×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

virtual fishbone

virtual fishbone

virtual fishbone

(OP)
this ought to be fun for some out there -
What environmental/application factors can contribute to increased alternating stress in connecting rod bolts, while running in the engine?

- impending piston siezure, leading to increased tension
- engine overspeed giving higher tension
- rod large end lateral deformation due to _x_ leading to bending
- etc...

 

RE: virtual fishbone

Where "_x_" might include..
.. improper setup, terminal wear, or outright failure of the engine's main thrust bearing, allowing thrust loads to be applied to the conrod(s).
 

Mike Halloran
Pembroke Pines, FL, USA

RE: virtual fishbone

(OP)
good one.
how about detonation... it's hard to picture how, but do you think that could lead to big end deformation?

 

RE: virtual fishbone

(OP)
in the same vein, how about if the bore spacing were incorrect...  resulting on thrusts in opposite directions for a pair of rods?
 

RE: virtual fishbone

Are you picking on me, Isaac?

Bore spacing, at least on the production engine would seem a stretch...A 'one off', perhaps.

Detonation usually leads to other failures first in a properly designed engine...However, I have had the bearing shells torn up by det a couple times.  Perhaps left to it's ultimate conclusion, a rod bolt failure would be possible.

Most of my rod bolt failures have been the result of over-revs and or too long in service....too many races on that engine, etc.

Rod

RE: virtual fishbone

(OP)
yeah, the bore spacing seems a stretch.  

 

RE: virtual fishbone

You have a point, Pat.  

EVERY TIME, yes, each and every time I've had a rod separate, had a pin pull out or a rod bolt break, it has been when I lifted to shift or at the end of a long straight.  Trailing throttle problem, for sure!

Rod

RE: virtual fishbone

(OP)
you guys are right, of course, for that application.  at the moment I'm primarily thinking about a turbocharged constant speed / constant load engine.  still, it's a useful thing to bear in mind.
 

RE: virtual fishbone

how about a learner driver kangaroo hopping at low speed after letting out the clutch too quickly. alternating full throttle and let off

A tidy mind not intelligent as it ignors the random opportunities of total chaos. Thats my excuse anyway
Malbeare
www.sixstroke.com

RE: virtual fishbone

I would have to agree that most rod issues are from the decel and not the accelration....when useing a direct drive like a standard trans....autos are not as bad.......fastner companys...i would only use the best...so see what the rod company uses and offers...

Engine detonation is also right as it will beat a rod brg. into submistion..it wasnt that many years ago methanol and nitro burning engines we tuned by the rod brgs.....yes before data recorders....and even today with all the recorders i still read my brgs....

How said rod bolt is tourqed and is it done by strecth guage or just a tourge wrench thats 25 years old....strech gauge is the only true way of doing it corectly IMOP..This also is the biggest reason of bolt failure from decel because the rod bolt has been streched to far from over tourqe...i think ARP gives there specs at 75% of bolt capacity....Ktech are a good bolt and i like  A-1 out of all of them...

Johnny

RE: virtual fishbone

SPS also make some very nice bolts.

There are a huge number of engines that run the entire life of the engine with rod bolts tightened by a good accurate torque wrench used correctly. That is also how most main cap bolts and head bolts are installed as there is no place to measure stretch.

I agree stretch is a better method, but it is only really necessary if the bolts are marginal.

Poor workmanship or poor tools can result in a failure by either method.

Regards
Pat
See FAQ731-376: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies for tips on use of eng-tips by professional engineers &
http://eng-tips.com/market.cfm
for site rules
 

RE: virtual fishbone

How about running with a non-standard piston; one that is heavier than originally designed for, such as might happen in an engine intended for moderate boost/cylinder pressure which is then uprated, and your piston supplier recommends moving from an aluminium piston to a heavier steel Monotherm or similar?

PJGD

RE: virtual fishbone

Pat I agree with what your saying,but a main and a rod are 2 differant forces...and yes done for years but why are there dimples in the center of any quality rod bolt?
Just like all the tourqe to yeild head bolts...but we are talking rod BOLTS....

Do you think Hendrick engine builders use a strech or a wrench on the rods?Any major nascar team...?

My aluminum rods are a cap bolts and I have no choice...I take great care in how i do them and what extentions add to the equation and the sockets as well....this may seem anal but my engines come down after every weekend and sometimes at the track so I have alot more to look at as I measure them on a service schedual that i maintain...

I have done many motors over many years also,I am just adding to what causes or can and the proper way which if you ask any rod manufacture is to use strecth because of the variables with wrenches...

RE: virtual fishbone

(OP)
we do use stretch for all our rods, but typically not by measuring stretch itself (although that is done in certain cases). It is much more common to set stretch by using a torque+turn tightening method, where the initial torque gets the joint snug and the turn angle sets the stretch.

Hydraulic tensioning is common for large engine head bolts - the bolt is stretched hydraulically to a desired amount of stretch, and a nut is gently (as w/fingers) tightened, then hydraulic tension is removed.  This is even done in the field on these engines.

 

RE: virtual fishbone

Johny---Stretch is the only way to accurately set rod bolt torque.  The idea that I ck every rod bolt on every engine I build each and every time I tq them is a bit of a 'stretch' (pardon the pun).

Typically, I check the stretch on several rod bolts in a set and then use the tq determined by those cks as a final setting for assembly...USING MY TQ WRENCH!  I see nothing good coming from ME cking the stretch and YOU doing the assembly with another tq wrench.

Isaac--- In the field, using bolt stretch to set final tq is pretty common.  Handy little gadget...labor saving device, and assembly is a breeze...especially when the bolts are ~2" dia.  Even at that, the stretch is determined in the "lab" and all we get in the field is the pressure settings on the gauge of the Porta-Power.


Rod

 

RE: virtual fishbone

(OP)
re: " to set final tq "

The critical point is that bolt torque is not important.  The desired outcome is a particular amount of stretch (which gives you a particular joint preload).  The torque required to achieve that stretch can vary wildly for a given set of geometry based on differences in lubrication, surface condition, cleanliness, etc., even between repeated installations of the same hardware.  

Yes, the required force (and therefor pressure) is determined in advance when the joint is designed.  Luckily the hydraulic piston diameter doesn't change much over time.  

There's a nifty tool which uses an embedded chip on each bolt head to make before and after length measurements.  
 

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources