×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

galvanized, weathering, painted steel

galvanized, weathering, painted steel

galvanized, weathering, painted steel

(OP)
almost all steel i work on uses galvanized steel.
am interested when weathering, painted, etc.. are used.

can someone link me to this.

my online search hasnt really helped me.

thanks,

RE: galvanized, weathering, painted steel

Weathering steel was used a lot on bridges in the 60's and 70's. It was marketed as a magic material that answered all your wants and needs. It turned out the weathering layer didn't adhere as well as expected in wind and rain, so the sections started to reduce in thickness.  This eliminated the advantage (no coating ever), so its use has greatly gone down.
As far as your ohter question, I'm not sure what you're driving at. Painted steel (or at least primed) should be used everywhere. Unless steel is not exposed to oxygen or water, it will corrode.

RE: galvanized, weathering, painted steel

(OP)
thanks,

i only have experience designing galvanized steel. i have not designed any steel that is painted.

RE: galvanized, weathering, painted steel

The question is very vague Delagina, what kind of designing do you do? Bridges/buildings/mechanical/industrial?

In general the decision of using weathering, painted or galvanized steel will come from analyzing a number of factors, such as location of the structure, use, environmental conditions, expected use and maintenance, design life...
The three systems provide different levels of protection at different costs.

It is very difficult to summarize it but in a couple of lines, paint is cheap, OK for most applications but requires maintenance. Galvanized gives the best protection with less maintenance required at a price. Weathering steel is supposed to be maintenance free but requires dry/wet cycles to develop the proper patina and has other issues such as staining.  

RE: galvanized, weathering, painted steel

Hi D,

See you into Structural design....

I do not know where in the world you come from but,

I work in South Africa in the cheaper residential structures and galvanizing are often prompted to be expensive and "the ordering of it" time consuming, therefore we paint most of our structural steel work,
that is often not the case with bigger projects thou,

 however,  the Galvanizing society had a huge marketing thing going on and they have compared the two systems and therefore I think I understand the differences,

Painted methods need more maintenance and application is important.

Galvanizing need lessor maintenance IF DONE AND INSTALLED CORRECTLY and therefore is cheaper over time,

Galvanizing is a chemical method while painting is a mechanical method – the paint get "sucked" to the steel,

Preparation for paint is done by sandblasting to remove slag - that is never done over here anyway, and the slag is burned automatically when galvanised

The design calcs is the same as strength are not influanced (I do not know if this is true with all grades of steel)

Tx for giving my 2 cents
 

RE: galvanized, weathering, painted steel

The clearest line in the US between galvanized and painted steel projects, is industrial vs. commercial projects.  Nearly all of our industrial projects are galvanized.  Most are exposed structures or have specific corrosion concerns which require the additional protection of galvanizing.  On the other hand nearly all of our commercial projects painted or provide no coating at all.  For highrise construction or  exposed steel structures (stadiums and arenas), painted coats are used to provide a Class B slip coefficient.  Class B can be achieved without paint, in projects that do not have exposed steel or where fire proofing is applied directly to the steel.   

http://www.FerrellEngineering.com

RE: galvanized, weathering, painted steel

(OP)
thanks. i work in industrial projects, refinery plant.

RE: galvanized, weathering, painted steel

Not sure exactly what you're looking for, but I've found the following AISC publication helpful when specifying painted protection for exposed structural steel:

http://www.aisc.org/WorkArea/showcontent.aspx?id=17506

There is a good discussion of the relative costs of different levels of painted protection and various surface prep methods..

RE: galvanized, weathering, painted steel

......just to add that combination of galvanizing and paint ( primer and top coat ) is very common in thin gauge steel sheets used in :
- electric/domestics appliances industry
- car manufacturing
- insulating panels used as roof and wall claddings
  (mainy in preengineered steel buildings )
    

RE: galvanized, weathering, painted steel

@JedClampett:  weathering steel for bridges is quite alive and well.

Hg

Eng-Tips policies:  FAQ731-376: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies

RE: galvanized, weathering, painted steel

Do they coat it?

RE: galvanized, weathering, painted steel

JC...weathering steel is typically not coated.

RE: galvanized, weathering, painted steel

Some designers or owners call for coating the ends because if the joint leaks deicing-salted water, that would be really hard on any steel, coated or not.  (I've seen plenty of painted girders with their ends rusting away under a leaky joint.)

But "wind and rain" are not an issue for weathering steel. (And I'd be interested in seeing your source for that claim.)  It's not good for splash zones or low-water crossings with frequent immersion, because with frequent rewetting the protective patina doesn't get a chance to form, but otherwise, it does well with ordinary weathering exposure ("wind and rain").

Hg

Eng-Tips policies:  FAQ731-376: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies

RE: galvanized, weathering, painted steel

I'm with HgTX on this..  

The whole idea of weathering steel is that the protection is, for lack of a better term, "built in".. In other words, it is a material property of the steel itself that a protective coat forms on the steel to prevent further corrosion, much like aluminum.. It is not a "coating" in the traditional sense of the word.

RE: galvanized, weathering, painted steel

This is stuff I heard a long time ago.  But I dug around and found this:
"The FHWA TA recommends caution in employing weathering steels in areas where the material could remain wet for extended periods of time due to high levels of rainfall, humidity or fog. The FHWA TA recommends evaluating these conditions using ASTM Test G 84 "Time of Wetness Determination (On Surfaces Exposed to Cyclic Atmospheric Conditions)." If the average time of wetness exceeds 60 percent, use of weathering steel is not recommended. No measurements of the time of wetness were taken at any of the bridge sites visited, so an assessment of the adequacy of the FJWA TA recommendation cannot be made. It has been reported by others that weathering steel in bridges located in the Northwest portion of the United States, west of the Cascade Mountain range, and southeastern Alaska, has not performed satisfactorily and required painting...."

However, contrary to what I said before, most of the experiences have been satisfactory. Read the whole report.

http://www.steel.org/Content/ContentGroups/Construction2/Bridges/AISI_Construction_Pe6.htm

RE: galvanized, weathering, painted steel

...agree with frv ,same idea as stainless steel in which chromium is the main element forming a protective coat on steel surface ( i.e. the reaction of chromium / oxygen )...

On the other hand, in my country weathering steel ( CORTEN ) is mainly used in Electric Power Authority's projects and in train manufacturing.  

RE: galvanized, weathering, painted steel

@Jed:  yeah, WS not recommended for what would essentially be immersion service, and one needs to design the structure to drain well because it doesn't like ponding either.

But for applications where it will work (which is most bridge applications in my opinion), I'm a fan.

Hg

Eng-Tips policies:  FAQ731-376: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources