×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

submersible centrifugal vs dry pit centrifugal pumps

submersible centrifugal vs dry pit centrifugal pumps

submersible centrifugal vs dry pit centrifugal pumps

(OP)
Designing wastewater treatment plant for non ferrous metal processing wastewater treatment in China. The Chinese typically prefer submersible pumps vs dry pit pumps. The tanks that submersible pumps will set in will also have large mixers running at over 100 rpm with a high rate of tank turnover. On the face of it the submersible seems to be a better choice, low NPSH, lack of cooling problems. My concern is air intake. Thoughts on this appreciated.

RE: submersible centrifugal vs dry pit centrifugal pumps

Can you share a sketch of your proposed arrangment with us.

 

RE: submersible centrifugal vs dry pit centrifugal pumps

(OP)
I uploaded diagram to ENGINEERING.com. The name of the file is "nonferrous_metal_EQtank.jpg"

RE: submersible centrifugal vs dry pit centrifugal pumps

attach the link to a posting, makes life easier and saves us the problem of searching for it.

RE: submersible centrifugal vs dry pit centrifugal pumps

Air entering the submersible pump (or dry pit pump for that matter) is a good possiblility if the water levels in the tank vary.  The mixer will introduce air into the process when the water levels in the tank drop too low.  submersible mixers perform differently with different working water levels.  

For a similar situation, see thread407-276105: Centrifugal Pump Cavitating on tank changeover .  

RE: submersible centrifugal vs dry pit centrifugal pumps

nothing there.

RE: submersible centrifugal vs dry pit centrifugal pumps

Correct. Link is not working.

RE: submersible centrifugal vs dry pit centrifugal pumps

Whether you have submersible pumps or dry pit pumps and a mixer in a common sump you run the same chance of air being beaten into the pumped product ending up in the pump.

If entrained air looks to be a problem the solution is to ensure the mixer is always submerged - however,this in itself may not be cure, even submerged mixer can entrain a lot of free air from the surface, the second solution is to shut down the mixer at a pre-determined sump level so as not to entrain air - alternately use both, keep the mixer submerged and shut it down when air is starting to be entrained.

I have seem a change of direction of the mixer eleviate an air entrainment problem.

Mixers and pumps can be a very poor combination, especially in small sumps.    

RE: submersible centrifugal vs dry pit centrifugal pumps

(OP)
Artisi

Thanks for this great tip, I thought as much so I am going to go ahead and make necessary design changes based on your input.  

RE: submersible centrifugal vs dry pit centrifugal pumps

One other point you need to consider is the inflow, if it is allowed to free-fall into the sump this can also drive air into the pumped product - try and discharge via a pipe if necessary below the sump working level.  

RE: submersible centrifugal vs dry pit centrifugal pumps

Your mixer manufacturer will advise you what the minimum working water level in the tank should be to prevent air being entrained in the water.  The blade design greatly affects things.  You really have to talk to the mixer manufacturer.  There is a lot of science behind the mixing


For a similar situation, that was solved, see thread407-276105: Centrifugal Pump Cavitating on tank changeover: Centrifugal Pump Cavitating on tank changeover .   

RE: submersible centrifugal vs dry pit centrifugal pumps

(OP)
Artisi and Quality Time

A great lesson in troubleshooting pump noise, air entrainment problems from mixers, NPSH and so forth Based on this education, going to use variable speed centrifugal pumps, keep the EQ tank large and deep and also going to use submersible pumps. Going to independent mixer expert to review mixer selection recommended by sales engineer.   

RE: submersible centrifugal vs dry pit centrifugal pumps

Guess you also need to review mixer effect on the sump and the level at which it is installed / stops / starts etc. If the mixer shuts down a too high a level will it keep the lower level of the sump agitated and the solids in suspension?

     

RE: submersible centrifugal vs dry pit centrifugal pumps

You are welcome...try Chemineer....they have some engineering depth  

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources