×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Water Water Everywhere or It Makes No Sense.

Water Water Everywhere or It Makes No Sense.

Water Water Everywhere or It Makes No Sense.

(OP)
I need to sense water level in a small tank with tap water.

I set out to detect it via conduction.  I capacitively excite a probe with 1kHz 24V pulses.  I look at the same probe by charging a capacitor via a simple diode rectifier.  If the probe touches the water in the grounded metal tank the DC pulse train is supposed to diminish dramatically.  The loss should appear on the sensing cap and the comparitor should signal the loss.

It's not working..  I have reduced the caps from 2.2uF clear down to 1000pf. At 1000pf the comparator trips every pulse for about 1/3 the period.  It still doesn't definitively trip.

By "caps" I'm referring to both C25 and C27 at the same time.
The comparator's trip point is 4V.
The comparator is running the LED you see.
TP28 Has the 1kHz pulse train on it. This is cycling the drive comparator at the top.


http://www.box.net/shared/static/bopujnd0xu.png

Suggestions?

Keith Cress
kcress - http://www.flaminsystems.com

RE: Water Water Everywhere or It Makes No Sense.

Uh oh. Remember the 'World's Longest Eng-Tips Thread' about measuring the depth of water in a well? Here we go again... winky smile

Are your probe wires insulated from the water? I seem to recall a circuit that used capacitance to measure water height (similar) and the wires were (IIRC) fully insulated from the water (including the tips).

 

RE: Water Water Everywhere or It Makes No Sense.

Tap water using conduction?
My take on this is that tap water conduction varies immensely from location to location and also over time.

Wouldn't it be better to measure reactance, given that water has a dielectricity constant of around 80?

Just my 2 cents.

Benta.
 

RE: Water Water Everywhere or It Makes No Sense.

I was thinking the same thing, VE winky smile

Time to call up Polaroid and get one of their ultrasonic sensors :-p

Dan - Owner
http://www.Hi-TecDesigns.com

RE: Water Water Everywhere or It Makes No Sense.

GEMS level sensors; floats with magnets, reed switches.
Inexpensive, and reliable as mechanical devices go.

Retroreflective sensor looking at the flat end of a pencil-shaped piece of plexi will sense the difference btw air and water at the point.  "Delco Eye".

Honeywell makes something commercially that sort of does the same thing through a penetration in the bottom of the tank using a transparent hemisphere.  It's British, so follow the app notes exactly or it won't work.

If the tank is transparent, you can do the critical angle thing through the wall with no actual penetrations.  It's simple enough to do with discretes; no one is doing it commercially.


 

Mike Halloran
Pembroke Pines, FL, USA

RE: Water Water Everywhere or It Makes No Sense.

Not quite seeing the reason for back-to-back diodes to ground (D4)...won't those swamp anything the probe is doing?

RE: Water Water Everywhere or It Makes No Sense.

Sorry, smoked, sent that last too soon.

What are the metals used for the probe and tank, and can you measure an emf from probe to ground with probe decoupled from circuit, and/or with power off to circuit.  Idea being dissimilar metals will produce a battery-like emf, and it can fubar low voltage signals.  24 v should be enough, but those diodes in the path may not play nice, dunno.

RE: Water Water Everywhere or It Makes No Sense.

(OP)
Yes I'm  bit concerned about wild conductivity variations.

The dielectric change method is probably the better way.. Dang.   What do dielectric type probes look like?  Just bare rods near each other?  Or are they insulated to exclude water conductivity?

This is a pressure vessel.  In fact a steam generator too.  So it runs above atmosphere.  So floats are out. The really cool total-internal-reflection eyes (Delco like) are out. Reed switches, etc., etc., are all out!  No ultrasonics either.


btrue; These are standard probes that are stainless rods that are slightly bent. By twisting the rod you adjust the water level since it will touch the water at different points depending on its position.  The tanks are stainless.

I am able to use a DMM to measure a resistance when I hook it from the probe to the tank.

Keith Cress
kcress - http://www.flaminsystems.com

RE: Water Water Everywhere or It Makes No Sense.

With pulsed DC, won't you end up with electrolysis occurring? Do you see any bubbles forming on the electrodes that could affect the current flow?

Glenn

RE: Water Water Everywhere or It Makes No Sense.

Floats are definitely an option, they are used in plenty of LP boiler applications up to about 20 Bar or so. How much room have you got though - some of them are kinda chunky.

What about a DP cell arranged top to bottom? If you're careful with the impulse lines that would work fine, it's done often enough with things like deaerators.
  

----------------------------------
  
If we learn from our mistakes I'm getting a great education!
 

RE: Water Water Everywhere or It Makes No Sense.

(OP)
geekEE; It was thought that capacitively coupling the probe to the excitation would provide an average.  But actually it's not.  The pulses are all unidirectional. The cap charges up..   :(


Scotty.  The tank is six inches diameter and eight inches long, laying on its side.  Not a lot of room for floats and if I could get them in there there wouldn't be a lot of room for the water! :)

Keith Cress
kcress - http://www.flaminsystems.com

RE: Water Water Everywhere or It Makes No Sense.

Keith,


Google fossil aquarian for some examples of probes used in industrial boilers. They're not enormous. Given the high purity of industrial boiler feedwater I believe these are capacitive rather than resistive although someone else might refute this.
  

----------------------------------
  
If we learn from our mistakes I'm getting a great education!
 

RE: Water Water Everywhere or It Makes No Sense.

(OP)
Thanks Scotty.

Expensive stuff that!

I just got it working!  I switched C27 and R38 to 10M Ohm resistors.  C25 went to 1000pF.

This creates a voltage divider that gives about 12V to the input of the sense comparator.  Water across the input drops that voltage well below the trigger 4V.  That includes reverse osmosis water.

To head off electrolysis I excite to check, for only 3ms a second.

Keith Cress
kcress - http://www.flaminsystems.com

RE: Water Water Everywhere or It Makes No Sense.

"To head off electrolysis I excite to check, for only 3ms a second."

Yup, it will help.  You may still get some plating over time, and that may affect the overall path resistance, but it's slow and manageable, and descaling the boiler periodically should return things to the design condition.

We have a 15 foot water tank inside the building now, with 1 foot clearance between top and ceiling.  Conductance depth probes, level checked for 10 seconds, once per hour.  Home-built probes (1/8" brass wire fed thru 1/4" o.d. poly or PFA tubing, and the pair fed thru a Swagelok compression fitting.  Works like a charm.

RE: Water Water Everywhere or It Makes No Sense.

Looking at possible failure modes
 Quoting Btrueblood
  " descaling the boiler periodically should return things to the design condition. "

 Are there any consequences for detecting FAKE Emptyness  ?

The solution looks good ie Few moving parts to Fur up !
 

RE: Water Water Everywhere or It Makes No Sense.

(OP)
Well like the usual boiler there's a thermal/pressure relief valve.  So if everything goes pear shaped the water starts flowing down the drain.

Keith Cress
kcress - http://www.flaminsystems.com

RE: Water Water Everywhere or It Makes No Sense.

...assuming you remembered to hook up the drain pipe, otherwise it's a big puddle on the floor.

RE: Water Water Everywhere or It Makes No Sense.

A wet and dry hoover can help with these teething problems ,

and sometimes help defy gravity !

   

 

RE: Water Water Everywhere or It Makes No Sense.

There are commercial well level probes on the market that use a transformer putting out about 300 volts and a relay.
The combination of low current and AC avoids electrolysis. Cheap easy and dependable in suitable applications.

Bill
--------------------
"Why not the best?"
Jimmy Carter

RE: Water Water Everywhere or It Makes No Sense.

(OP)
I got it going. I took a DMM and cranked up the Ohms range. Then I "probed" tap water, filtered water, and reverse osmosis water.  All of them were below 1.2M ohms.  So I altered the above frontend slightly to be an ohmmeter feeding a comparator.  I ditched the whole AC angle as a waste of time because I only turn on the excitation for 1ms every once and a while.

Let it try to plate out... Mwahahahaha!!

Keith Cress
kcress - http://www.flaminsystems.com

RE: Water Water Everywhere or It Makes No Sense.

I'm just curious because I've wanted to do the same test - what resistance did you measure for your tap, filtered, and RO water?  

John D

RE: Water Water Everywhere or It Makes No Sense.

"The combination of low current and AC avoids electrolysis"

I really think that is crapola.  From a chemistry standpoint, once the metal ions leave the solid cathode and become aqueous ions, even if for a few milliseconds, they aren't gonna go back to the cathode in the same order as they left, and other ionic species are just as likely (possibly more so) to plate before the metal ions you wanted.  Otherwise, why do battery plates in wet-cell batteries deteriorate with increasing charge cycles?  Smoked's method is really the best, only sample the probes for a brief moment, when necessary, and leave the current off in the between times.

RE: Water Water Everywhere or It Makes No Sense.

I may have misspoken. I meant to say that issues based on electrolysis are largely avoided.
See
 http://www.gemssensors.com/content.aspx?id=2258
I have used these and similar units from other manufactureres for water level control.

Bill
--------------------
"Why not the best?"
Jimmy Carter

RE: Water Water Everywhere or It Makes No Sense.

(OP)
zapped; I got:
~700k with tap
~860k with filtered
1.4M with RO.


btrueblood;  I couldn't agree more.
Once while staying in a cabin at Yosemite's Ahwahnee Hotel I needed to heat some chicken soup. No hot plate.

All I had was a pot and... well nothing. I used a coat hanger I cut in half.  I scraped the shellac off the ends and poked them in an outlet bent appropriately to sit in the pot without touching bottom.  Then I added the soup.

There was some satisfying sizzling going on so I left it briefly.

On checking the progress I found that the soup had turned a brilliant lime green.  I mean  b r i l l i a n t!  Like glow-in-the-dark brilliant!   That was AC and certainly something had gone into solution never to return..

And No! I didn't eat it. I may be crazy but I'm stoopid not.

 

Keith Cress
kcress - http://www.flaminsystems.com

RE: Water Water Everywhere or It Makes No Sense.

I'm thinking the shellac and all of that soup's salt had some fun times together...

Dan - Owner
http://www.Hi-TecDesigns.com

RE: Water Water Everywhere or It Makes No Sense.

(OP)
I think the salt and the Iron in the coat hanger?

Keith Cress
kcress - http://www.flaminsystems.com

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources