×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

URGENT, PLEASE COMMENT

URGENT, PLEASE COMMENT

URGENT, PLEASE COMMENT

(OP)
i've just poured a waffle roof slab(flat) of a single family home. The beams are 6"x6" spaced 24" in both directions with 4-#3rebars and its slab is 3".
Now here comes my problem. The structural engineer specified the concrete resistance at 200kg/cm2 and they used 150kg/cm2. The structural engineer is not in town so I came here....

How critical is it?

*Attached is a JPEG
The area in red is my concern since it spans +/-14'
Everything is in centimeters.

RE: URGENT, PLEASE COMMENT

I wouldnt worry about it today, they are not going to remove the forms today correct? Long term might be an issue, but for the next couple days till the engineer returns, it will be curing and not achieve the 200kg anyway.  

RE: URGENT, PLEASE COMMENT

Could not find your attachment.

The concrete strength specified is 2840 psi.  The concrete strength used is 2130 psi.

When you say the beams are 6"x6", do you mean the overall depth is 9" including slab?  Or is it only 6"?

The low strength will affect deflection.  It should not significantly affect strength in bending, but it will affect shear strength.

Best plan is to wait for the engineer to return and give you his opinion.

BA

RE: URGENT, PLEASE COMMENT

I agree.  Wait for the engineer and also the cylinder breaks for the concrete samples.  Maybe the 200kg/cm2 will be there when tested.  Maybe the design still works with 150 kg/cm2.

www.PeirceEngineering.com

RE: URGENT, PLEASE COMMENT

(OP)
Thanks for your response.
No, they just pour it today but it has accelerator. Why will it be an issue in the long term? What can be done about it now?  I don't want to waste 407ft3 of concrete....

RE: URGENT, PLEASE COMMENT

Waiting for the Engineer to return is reasonable. To answer you second question:
"What can be done about it now?"
Regardless of what the specification requires for curing - start a "traditional" wet cure NOW.  Keep the concrete CONSTANTLY wet with sprinklers, soaker hose, burlap, Burlene, etc. At least this step will make the the 150 kg/cm2 concrete be its best.

www.SlideRuleEra.net idea
www.VacuumTubeEra.net r2d2

RE: URGENT, PLEASE COMMENT

(OP)
Answering BAretired:

Correct, the overall depth is 9". I've attached the file separately.

Let me clarify, it has already been poured, by the time he comes back it will be cured since is has accelerator...
If it's a major issue I rather remove the concrete NOW while I can.

RE: URGENT, PLEASE COMMENT

I dont see how you even know what the strengh is. Certainly they are not going to remove it based on your word, and not wait for the engineer. Long term, it might be that the design doesnt work, i.e. after 28 days, etc. For now, let it cure, cure it correctly and see what you get in 28 days. Also, by then, the engineer might say  its ok with 150.  

RE: URGENT, PLEASE COMMENT

Since your say that you are willing to remove the concrete, that is the best option. Much easier now and the long term technical and possible financial problems go away.  Even if the Engineer can and is willing to accept the concrete, the Owner may deduct partial payment from you as fair compensation for accepting substandard material. As a former Owner's representative, I would.

www.SlideRuleEra.net idea
www.VacuumTubeEra.net r2d2

RE: URGENT, PLEASE COMMENT

AdM22,

Follow SlidRuleEra's advice and wait for the engineer.   

BA

RE: URGENT, PLEASE COMMENT

Oops, SlideRuleEra came up with some more advice.  I was referring to his earlier thread where he advised you to wet cure it.  That would be my advice.

BA

RE: URGENT, PLEASE COMMENT

(OP)
Answering to engineertipsman:

1-I know because I order it myself.
2-yes, they will remove it based on my word.

I already got hold of the engineer, I am waiting for his response.

RE: URGENT, PLEASE COMMENT

AdM22,

It never pays to rush into things until you have had an opportunity to review all aspects.  There may well be a method of strengthening the most critical area (shaded red) after the concrete sets.   

BA

RE: URGENT, PLEASE COMMENT

(OP)
I agree BAretired, that's why I am waiting until he calls me back this afternoon.

Going back to your question regarding the slab, sorry, it's 6.5" overall.

Thanks to you all. I will keep you posted.

RE: URGENT, PLEASE COMMENT

AdM22...an accelerating admixture does not shorten the curing time...it only shortens the initial hydration time and initial set time.  Keep the curing process the same.

RE: URGENT, PLEASE COMMENT

I would advise you not to remove shoring until the matter is resolved. This will prevent any excessive deflection. If strength or deflection is an issue, an intermediate support may be required to resolve the situation. Did want to commend you for standing up and being forthright about the problem.

RE: URGENT, PLEASE COMMENT

Wet curing is good and leaving the shoring in as long as possible is good... best to wait until the engineer has reviewed it.

SRE... you may have to be careful about holding back some of the funds... in many jurisdictions, this has to be in agreement with the Contractor. In some jurisdictions, the only manner in which funds can be withheld is for the engineer to reject that portion of the Work outright.

Dik

RE: URGENT, PLEASE COMMENT

(OP)
Answering to DRC1:

Absolutely, if there´s an issue, I leave finger pointing aside and focus on resolving the matter. We all make mistakes, the problem is the cost associated with it. This is a great forum and I am very fortunate.

Answering to Dik:

Yes, wet curing is currently in the works and yes, shoring is not going anywhere.

Regarding your second comment, it´s not a concern first because I am in Mexico and second because I am the one in charge of construction. Nevertheless, thanks for your advise.

RE: URGENT, PLEASE COMMENT

dik - I know what you mean. I have spent a career negotiating this type settlement with Contractors. The Contractor always is given the option of removing and replacing the substandard material.

Usually it takes the stark choice between material replacement or negotiations to convince the Contractor that he can not disregard the specification, intentionally or accidentally, without (financial) consequences. Am happy to say that no contract that I've helped settle has resulted in legal action or arbitration. Also, the vast majority of the time, the Contractor would bid on and be awarded future projects - he must have been treated fairly during negotiations or we would not have heard from them again.

www.SlideRuleEra.net idea
www.VacuumTubeEra.net r2d2

RE: URGENT, PLEASE COMMENT

It was just a headzup... I've seen this done many times and unless people are being unreasonable, it can come to a relatively happy ending... One that I didn't do, but was involved in the litigation that followed ended up very badly for the Owner/Consultant.

With many contracts, the only way to 'technically' deal with it is to reject it outright... they often don't have anything between 'accept' and 'reject'.  My response was only cautionary.

Dik

RE: URGENT, PLEASE COMMENT

. . . in the meantime, might I suggest that you contact the ready mix company and ask them what their "historical" records are for the mix that you requested by mistake?  In addition, ask for the records over the last 30 or so samples to see what they have recently attained for 28-day strengths.  While this will not obviate the need for the breaks on your job, it might give some comfort (or not) regarding the likelihood that the concrete may be considered acceptable. As SRE and others have said, ensure that you cure properly and don't remove the support.  Do you have extra cylinders that you might break for a 3-day strength and a 14-day strength - to get a handle on the potential for reaching an acceptable 28-day value?

RE: URGENT, PLEASE COMMENT

200kg/cm2 (2840 psi) is pretty low for concrete in my area (Midwest USA). Most concrete, even if specified to be less, is going to break higher then that.

I'm not sure what commonly occurs where you're at but I'd hope you could expect high enough breaks.

To eas you mind somewhat, ask the mix provider to provide you with some of their historic test breaks(past jobs) for that mix. It can perhaps alieviate some concern if they typically are breaking higher than 200 kg/cm2

Boyd

RE: URGENT, PLEASE COMMENT

Yep. BigH has you covered on the advice. Good Job

RE: URGENT, PLEASE COMMENT

(OP)
Yes, it could be a relief...or not. I will post the results. Thanks!

RE: URGENT, PLEASE COMMENT

(OP)
Ok, I've just met with the concrete representative at the site and he tested the concrete strenght with a test hammer at 14 days and it already reached 200kg/cm2 and by 28 days he says it should reach 225kg/cm2.  He will give me a formal report by the end of the day.

He explained the Kilogram difference of cement in the mixture between the 200kg/cm2 and the 150kg/cm2 is only 5kg.

Thanks all of you that took the time to post.

-Andre

RE: URGENT, PLEASE COMMENT

That is indeed good news.

BA

RE: URGENT, PLEASE COMMENT

AdM22...before you get such a warm fuzzy feeling, keep in mind that the rebound hammer test is a poor indicator of compressive strength of the concrete and almost always overestimates the strength.

Sorry, but I would not rely on that type of test.  Get appropriate testing done or if samples were taken, wait for the 28 day results.

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources