The common interpretation of Ontario Building Code (OBC) is that the reference is not lower base of the foundation and in most cases is the lower level of building (AKA top of foundation). For example, if you have a site with thick soft clay and use pile foundations driven to the bedrock for support of the building, you can NOT consider the site as Class B. Similarly, if the soft clay is medium thickness (say 3 meter) and you decide to use deep footing placed on the bedrock for the support of the building, it is still NOT a Class B.
I believe the idea is that the pile and/or foundation wall (of the footing placed over bedrock) are not going to move completely independent of the clay mass surrounding the pile/foundation wall when earthquake hits. There would be interaction and therefore, the soft clay mass will have some effect on the foundation movement. It would not be similar to a case when the footing is placed over bedrock with thin stiff overburden soil (hence not Class B).
On the other hand, as I mentioned this interpretation applies to most cases. For example, in case of a building with multi-level basement and perimeter retaining walls being part of the structure, it is not completely correct to consider the lower level of the building. In my opinion and by the same logic noted above, the perimeter retaining wall that are in contact with the structure and extend all the way to the ground surface would have some effect to the movement of the building and therefore, considering the lower level of the building for site classification may be incorrect (particularly, if the soil between the ground surface and foundation level is much weaker than the soil below foundation). In this particular case, considering the ground surface may also be conservative. In a case like this, it is better to conduct a detail site specific assessment to come up with the parameters (It may save some money). If the owner does not want to spend the cost of detail analyses, they you have no choice unless to assume it from ground surface. |
|