×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Tools for Baseplate and Anchor Design?

Tools for Baseplate and Anchor Design?

Tools for Baseplate and Anchor Design?

(OP)
What software or design references do you use for design of baseplates (or embeds) and anchors?

We frequently deal with non-concentrically loaded baseplates.  With combinations of shear, moment, and axial forces.  Whether due to the cross sectional shape of the column or the position of the column relative to the plate center, forces are concentrated unevenly.  This results in uneven loading of the plate and anchors.  These calculations can be time consuming by hand, and are often trial and error in order to determine a pattern, anchor size, and plate thickness.  

We have similar issues with embed plates.

http://www.FerrellEngineering.com

RE: Tools for Baseplate and Anchor Design?

HILTI PROFIS seems to work fine for such applications. They have hex, heavy hex, square and heavy square for anchor bolts and also AWS headed studs in embedded plates.

RE: Tools for Baseplate and Anchor Design?

I've used the Simpson program, but I hate it because it always tells me what I am trying to do is in gross violation of the code for the new "cracked concrete" provisions.  Also, it doesn't design base plates, only the anchorage.  I haven't found anything that does both base plate design per Design Guide 1 and anchorage design per ACI Appendix D.

banghead

RE: Tools for Baseplate and Anchor Design?

CSC's Tedds just came out with a calc for Base Plate combined with Anchor bolts.  I'm not sure how robust/flexible it is or what sort of configurations are available as I have yet to use it.

EIT

RE: Tools for Baseplate and Anchor Design?

have you tried Engineering International ans/or Archoneng.

Both cheap and may solve your problems

RE: Tools for Baseplate and Anchor Design?

I use Ram Baseplate for my baseplate designs and really like it a lot.  Its a bit out of date code wise and I'm not sure if they've updated the program lately but it does handel both tension loading and moment loading on the baseplates.  It will also give you the loads on the anchor bolts.  Then I basically use ACI appendix D for the anchor bolt designs.  For the moment case you'll typically have two bolts in tension.  For the uplift case all four bolts will be in tension.  So depending on the load case a decent spreadsheet can help you navigate ACI appendix D.

I used a trial run of Dimensional Solutions anchor bolt programe and it seemed pretty robust regarding ACI appendix D solutions.   

John Southard, M.S., P.E.
http://www.pdhlibrary.com

RE: Tools for Baseplate and Anchor Design?

I'm with Southard - I design the plate with RAM Baseplate (admittedly, I hate that it won't do biaxial bending), then pull out of the anchor forces and dump that into my ACI App. D spreadsheet to design the anchors.

RE: Tools for Baseplate and Anchor Design?

Ram Baseplate is now part of the Ram Connection and can design for biaxial bending as well as perform Appendix D type calcs for most general conditions.   

RE: Tools for Baseplate and Anchor Design?

RFreund,
The TEDDS report seems nicely laid out. I compared it to RAM Connection and noticed a mistake. Under pullout strength, TEDDS shows Abrg=1.5 in^2 for a 3/4" bolt but RAM gives 0.654 in^2.  I believe RAM is correct. If you agree, I recommend you report this as a bug.

Another difference I noticed is that RAM will only let you consider friction if you use a shear lug.  That doesn't make a lot of sense to me.  I'll try to post the RAM output when I get a little more time.

RE: Tools for Baseplate and Anchor Design?

Bookmarked for reference.

RE: Tools for Baseplate and Anchor Design?

Here's a sample of RAM Connection's output. I used the same data as the TEDDS example above.  There is also an option to have it show all of the equations. Nice for seeing how it arrived at the answer but pretty busy, not very pleasing to the eye.

One thing I like about RAM is that it gives the utilization ratio for each mode of failure so you can easily see what controls.

RE: Tools for Baseplate and Anchor Design?

Dozer - Nice catch. I believe that is a manual input for Abrg. However I think that was CSC's standard example.  I do like the utilization ratio.  In Tedds they will show you the ratio in the design module but it is not shown in the output although there are a couple of output options.  I have not compared the results but sounds like the two are pretty similar.  

EIT

RE: Tools for Baseplate and Anchor Design?

Dont have a software suggestion for you, but a good design reference is the AISC Design Guide No. 1.   

RE: Tools for Baseplate and Anchor Design?

I agree with bluetree, that is what I use. If you follow the guidelines laid out DG #1 it is actually pretty easy to come up with a spreadsheet to do these calcs for you. Just don't follow the spreadsheet blindly.

As far as the embedment goes, this has been a thron in the side of a lot of engineers in my office. A lot of guys use the old school method of 17d, where d is the diameter of the bolt or rod but I'm not one to just blindly follow something because "that's the way its always been done". I reccommend ACI 349.2R-07.

RE: Tools for Baseplate and Anchor Design?

Jp-

it's only easy to make a spreadsheet for basic cases.  I made a spreadsheet a while back and it's exceptionally involved.  This is especially true where the breakout cone is controlled by three sides for tension or where the shear force is parallel to the edge instead of perpendicular.  Also, if there are eccentricities for shear or tension makin sure that the correct anchors see the additional forces from an elastic bolt group analysis only for the appropriate conditions is no smal feat either.

RE: Tools for Baseplate and Anchor Design?

SEIT:
Are you accessing the forums during the lunch break while taking the PE? :)

RE: Tools for Baseplate and Anchor Design?

I'm allowed to be here at lunch, aren't I?  I'm bored out of my mind sitting in my car. It took all of 7 minutes to eat my lunch.  I haven't seen any of the afternoon questions, so I didn't think it would be a problem.  Am I mistaken?  

RE: Tools for Baseplate and Anchor Design?

SEIT:

You are correct, the spreadsheet I have only uses 4-bolts but it does take into account moments and eccentricities.

I haven't made one for any type of embedment though.  Unfortunately I do that one by done by hand if abnormal conditions exist. And repetitious numbers calc'd out for reference. However, going through the steps once and creating a nice clean calc to reference back to when doing multiple runs is nice.

For reference, Powers Fasteners makes a program similar to Hilti Profis but not as aesthetically pleasing. Easy to use though.
 

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources