Pipe Flow and Pressure
Pipe Flow and Pressure
(OP)
This may be an elementary question, but I am having the hardest time finding the answer.
I have a 2" pipe that is running water at 50 psi (city pressure) with a valve on the end. Total length from the city main to the valve is about 100 ft. If I open this pipe up, fully open, to fill up a tank, what will the flow rate (gpm) be?
Thanks in advance for any help.
I have a 2" pipe that is running water at 50 psi (city pressure) with a valve on the end. Total length from the city main to the valve is about 100 ft. If I open this pipe up, fully open, to fill up a tank, what will the flow rate (gpm) be?
Thanks in advance for any help.





RE: Pipe Flow and Pressure
This isn't homework is it?
Additionally, is it work related?
Patricia Lougheed
******
Please see FAQ731-376: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies for tips on how to make the best use of the Eng-Tips Forums.
RE: Pipe Flow and Pressure
RE: Pipe Flow and Pressure
Flow is area*Cd*Sqrt(2gh)
Convert pressure to ft and plug in for 'h' = 50 psi = 115 ft H20
Cd is about 0.98 for a smooth opening
g is 32.2 ft/sec/sec
Comes out to about 55 GPM.
RE: Pipe Flow and Pressure
Velocity was calculated to be 5.6 ft/sec. Once I have the velocity the flow is calculated pretty easily through a 2" pipe.
Thus the answer is 55 GPM.
RE: Pipe Flow and Pressure
The big unknown is always whether the mains pressure will remain at the indicated value when the branch is flowing. But assuming that it remains at 50 psi you can use the online calculator at http://www.freecalc.com/fric.htm to determine the flow. Actually you have to do a bit of trial and error because the calculator requires you to enter the flow rate and it calculates the pressure drop.
Apart from the length and diameter, the details of the fittings are important. You can model the actual branch from the mains to the 2" pipe as one entrance effect plus one short radius 2" elbow. Also include one exit and your valve.
It looks like you should get about 240 USgpm.
Katmar Software
Engineering & Risk Analysis Software
http://katmarsoftware.com
RE: Pipe Flow and Pressure
RE: Pipe Flow and Pressure
I recommend downloading EPANET software (from EPA) and having it to model every pressurized net from a simple pipe to a full city network. So easy to use and still capable. You can even use it as a learning tool by playing the parameters and observing the results.
I have to say that I acknowledge the concept of "understanding" and then doing the model by few "clicks".
RE: Pipe Flow and Pressure
Good luck,
Latexman
RE: Pipe Flow and Pressure
HD2/HD1=(GPM2/GPM1)^2
HD1 is known: 50 psi
HD2 can be calculated by the pipe loss from the valve to the truck
GPM1 is calculated from HD1
and GPM2 is the fill rate of the tank
Job, you calculated the leaving flow rate from the valve. Now you need to figure the rest of the way.
It's been awhile since I've had to figure a flow rate this way. Usually I size the pump for full flow, and have to calculate the head to determine the pump size needed.
RE: Pipe Flow and Pressure
Ione- You are on the right track. I also made some unit mistakes in my initial calculation.
Using the formula
Flow = Area * Cd * Sqrt (2 * g * h) is correct, but it is like a tank emptying problem with no head loss. However, this is a representative equation if I know the pressure at the end of my line.
I calculated my head loss through my line with all the valves, fittings and turns and end up with about 30 PSI at the end of the line coming out to fill the truck.
If I recalculate with this number using the above equation and use Cd = 0.64 for a sharp edged nozzle I come up with...
0.93 ft^3/sec = 417 GPM.
Still seems like way too much. So after all that I'm still a little confused. I am expecting something less then 100 GPM out of a 2" line.
RE: Pipe Flow and Pressure
jt
RE: Pipe Flow and Pressure
To calculate the pressure drop you must have assumed a trial flow rate (which is the unknown of your problem).
I can reassure you that 417 usgpm in a 2" commercial steel pipe 100 ft long (neglecting fittings and entrance/exit effect) lead to a pressure drop of approx 120 psi. How could the main line be at 50 psig? You can't force your scenario to be something different from what it is.
RE: Pipe Flow and Pressure
pressure at the main is 50, pressure once the fluid leaves the nozzle is atmospheric. You have 50 psi or about 115 feet of head to work with. That head will be lost due to friction and turbulance losses 1)through the valve 2)through the pipe 3)through any bends or fittings 4)through the nozzle at the end. Ignoring all the minor losses and assuming all loss is due to pipe friction alone, your velocity will be 22 feet/sec and flow rate 220 gpm - more or less. Including the minor losses, I would expect much less flow.
Try Hazen-Williams method
http:
http://en.
RE: Pipe Flow and Pressure
The simple solution to your question is Bernoulli's equation (yes the simple equation for this simple question).
First, neglect the losses. considering Bernoulli, 50 psi (3.4 bar) corresponds to 34 meter height. if you have the end of your pipe in an elevation higher than 34 meter, then you will have no flow in the pipe (quite obvious, water doesn't run uphill!).But your pipe is 100 ft long(30.5 meter), so it never reaches to 34 meter above the city main (lucky you!).
Now, imagine your pipe end (filling tank)is in the same level as the city main (like taking water from the city main by a 2inch pipe to extinguish a fire at the ground level). Using Bernoulli, then you have V=25.8 meter/s that means 50 lit/sec (790 gpm)flow. Ummm, quite high. Did I misses something? YES, the losses. so again put the hf term (losses)in Bernoulli and solve the equation. Doing so you'll be able to calculate the flow.
Guys, I'm sorry but I'm a bit ahead in time of you that are sitting in US. I have to rush to get to a Friday party. But please you go ahead and follow some fundamentals here:
And
And
And after this review, I'd suggest to use EPANET or any other software to get out of the hand calculations.
Have a nice weekend.
RE: Pipe Flow and Pressure
Just to acknowledge, the exercises posted are from "2500 solved problems in fluid mechanics & hydraulics" by Evett and Cheng Liu.
RE: Pipe Flow and Pressure
RE: Pipe Flow and Pressure
1. Will the mains pressure drop when flow starts
2. What is the elevation difference to the truck
3. What schedule is the 2" pipe
4. What material (i.e. how rough) is the 2" pipe
5. What number and type of valves are in the line
6. What is the exact length of the line
7. What other fittings are in the line
we can really only give a ballpark figure.
Katmar Software
Engineering & Risk Analysis Software
http://katmarsoftware.com
RE: Pipe Flow and Pressure
However, I wonder why he didn't just ask the firemen? They've presumably been doing this all along and probably know reasonably closely how long it takes them to do it.
Patricia Lougheed
******
Please see FAQ731-376: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies for tips on how to make the best use of the Eng-Tips Forums.
RE: Pipe Flow and Pressure
The calculator Katmar posted and the Hazen-Williams method posted by cvg seem to be the most helpful.
Also most likely the residual pressure will be less then 50 psi when that 2" valve is wide open. Often we can get residual pressure tests on those main lines. That is something I will need to track down.
So with the reduced residual pressure the number will be less then 220 gpm and along with the fittings/valve losses I plugged into the on-line calculator I am ballparking the flow rate to be around 125 gpm. Once I get the residual pressure I will get a more definative answer.
Thanks for your help!
RE: Pipe Flow and Pressure
265 gpm
"I am sure it can be done. I've seen it on the internet." BigInch's favorite client.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hpiIWMWWVco
"Being GREEN isn't easy." Kermit
http://virtualpipeline.spaces.live.com
RE: Pipe Flow and Pressure
Cameron's Hydraulic Data book, for 2" SCH 40 new commercial steel pipe, shows 260 USGPM corresponding to a head loss of 113 ft per 100 ft of pipe.
That is at *start* of tank fill...
Close enough for me.
Regards,
SNORGY.
RE: Pipe Flow and Pressure
"I am sure it can be done. I've seen it on the internet." BigInch's favorite client.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hpiIWMWWVco
"Being GREEN isn't easy." Kermit
http://virtualpipeline.spaces.live.com
RE: Pipe Flow and Pressure
50/0.4338 = 115 ft = dH
100 + 10x2/12 = 102 ft (adding 10 diameters for unspecified valve)
Add "a bit" for entrance / exit losses, say 8 ft.
Thus L = 110 ft
then dH/L = 115 ft per 110 ft of pipe
Cameron says 113 ft per 100 ft of 2" SCH 40 pipe yields 260 USGPM.
My number was 259 USGPM.
BigInch's number was 265 USGPM.
cvg, 220 USGPM; katmar, 240 USGPM.
Results seem pretty good across the board.
Just to qualify my number a bit, I just "threw f=0.015" at it. Looking at the Moody charts in Crane, it probably should have been closer to f=0.02. Then my number works out to 228 USGPM - but remember that I am also carrying 1.5 velocity heads as additional losses for entrance and exit points. I am thinking that ~260 USGPM is a good number, depending on whatever assumptions are made.
Regards,
SNORGY.
RE: Pipe Flow and Pressure
If the stated objective is to figure out how much longer it would take to fill a tank with a 2" pipe instead of a 3" one, wouldn't it be easier to use the relative incompressibility of water and figure it out via a ratio:
V1t1=V2t2 where V is the volume and t is time?
If the pipes (or hoses or whatever) are pretty much the same length, this would roughly work out to the tank filling taking a bit more than twice as long.
Patricia Lougheed
******
Please see FAQ731-376: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies for tips on how to make the best use of the Eng-Tips Forums.
RE: Pipe Flow and Pressure
If you adjust your approach to say the volumetric flow rate will be proportional to the cross sectional area then you are effectively assuming the velocity in the pipe is the same for the 2 different pipe sizes. This is a reasonable assumption for a rough estimate, but in fact the velocity (for a fixed pressure drop) will be higher in the 3" pipe than in the 2". The higher flow rate in the 3" pipe will lower the residual pressure in the main, making the assumption of equal velocity closer to the truth.
Overall, I think you are coming close to the right answer, but for the wrong reasons.
Katmar Software
Engineering & Risk Analysis Software
http://katmarsoftware.com