×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Does humidity change vacuum

Does humidity change vacuum

Does humidity change vacuum

(OP)
I have a process that involves picking up a 3/16"x30"x60" piece of glass with a small vacuum system. Recently we have experienced a situation where the glass falls from the device. We currently have very high humidity and I am curious if vacuum increases or decreases as the humidity increases.

RE: Does humidity change vacuum

How do you think the humidity would affect negative pressure?  It more sounds like your nozzle material is not making a complete connection/seal with the glass.   

Tobalcane
"If you avoid failure, you also avoid success."  

RE: Does humidity change vacuum

How are you creating vacuum?

RE: Does humidity change vacuum

(OP)
I am using a small electric motor connected to a vacuum pump.  

RE: Does humidity change vacuum

smiao,
Did you measure the system pressure during the lifting cycle?  If it is high, then there a few things to check.

Are there any pockets in the system where water could condense?  If so, the demand may be significantly greater for the vacuum pump on days of high humidity where water would need to be flashed prior to obtaining the design vacuum.

Are there any leaks in the system that only show up when you move the lifting tool/head?  

RE: Does humidity change vacuum

Clean the rubber pad...it's probably dirty.  Moisture will enhance the sealing but to my knowledge, has no substantial effect on the vacuum.

RE: Does humidity change vacuum

Is there a depression associated with the increased humidity?

Since a vacuum lifter actually relies on atmospheric pressure to do its lifting, you would expect the available force to vary with barometric pressure.  The difference between a high pressure and a low pressure day is usually less than 10%, but if your margin between lifting and dropping is a bit narrow, reduced pressure isn't going to help.

Direct answer to your theoretical question is that the lift should reduce with rising humidity (water vapour is about half the density of dry air, so the more there is in the mix, the lower the barometric pressure you should expect).

A.

RE: Does humidity change vacuum

Back to your title "does humidity change vacuum".  No.  Changes in humidity can change vacuum, but if you pull a vacuum the remaining gas will have a humidity that is reflected in the vacuum gauge.  On the other hand if the remaining air is at high humidity then a temperature change can cause some of the humidity to condense which will significantly increase the vacuum (fill a vessel with steam, isolate it, let the temperature bleed of to ambient, pressure will drop to vacuum with condensation).

David

RE: Does humidity change vacuum

David...are you nuts?!  You can't throw common sense into this mess!!lol
Ron

RE: Does humidity change vacuum

But in all likelihood your problem is something much more mundane - like a leak.

RE: Does humidity change vacuum

I have to disagree with David on this one.  Humidity (the presence of water vapor) does affect how much vacuum you can pull.  Where no water vapor is present, vacuum can be pulled to very very low torr values (if you have the equipment capable of doing that).  However, where moisture is present, the vacuum attainable is limited by the vapor pressure of the moisture at the temperature of that moisture - until (and if) of course the moisture is all 'boiled' away by the vacuum.

I could always get to a deeper vacuum more quickly on A/C systems by taking a propane torch and applying some gentle heat to key parts of the system while pulling vacuum - areas where oil accumulated.

rmw

RE: Does humidity change vacuum

Water vapor is just a gas.  If I pull all of the gas that is in a container down to a very low remaining mass, the mixture of remaining gases will be the same provided there was nothing in the vessel except gas to start with.  If I started with 100% RH and that number represented 2,000 lbm/MMCF then at the end, the remaining gas will have 2,000 lbm/MMCF just like I started with (although the RH humidity will now be closer to 10% than 100% because at very low pressures the gas can hold more water vapor).  If I had 19% oxygen at the beginning I'll have 19% oxygen at the end.

In other words, there is nothing magical about water vapor.  It is just a gas.  The vacuum equipment will suck out whatever gases it encounters be they nitrogen, oxygen, or water vapor.  

I've seen very deep vacuum pulled inside vessels with a coherent gas/water interface.  In that case the volume percent of water vapor increased by at least an order of magnitude because the liquid kept evaporating to maintain 100% RH.  By the time we reached 29"Hg (we were at sea level or just below), there was very little in the vessel besides water vapor and not much of that.

David.

RE: Does humidity change vacuum

How much vacuum do you use?

RE: Does humidity change vacuum

It doesn't matter.

If you are dropping glass, then your vacuum is inadequate.

If it was working before, but isn't now, then something changed, and relative humidity or not, it needs to be fixed to cover the range of requirements.

So... what was the vacuum gauge reading when you installed the system, and what is it now?

What was the air flow reading AT THE CUPS when you installed the system, and what is it now?

How old is the vacuum pump? They are only good for so long before they need to be replaced or rebuilt.

Did you change the filter?

Are you using a filter?

Did you check the lines for leaks and kinks?

Are you using stiff tubing of the right diameter?

Do you have a lot of fittings in the mess?

Are the lines dirty?

How old are the vacuum cups? They don't last forever.

I deal with vacuum systems every day, it's never been the humidity. It's one of the above issues. The humidity inside the vacuum pump is the same air as outside.
 

Charlie
www.facsco.com

RE: Does humidity change vacuum



...coming in late, and will give further the advice from qualified instrumentation mechanics i know:

if a device do not work, take it carefully apart, clean it, set it equally careful together again, without touching or screwing on any control or regulating part. In more than 90 percent of all cases, it will work properly.

For vacuum: even tiny, microscopic cracs will give leaks, rubber or elastic devices can have 'invisible' breaks in unseemingly places, for instance metal/rubber bridges or on glass contact surfaces or at lips.

All elastic cups to be exchanged.    

RE: Does humidity change vacuum

Interesting discussion.

I would think that humidity DOES change with the creation of a vacuum.  Is not the definition of humidity the percentage of water vapor per unit volume of medium?

A vacuum IS NOT negative pressure, but correctly any pressure below atmospheric.  The negativity aspect comes from the fact that the surrounding atmosphere weights more heavily on the membrane of the vessel, i.e. the outside air is crushing the vessel since we no longer have a balanced pressure on either side of the wall of the containment.  I would like to point out that in space, there are an average of only three molecules per litre, absolute vacuum means zero molecules.  This lends itself well to the physics of the chemistry, pressure is the reactive force of molecular impact at the wall of the pressure vessel.  So vacuum IS NOT negative pressure in the true sense of the mathematics.

As all as we are doing is pulling medium from a confined, enclosed space so would I not be changing the "unit volume" measure in the ratio of water vapor per volume of medium?  The denominator decreasing means that the humidity is rising.

To visualize this, I start sucking out air from a containment and sooner or later begin to see "fog".  That would be the dewpoint, would it not?  In other words I would be creating "rain" inside the containment vessel as the pressure begins to drop since I hit 100% humidity.

I believe this is consistent with thermodynamic computations in the two phase region of the CV curves.

Kenneth J Hueston, PEng
Principal
Sturni-Hueston Engineering Inc
Edmonton, Alberta Canada

RE: Does humidity change vacuum

Okay, the above mental exercise assumes that as the vacuum is being created, the volume of water remains constant inside the container.  But as I draw out air, would I not be also drawing out water vapor in an unbais way?

So then humidity would remain constant, since the percentage of water vapor to volume of air are removed at the same rate.  The ratio of water to air remains constant so then humidity would not change.

So I just confused myself.  Not a clue if it rises (argument 1) or remains constant (argument 2).  I'm very happy this is not an exam question, I would probably take the pipe on this one!

But have fun with it!

Kenneth J Hueston, PEng
Principal
Sturni-Hueston Engineering Inc
Edmonton, Alberta Canada

RE: Does humidity change vacuum

Think in terms of mass.  If the air has a water content of 0.1% at atmospheric pressure it still has 0.1% by mass at 30 inHg of vacuum.

It gets confusing when you start talking about relative humidity.  As pressure goes down (or temperature goes up), the amount of water vapor that the air can hold (i.e., the mass of water that constitutes 100% RH) goes up dramatically.  So, if the 0.1% mass at atmospheric pressure corresponds to 100% RH, then at 30 inHG that same mass percent is now 25% RH since the air can hold so much more water vapor at low pressure.

The "fog" discussion above doesn't seem quite right.  I could see pulling a deep vacuum on a vessel with a coherent air/water interface and letting it equilibrate to 100% RH (probably have to circulate the air to do it).  Then when you start raising pressure (say by inserting a piston to reduce volume).  At some point, you will exceed 100% RH and the condensing water can fog.  Going the other way, the air will be consistently more able to hold water vapor and shouldn't fog.

David

RE: Does humidity change vacuum

(OP)
Thanks to everyone for their help with this issue. Apparently I asked a reasonably good question.

As a fairly simple minded person I believed the problem to be mechanical in nature so after a good cleaning of the air filter, hoses and suction cups the issues seems to be corrected (we can not pull the glass off the device).

I posted this question more from a theoretical perspective, I do believe that after watching the gauges on the machine that elevated levels of humidity coupled with elevated levels of temperature do have an impact (seems to increase vacuum) but in this case not enough to be relevant.   

RE: Does humidity change vacuum

>  But, there are way more other things that correlate with high temperatures besides RH.  Many of those are probably more of an impact on performance than RH.

>  I don't think that the pumped vacuum (dynamic) is the same situation as a low pressure (static).  In the latter case, it's the partial pressure of water at a given temperature that drives the amount of water vapor.  So, unless there's liquid water, the partial pressure cannot be sustained.  In the former case, the pressure is being actively maintained, and there is a concentration gradient that drives diffusion of molecules toward the pump.  This is independent of the partial pressure question, and the other other molecules in the system can also steer the more recalcitrant molecules towards the exit.  This mode is similar to that of a high-vacuum diffusion pump, where hot, vaporized oil essentially drives gas molecules away from the vacuum chamber towards the mechanical pump.

The mechanical pumping process, be it diaphragm, scroll, or turbo, is mechanically unaware of whether a molecule is water, or not, and will pump it away.  That said, it might be possible that water intrusion into the pumping mechanism might degrade its pumping efficiency.

TTFN

FAQ731-376: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies

RE: Does humidity change vacuum

Good that your problem seems to have been solved.

It seems to me that the lift/hold force this system is capable of delivering would be proportional to the pressure difference between the atmosphere and the inside of your vacuum system.  If you reach 1/10th of an atmosphere in your vac system, you've achieved 90% of the lifting/holding force you'd achieve at full vacuum.  A little condensed water inside the equipment/tubing might drop your maximum achievable vacuum to the vapour pressure of water at room temperature (~ 0.03 atmospheres), but that wouldn't make much difference on your ability to lift.

A little liquid water WOULD make a HUGE difference in your ability to achieve a high vacuum, like the one you desire in a tubing system prior to filling it with refrigerant!

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources