when the high current occured. If he will not let you do that, you must assume he is not only less qualified, but also lying.

Gunnar Englund
www.gke.org
--------------------------------------
100 % recycled posting: Electrons, ideas, finger-tips have been used over and over again...

RE: Arc Flash Mystery

I know of a case where dislodged dust cause an arc flash, not everything is as it seems.

RE: Arc Flash Mystery

(OP)
He says the probes were in the voltage terminals.  By the time I got the meter, the leads were removed.  The  

RE: Arc Flash Mystery

After rereadng your post I would ask him to explain how his meter was damaged when he had not yet connected the probe to the distribution block.  That statement alone puts everything else he says in doubt.

RE: Arc Flash Mystery

Open it then. If there was a current heavy enough to melt the probes, then it must also show inside.

Dust? Yes, perhaps. But not very likely in a test setup.

Reaching to take a measurement in high power equipment is a very bad idea. Easy to slip and cause shorts. That would cause exactly the damage you describe.

I am so tired of listening to 'mystical' explanations - often with assumed harmonics and resonances - from guys that have made a mistake. Much better to train not to make those mistakes. And never accept those fairy tales. Such things do not happen when lead or cable lengths are short (meaning 1 - 100 m).

Gunnar Englund
www.gke.org
--------------------------------------
100 % recycled posting: Electrons, ideas, finger-tips have been used over and over again...

RE: Arc Flash Mystery

OK, see that you already opened it. Current from A terminal or V terminal?
 

Gunnar Englund
www.gke.org
--------------------------------------
100 % recycled posting: Electrons, ideas, finger-tips have been used over and over again...

RE: Arc Flash Mystery

(OP)
I was trying to figure that out and I'm not sure.  Negetive terminal trace is fried, but the A and V terminals don't looked damaged.  It looks like it arced to the back of the case where the little foil beeper is.  The meter was given to him by our maintenance man.  It was an old one he had lying in a drawer.  

Let's assume our guy is telling the truth.  He's an old navy radio operator and has been HAM certified for 30+ years.  He used to work for us as a service tech years ago.  Could a faulty meter be the culprate?   I'll upload some pictures in a few.

RE: Arc Flash Mystery

Must be the meter then.

Navy, ham certificate, decades of experience, still alive.

I would trust such a guy.

But - he never touched anything? That's where the problem starts. And that's where my doubts creep in.

Do you calibrate your meters regularly? You can usually also have meters checked for debris and overall condition if you have them calibrated.

Gunnar Englund
www.gke.org
--------------------------------------
100 % recycled posting: Electrons, ideas, finger-tips have been used over and over again...

RE: Arc Flash Mystery

(OP)
That's why we are so confused.  The meter was an old junker.  I suspected the leads were in the amperage terminals, but he swears not.  The amp side is unfused.  I just can't see 480V jumping thorugh free air like that.  We even called in an outside electrician and he was stumped.  Said it looked like something shorted across the top of the fuse block.

RE: Arc Flash Mystery

Old junkers don't have cat ratings, and can be damaged by surges. Might want to replace with a cat III or IV.

RE: Arc Flash Mystery

(OP)
Took a closer look at the meter.  My suspicion is that he tried to read voltage when the probes were plugged in for amperage.  Being a non-fused meter exacerbated the problem.   

RE: Arc Flash Mystery

Where was the meter positioned? Perhaps the meter was hanging so the screws on the back of the meter shorted the fuse block It looks like there is tracking between the screw holes. If the probe tips were dangling, they may have been grounded somewhere on the bottom of the panel, and that caused the damage to the probe tips.  

RE: Arc Flash Mystery

(OP)
That I'm not sure we will ever know for sure.  I know that people's memories tend to get foggy in situations like this.  Where he was and where he thought he was may be two different things.   

RE: Arc Flash Mystery

480 volts won't "jump".  However, once an arc is started it will span considerable distances until the source gives up.

I'd lean towards "compositepro"'s idea, or the "Probes in the current jacks" idea.  The tips obviously saw arcing and that is not usually the result of a voltage measurement.

 

old field guy

RE: Arc Flash Mystery

Check the spacing of the screws against the parts in the fuse block. Look for arc marking on the screw ends on the meter that would have been facing the fuse block. Look for arc markings on the bottom of the panel and elsewhere. There is a lot of physical evidence you have available. How do you troubleshoot any technical problem? You have to make knowledgeable hypotheses and then find evidence to support or eliminate the hypothesis.  

RE: Arc Flash Mystery

(OP)
There were no exposed screws.  The meter was in a protective rubber boot.

I just talked to the guy.  He thinks the probes may have touched the block as he was holding them in his left hand.  He still swears the leads were in the Voltage position.  

After the incident, the meter still worked.  I tested a 120V souce with the meter.  It jumped around a bit, but was still working.  Now that's a tough meter.  I think someone may have switched the leads around when he wasn't using it.   

RE: Arc Flash Mystery

Looks to me like he got the wrong "terminal block" and shorted it out somehow, likely with the meter leads in the current position. However, it could have been an accidental touch which flashed over while the meter was set to measure voltage. Of course, this is much less likely.

Please, if nothing else, go out and get a good Fluke meter for the future. The Fluke 87 is the old standard meter here but we've got some other models too. No-one has ever able to do something like that in the 12 or 13 years I've worked here and those meters get used all the time (and some of them were here when I started too). Another option is fused leads but I consider them less important than starting with a good meter.

Some of the meters I see a "pro" carrying and using in the workplace make me shudder.
 

RE: Arc Flash Mystery

(OP)
Yes, when I saw that the voltage side was fused, but the Amperage side is unfused, I had a WFT moment.  I was told the meter was from the 90's.  It's an AmpProbe.

Long story short, I concur with you and we are ordering him a new meter.   

RE: Arc Flash Mystery

Looking at the photos, the meter probes are not up to the current designs- with only tips exposed.
Also I would consider increasing the safety of the panel, by looking at IP2X components as much as possible to minimise contact points,remember someone still has to set up the equipment -hot with the doors open  . IP2X also make the panel look a lot sexyier, and more modern. Which has the benefit down the line, when the maintenance team look at it- they will say nice looking panel- buy from them again.

regards

Stablefordd

RE: Arc Flash Mystery

Quote:

Yes, when I saw that the voltage side was fused, but the Amperage side is unfused, I had a WFT moment.  I was told the meter was from the 90's.
LOL.  I'm not familiar with WFT but I am familiar with WTF, and that would be my reaction also.  The meter makers never envisioned the possibility that someone would connect current probes to a voltage?!?  Probably they knew it full well but were driven by cost factors.  

=====================================
(2B)+(2B)'  ?

RE: Arc Flash Mystery

(OP)
Ah, yes.  I had a bit of a typing problem there.  Must have been the Gin and Tonics.  WTF??

I've tried to get these machines to use IEC equipment, but the "higher ups" say that it's a Cadillac machine and he customers want NEMA components. Until then, it is what it is.  

Note:  There was a plus side.  This incident got the president moving and has finally approved the $$ for an engineering firm to come in and do an arc flash study and training.    

RE: Arc Flash Mystery

Quote (killjoy):

we are ordering him a new meter

.... because the old one makes an unpleasant smell?

A.

RE: Arc Flash Mystery

Kiljoy, I highly recommend that you go to "e-hazard.com" and consider their arc / flash training course. I had my Low Voltage Qualification (<600V) last year, and the refresher this year. Drake Drobnick is a fantastic instructor. Is based on NFPA 70e.

Scott  

In a hundred years, it isn't going to matter anyway.

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources