×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

left hand threads on left hand wheel studs

left hand threads on left hand wheel studs

left hand threads on left hand wheel studs

(OP)
This is a question that I have tried hard to find a legitimate answer for, I hope you can help.  It relates to large vehicles with stud centered wheels, where the common practice is to use left hand thread studs on the left had side of the vehicle.  The common wisdom is that there is a self-tightening action from having the lug nuts on a counter-clockwise turning wheel tighten in a counter-clockwise direction,, but it is related to the taper (or ball) seating of the lug nut onto the wheel, since washer style lug nuts used with later hub centered wheels use the more common right hand taper all the way around the vehicle.

So the question is - what is the engineering reason for using LH studs on the LH side of the vehicle, and what is is physical phenomenon that is causing a taper seat lug nut to require this while a washer seat lug nut doesn't?

thanks very much, Brian

RE: left hand threads on left hand wheel studs

I have wondered myself why some car makers did this. The Chrysler Valiant (in Oz) was like this - very awkward undoing the wheel nuts if you didn't know they were left-hand threads. Does any company still use this system?    

RE: left hand threads on left hand wheel studs

A whole lot don't do it and they have no serious issues with wheels falling off, so at best it could be seen as an extra expense and complication to solve a non existent problem while creating a new problem for non suspecting owners when the need to change a wheel.

Regards
Pat
See FAQ731-376: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies for tips on use of eng-tips by professional engineers &
http://eng-tips.com/market.cfm
for site rules
 

RE: left hand threads on left hand wheel studs

I suspect it has nothing to do with lug nut type.
Maybe the more modern washer style  is just accompanied
 by more modern theory,
  (that the Coriolis effect is too small to worry about)?

 It's definitely more trouble than it's worth.

RE: left hand threads on left hand wheel studs

A few of the pre war theories made it post war.  One of which is the left hand thread on the wheel cap screws (Chrysler products in my experience).  Like has been posted, my dad told me it was because in the early cars the left side wheels tended to loosen in use.  Dunno.  Never thought too much about it...just pleased that it's no longer a problem.

However---This is for those of you that have owned and/or raced pre war and post war MG's---They did have a nasty little habit of loosening the left rear axle nut (RHT) allowing the drum to come off, BTDT!  Some later Ford/UK cars had problems with the LF nut backing off due primarily to a faulty stamped 'tang' washer and improperly packed wheel bearings, also BTDT!  

Of course, on the other hand, a LHT axle nut could have caused the bearings to seize from being overtightened???  Well, maybe not as I never had any problems with right side axle nuts.

Live long enough, own and drive enough miles in old (pardon me, VINTAGE) cars and your sure to find the built in/design flaws.  I never had a wheel loosen because of LHT/RHT OEM design, old or newer cars.  I just chalk it up to "lack of sufficient knowledge/customary design" of the times.  Times when if "X" would probably work okay, then let's go "2X" just to be on the safe side.  Bean counters nightmare?

Rod

 

RE: left hand threads on left hand wheel studs

Q: What is the engineering reason for using LH studs on the LH side of the vehicle?

A: As you alluded to, it is due to the idea of self-tightening of the threaded fasteners from rotation of the clamped (but almost unclamped) components.

Q: What is is physical phenomenon that is causing a taper seat lug nut to require this while a washer seat lug nut doesn't?

A: None.  As FoMoCoMoFo stated, nut-washer assemblies are newer and it has been found over time that left hand threads do not provide enough value/benefit for the effort/cost involved.

RE: left hand threads on left hand wheel studs

As an AA patrol and oncea service manager in the Commercial vehicle sector I have seen a number of vehicles were the wheels have come loose and lost from the left hand rear wheel station. Even with the correct torque setting wheels will still come loose on the left hand side of the vehicle. This esp found on light commercial vehicles ie 3.5t to 7.5 tonne.   

RE: left hand threads on left hand wheel studs

Rod, I had a big Healey that stripped the splines on the LF wire wheel; when I'd put on the brakes, the hub would stop, the wheel would not (it made an "interesting" noise!!!).  It had (as I recall) LHT's on the left side of the car.  If it didn't, when my spines stripped, the knock-off nut would have unscrewed the first time I put on the brakes.  

Could this type of experience be the origin of this practice?

RE: left hand threads on left hand wheel studs

Probably not, Ross.  I think I've seen LHT on the lug bolts of a pretty early 20's car...Plymouth/Dodge, maybe?

I did have the LR wheel of my 50 TD come off once.  Stopped with the hand brake and walked back to pick up the shoes, springs, etc.  Put it all back together and continued on.  Ahhhh, the good old days.  
In 1962, the Lucas electrics failed on our 58 MGA coupe between Heber and Snowflake AZ (look it up) and taped two flashlights to the roof...and...continued on...Life's little ups and downs, eh?

Rod

RE: left hand threads on left hand wheel studs

"the Lucas electrics failed on our 58 MGA coupe"

Go on!  Not really?!  LOL  In all fairness, I have to say none of my Brit cars ever had the usual Lucas issues.  Brit motorcycles, that's a different story...

RE: left hand threads on left hand wheel studs

Maybe the Coriolis effect does work on bolts that aren't tightened enough? You still do see these still in practice on some modern vehicles, but most passenger cars tend to just use a normal thread these days.

Wheel bolts on passenger cars (only thing I tinker on) that come off, usually are because of the wrong torque used, wrong bolts being used (wrong angle for the centering bit, too short thread part) or stripped threads in my experience. People do underestimate the importance of the correct torque being applied on bolts in combination with cast alloy wheels. Deformation of the rim and metal fatigue in the bolts leading to bolts loosening and shearing is probably too complex for car mechanics and owners.

RE: left hand threads on left hand wheel studs

On the few dozen alloyed wheel vehicles I have known the clamped interface surrounding the bolt/stud is "solid metal." Thus all the "stretch" occurs in the bolt.

Steel wheels on cars often (but not always) have some arch or contour near the bolt that puts the bolt/nut seat on a plateau or mezzanine up in the air, similar to a belleville washer.
http://image.made-in-china.com/2f0j00JMHtmDwdpzcZ/Steel-Wheel.jpg
http://www.hubcaps-wheelcovers.com/photo/img_3070%20(2).jpg

So when thing are tightened the arch flattens as the wheel deforms elastically.

Since maintaining preload ( one of my best friends) requires that the amount of stretch far exceeds the potential embedment, etc, alloy wheels would seem to have a much greater chance of becoming loose over time than typical passenger car car steel wheels.

Tire shops often have a standard note on their invoices saying cars with alloy wheels must be returned for re-torquing in XX days/miles. The Sears service writer looked  at the sculptured plastic factory hubcaps retained by the lugnuts on my mom's Honda and told me I had to come back for a re-torque, and stamped my receipt accordingly.

http://www.realpolice.net/forums/archive/t-89565.html
http://www.normarkindustries.com/LooseLugNuts6.25Million.htm

 

RE: left hand threads on left hand wheel studs

Funny thing happened on the way to victory in the Japanese Grand Prix at Suzuka last night...Seems that a couple left rear wheels came off during the race....Hmmmmm !!!

Rod

RE: left hand threads on left hand wheel studs

Formula 1 wheel nuts have a locking mechanism and are single centerpiece items. If the mechanism fails, inertia alone would make it possible for them to come undone. True, there are similarities to the multi-bolt setups for passenger cars, but I don't think it's a fair comparison.

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources